GC022 Visual Spot Diagnoses - Survival Guide For Primary Care
A clinical reference covering key dermatological and physical examination findings that can be rapidly identified on sight to aid diagnosis and management in the primary care setting.
Visual Spot Diagnoses – Survival Guide for Primary Care
Lecture Map
This lecture trains you to look at a patient, recognise an abnormality, systematically describe it, and match it to a diagnosis – the fundamental skill of "spot diagnosis" in primary care. In an exam, you will be shown a clinical photograph and asked to identify the condition, describe the lesion, list differentials, or outline initial management. The lecture sweeps through eyes → mouth → skin → extremities → nails → general appearance, covering the most common and the most dangerous "can't-miss" diagnoses a family doctor encounters. [1]
Diagnose common "spot diagnoses" in primary care – distinguish the abnormal from the normal and describe the abnormality.
Differentiate lesions with similar appearances – look for the pathognomonic sign.
Identify uncommon but important "spot diagnoses."
Core Framework: How to Approach ANY Spot Diagnosis
FIRST: Look at your patient and find out what he/she is trying to show you! [1]
This sounds obvious, but the lecture hammers this home because students often jump to a diagnosis without first describing what they see. The systematic approach is:
| Descriptor | What to Comment On | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Location(s), distribution | Unilateral vs bilateral, dermatomal, sun-exposed, flexural, extensor | Distribution narrows DDx enormously (e.g., dermatomal = herpes zoster) |
| Shape | Round, oval, annular, linear, irregular | Annular = tinea/granuloma annulare; irregular = melanoma |
| Colour | Erythematous, violaceous, pigmented, hypopigmented, pearly | Pearly + telangiectasia = BCC; variegated colour = melanoma |
| Surface / border | Smooth, rough, scaly, rolled, everted, well-demarcated | Rolled border = BCC; everted border = SCC; well-demarcated + silvery scale = psoriasis |
| Size | Measure in mm/cm | Diameter > 6 mm is one ABCDE melanoma criterion |
| Consistency | Firm, soft, fluctuant, hard, rubbery | Hard + fixed = malignancy concern |
| Associated signs | Discharge, crusting, scaling, bleeding, excoriation | Crusting/honey-coloured = impetigo; bleeding on touch = malignancy |
| Pathognomonic sign | Specific feature clinching diagnosis | Wickham striae = lichen planus; Auspitz sign = psoriasis |
Then confirm with history (see below). [1]
The Golden Rule of Spot Diagnosis
Describe BEFORE you diagnose. Examiners award marks for a structured description – even if your diagnosis is wrong, a good description earns partial credit. Use the mnemonic "Lo-Sh-Co-Su-Si-Co-As-Pa" (Location, Shape, Colour, Surface/border, Size, Consistency, Associated signs, Pathognomonic sign).
After the visual assessment, take a focused history: [1]
| History Domain | Key Questions | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Other symptoms | Pain, itch, discharge, fever, systemic symptoms | Painful vesicles in a dermatome = shingles; painless red eye = subconjunctival haemorrhage |
| Progression | Acute vs chronic, getting bigger? Response to previous treatment? | Rapidly growing nodule = SCC or keratoacanthoma; slow = BCC |
| Precipitating / perpetuating factors | Sun exposure, new drug, trauma, stress | Drug → fixed drug eruption; sun → actinic keratosis |
| Risk factors | Immunosuppression, DM, atopy, smoking | Immunosuppressed → higher risk skin cancers, opportunistic infections |
| Family history | Atopy, psoriasis, skin cancer syndromes | Strong FHx of melanoma → lower threshold for biopsy |
| ICE | Ideas, Concerns, Expectations | Patient-centred care – fundamental to FM approach |
ICE in Spot Diagnosis – Exam Favourite
Ideas, Concerns, and Expectations should be explored even for a "simple" skin lesion. A patient may fear cancer (concern), think it's just a mole (idea), and want immediate removal (expectation). Addressing ICE is a core FM competency tested in OSCEs. [1]
Section-by-Section Spot Diagnoses
A. THE EYE
| Diagnosis | Key Features | Pathognomonic / Distinguishing Sign | Management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chalazion (meibomian cyst) | Painless, firm, round nodule in the eyelid, pointing towards conjunctival side | Non-tender, chronic, no acute inflammation | Warm compress; if persistent, incision & curettage (from conjunctival side) |
| Hordeolum (stye) – external | Acute, tender, red swelling at eyelid margin (lash follicle / gland of Zeis/Moll) | Painful, points externally | Warm compress and lid hygiene; do not squeeze. Antibiotics are not routine unless there is associated infection |
| Hordeolum – internal | Acute infection of meibomian gland, more painful, points internally | Often larger, may progress to chalazion | Similar to external; consider referral if recurrent |
| Xanthelasma | Yellowish plaques on medial upper/lower eyelid | Bilateral, symmetrical | Check lipid profile; cosmetic excision if desired |
The paired photographs show xanthelasma at the eyelids and tendon xanthomata over the hand extensor tendons. Together they are a visual cue to assess for inherited or severe dyslipidaemia and obtain a lipid profile (which need not routinely be fasting). [1]
Why it matters: Chalazion vs stye is a classic exam discriminator. A chalazion is a granulomatous reaction to trapped meibomian secretion (chronic, non-tender), while a stye is an acute bacterial infection (tender, red, warm). If a chalazion recurs in the same spot in an elderly patient, consider sebaceous gland carcinoma – a rare but important "can't-miss." [1][7]
Think about:
- Periorbital cellulitis (preseptal) – infection anterior to orbital septum; eyelid erythema, swelling, warmth, but no proptosis, no ophthalmoplegia, no vision change
- Orbital cellulitis – infection posterior to septum; proptosis, restricted eye movements, reduced vision, pain on eye movement → ophthalmic emergency, needs IV antibiotics + CT orbit
- Allergic oedema (angioedema) – bilateral, non-tender, associated with urticaria elsewhere
- Blepharitis – chronic lid margin inflammation, crusting at lash bases, bilateral
This is one of the highest-yield sections. The lecture distinguishes:
Bilateral red eye with discharge:
- Viral conjunctivitis – watery discharge, follicles on tarsal conjunctiva, preauricular lymphadenopathy, often post-URTI. Adenovirus most common. [7]
- Allergic conjunctivitis – itchy, watery, papillae on tarsal conjunctiva, bilateral, atopic history
- Bacterial conjunctivitis – mucopurulent discharge, morning crusting, one eye then the other
Unilateral red eye with minimal discharge, mild tearing:
Ask: Pain? Loss of vision? Photophobia? [1]
This trio of questions is critical because they separate benign from sight-threatening:
| Diagnosis | Pain | Vision Loss | Photophobia | Key Sign | Pupil |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subconjunctival haemorrhage | No | No | No | Flat, bright red area obscuring sclera, sharply demarcated | Normal |
| Episcleritis | Mild discomfort | No | No | Sectoral redness, blanches with phenylephrine 2.5% | Normal |
| Scleritis | Severe, deep, boring | Possible | Possible | Violaceous hue, does NOT blanch with phenylephrine | Normal |
| Anterior uveitis (iritis) | Yes (aching) | Yes (mild) | Yes | Ciliary flush (circumcorneal injection), cells/flare in AC, small/irregular pupil | Small, irregular |
| Acute angle-closure glaucoma | Severe | Yes (markedly) | Yes | Fixed mid-dilated pupil, hazy cornea, ↑IOP | Fixed, mid-dilated |
| Corneal abrasion / ulcer | Yes (sharp, FB) | Yes | Yes | Fluorescein staining positive, white infiltrate if ulcer | Normal |
Unilateral red eye associated with: Loss of vision (acute), periorbital pain, headache, malaise, nausea/vomiting → Think acute angle-closure glaucoma (AACG). [1]
Read the photographs before naming the condition:
- A sharply demarcated pool of blood under clear conjunctiva, with the rest of the eye quiet, is a subconjunctival haemorrhage.
- Thick yellow discharge matting the lashes supports bacterial conjunctivitis; watery bilateral injection is more typical of viral or allergic conjunctivitis.
- A localised sector of superficial redness with preserved vision and little pain supports episcleritis.
- Diffuse/circumcorneal injection, corneal haze and a fixed mid-dilated pupil are the visual danger pattern of acute angle-closure glaucoma.
Why AACG presents this way: The peripheral iris bows forward and physically blocks the trabecular meshwork → aqueous humour cannot drain → IOP rises rapidly (often > 40 mmHg) → corneal oedema (hazy cornea) → pain, halos around lights, nausea/vomiting (vagal response to pain). The pupil is mid-dilated and fixed because the iris sphincter is ischaemic. [7][8]
Subconjunctival Haemorrhage – Past Paper Favourite
A 70-year-old female on DOACs presents with a painless, bright red eye, no visual change, normal pupils. Diagnosis = subconjunctival haemorrhage. Key: completely painless, no vision change. Check BP, review anticoagulation. Self-limiting in 1-2 weeks. [14]
Red-Eye Safety Net
Do not rely on the photograph alone. Pain, photophobia, reduced vision, severe headache/nausea, unequal pupils, contact-lens use, trauma or chemical exposure require urgent same-day eye assessment. [16]
B. THE MOUTH
| Diagnosis | Features | Pathognomonic |
|---|---|---|
| Herpes labialis (cold sore) | Grouped vesicles on erythematous base at vermilion border, preceded by tingling/burning (prodrome) | Vesicles → crust; recurrent in same spot; HSV-1 |
| Angular cheilitis (angular stomatitis) | Erythema, fissuring, crusting at mouth corners | Often bilateral; associated with denture use, drooling, iron/B12/folate deficiency, Candida or Staph infection |
| Aphthous ulcer (on lip mucosa) | Painful, round/oval ulcer with yellow-grey base and erythematous halo, on non-keratinised mucosa | Recurrent; consider Behçet's if recurrent + genital ulcers |
Why herpes labialis recurs in the same spot: HSV-1 establishes latency in the trigeminal ganglion. Reactivation sends virus along the same nerve branch to the same dermatome area, producing vesicles at the same location. Triggers include UV light, stress, immunosuppression, fever. [1]
- Mucocele – painless, translucent, bluish, dome-shaped swelling on lower lip or floor of mouth; caused by rupture of minor salivary gland duct → mucin extravasation. Fluctuant.
- Ranula – a large mucocele specifically on the floor of the mouth (sublingual gland)
- Fibroma (irritation fibroma) – firm, smooth, sessile nodule on buccal mucosa along bite line; due to chronic trauma
- Oral leukoplakia – white patch that cannot be scraped off → premalignant; needs biopsy
- Oral candidiasis (thrush) – white patches that CAN be scraped off revealing red base; in immunocompromised, denture users, inhaled steroid users
The slide's important visual contrast: the smooth, translucent lower-lip dome is a mucocele, whereas the irregular exophytic/ulcerated lesion on the lateral tongue is suspicious for oral squamous cell carcinoma. A persistent indurated lump, unexplained ulcer, mixed red-white change, spontaneous bleeding or cervical node should not be labelled “aphthous” from appearance alone—arrange urgent dental/oral-maxillofacial assessment and tissue diagnosis. Current NICE guidance uses unexplained oral ulceration lasting more than 3 weeks as a suspected-cancer referral trigger; follow the local pathway. [17]
White Patch Discrimination
Leukoplakia cannot be scraped off; oral thrush can be scraped off. This is a classic exam discriminator, but “leukoplakia” is a clinical description rather than a histological diagnosis. Persistent or suspicious white/red lesions require specialist assessment and usually biopsy; do not wait for a rigid time threshold if there is induration, ulceration, bleeding or a neck node. [1][17]
- Acute pharyngitis / tonsillitis – erythematous pharynx ± exudates; viral (most common) vs bacterial (GAS – Centor criteria)
- Peritonsillar abscess (quinsy) – unilateral tonsillar swelling with uvular deviation to contralateral side, trismus, "hot potato" voice, drooling → needs urgent drainage
- Hand-foot-mouth disease – vesicles/ulcers on soft palate + hands/feet; Coxsackievirus A16 or EV71; children
- Herpangina – vesicles/ulcers on posterior palate/tonsillar pillars only (no hand/foot involvement); Coxsackievirus
Two white-throat photographs on the slide are not the same lesion:
- Oral candidiasis produces multiple soft white plaques over an erythematous palate/uvula and can usually be wiped away, leaving an erythematous or bleeding surface.
- A tonsillolith is a discrete white-yellow concretion sitting in a tonsillar crypt, often associated with halitosis or foreign-body sensation rather than a diffuse removable coating.
- Dental abscess – localized swelling, tender, may have draining sinus; refer to dentist
- Gingivitis – swollen, erythematous, bleeding gums; associated with poor hygiene; reversible
- Periodontitis – advanced gingivitis with loss of attachment and bone; pockets > 3 mm
- Epulis – localized gingival overgrowth; differential includes pyogenic granuloma, fibrous epulis, peripheral giant cell granuloma
- Drug-induced gingival hyperplasia – phenytoin, ciclosporin, nifedipine
Visual discriminator: gingivitis follows the gingival margin diffusely—red, swollen, shiny tissue that bleeds easily—whereas a focal punched-out ulcer, draining point or local fluctuant swelling should prompt a different diagnosis (ulcerative/infective disease or dental abscess) and dental assessment.
C. THE SKIN
Acne Vulgaris:
- Pathogenesis: ↑sebum production (androgens) → follicular hyperkeratinization → C. acnes colonization → inflammation
- Lesions: open comedones (blackheads), closed comedones (whiteheads), papules, pustules, nodules, cysts
- Distribution: face, chest, back (sebaceous gland-rich areas)
- Grading: mild (comedonal), moderate (papulopustular), severe (nodulocystic)
Differentiate acne from: [1]
| Condition | Key Differentiator |
|---|---|
| Rosacea | Middle-aged, central face, telangiectasia, NO comedones, flushing triggers; may have ocular symptoms |
| Perioral dermatitis | Papules/pustules around mouth sparing vermilion border; often triggered by topical steroids |
| Folliculitis | Follicle-based pustules; not limited to face; may be bacterial, fungal (pityrosporum) or chemical |
| Acne vulgaris | Comedones present (open/closed); seborrhoea; adolescents |
No Comedones = Not Acne
The presence of comedones is the hallmark of acne vulgaris. If a facial rash has papules and pustules but no comedones, think rosacea or perioral dermatitis instead. [1]
This section covers seborrhoeic dermatitis vs psoriasis vs eczema vs tinea – a massively important differential.
Seborrhoeic Dermatitis:
- Greasy, yellowish scales on erythematous base
- Distribution: scalp, eyebrows, nasolabial folds, behind ears, central chest
- Caused by Malassezia yeast → inflammatory response
- In infants = "cradle cap"
- Treatment: antifungal shampoo (ketoconazole), mild topical steroid
The facial photograph shows this distribution particularly well: subtle greasy erythema and scale cluster around the nasolabial folds, alae and central face, rather than forming sharply bordered plaques.
Psoriasis (covered on body/scalp slides too [1]):
- Well-demarcated, raised, erythematous plaques with silvery-white scales
- Distribution: extensor surfaces (elbows, knees), scalp, sacrum, nails
- Pathognomonic: Auspitz sign (pinpoint bleeding on removal of scale – due to thin epidermis over dilated capillaries)
- Koebner phenomenon (lesions at sites of trauma)
- Nail changes: pitting, onycholysis, oil-drop sign, subungual hyperkeratosis
On the scalp, the pictured plaque is sharply demarcated with thick white scale and extends just beyond the hairline (corona psoriatica); on the elbow, the same morphology appears on an extensor surface. These two views link distribution to diagnosis.
Eczema (Atopic Dermatitis):
- Itchy, poorly-demarcated, erythematous patches with vesicles, weeping, crusting (acute) or lichenification (chronic)
- Distribution varies by age: infants (face, extensor), children/adults (flexural)
- Associated with atopic triad (eczema, asthma, allergic rhinitis)
Tinea (Dermatophyte Infection):
- Annular, scaly patch with active, raised border and central clearing ("ringworm")
- Can affect face (tinea faciei), scalp (tinea capitis), body (tinea corporis), groin (tinea cruris), feet (tinea pedis)
- KOH preparation shows hyphae → confirms fungal infection
| Feature | Seb Derm | Psoriasis | Eczema | Tinea |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scale type | Greasy, yellow | Silvery-white, thick | Fine, may crust | Fine, at advancing edge |
| Border | Poorly defined | Well-defined | Poorly defined | Well-defined, annular |
| Distribution | Sebaceous areas | Extensor, scalp | Flexural | Anywhere, asymmetric |
| Itch | Mild | Mild-moderate | Severe | Moderate |
| KOH | Negative | Negative | Negative | Positive (hyphae) |
| Auspitz sign | No | Yes | No | No |
The photographs show an eczematous reaction pattern and then direct the examiner to look for scabies at the fingers:
- Acute/subacute eczema: poorly demarcated erythema with fine scale, small vesicles, crusting and excoriations.
- Chronic eczema: rubbing produces lichenification—thickened skin with exaggerated skin markings.
- Discoid (nummular) eczema: multiple coin-shaped, uniformly scaly plaques. Unlike tinea, scale is distributed through the plaque rather than concentrated at a raised advancing edge with central clearing.
- Scabies: intensely pruritic papules and short, thin, serpiginous burrows, especially in finger webs and on the sides of fingers/wrists. Nocturnal itch and similarly itchy close contacts are powerful discriminators; examine the umbilicus, waist, buttocks and genital region as appropriate.
Pompholyx remains a finger differential: look for numerous deep, clear “tapioca” vesicles on the sides of fingers/palms, usually without a scabetic burrow. A unilateral scaly hand with bilateral tinea pedis (“two feet, one hand”) instead supports dermatophyte infection.
The single annular lesion on this slide is tinea corporis, not urticaria:
- Annular plaque with a raised, scaly advancing edge and relative central clearing
- Often asymmetric and slowly enlarging; itch is common
- Scrape scale from the active edge for microscopy/culture when the diagnosis is uncertain
- Discoid eczema scales across the whole plaque and is less likely to show central clearing; granuloma annulare has a smooth, non-scaly ring of papules; an urticarial wheal is smooth, migratory and each lesion usually fades within 24 hours
Pityriasis (tinea) versicolor (slide 25): numerous hypopigmented, hyperpigmented or pink finely scaling macules coalesce over the upper chest, shoulders and back. The subtle “branny” scale distinguishes it from vitiligo (chalk-white, no scale), while the lack of an active annular border distinguishes it from tinea corporis. It is caused by Malassezia rather than a dermatophyte.
Herpes Zoster (Shingles):
- Unilateral, dermatomal distribution of grouped vesicles on erythematous base
- Preceded by prodromal pain (burning, tingling) in the same dermatome
- Pathognomonic: does not cross the midline (stays in one dermatome)
- Caused by reactivation of VZV in dorsal root ganglion
- Complications: post-herpetic neuralgia (PHN), herpes zoster ophthalmicus (V1 → Hutchinson sign = vesicle on nose tip → corneal involvement likely), disseminated zoster in immunosuppressed
- Treatment: antivirals (aciclovir, valaciclovir) within 72 hours of rash onset; analgesics
The illustrated diagnosis is chickenpox (varicella), not pityriasis rosea:
- Scattered papules, vesicles, and crusted lesions in different stages ("crops") on trunk, face, and limbs
- A mild fever/malaise prodrome may occur; the generalised rash is pruritic
- High-yield discriminator: lesions in different stages of evolution simultaneously (macule → papule → superficial vesicle → crust), concentrated on the trunk
- Caused by primary VZV infection; highly contagious
- Complications include secondary bacterial skin infection in children and pneumonia in adults; severity is greater in pregnancy and immunocompromise. [1][18]
Molluscum Contagiosum:
- Multiple discrete, smooth, dome-shaped, pearly/flesh-coloured papules with central umbilication
- Caused by poxvirus; spread by direct contact or fomites
- Common in children and immunocompromised adults
- Self-limiting (months to years); treatment if desired: cryotherapy, curettage, topical agents [1]
Do not confuse the two umbilicated rashes: molluscum papules are firm, pearly and usually asymptomatic without a febrile crop; varicella vesicles are fragile, inflamed, pruritic and occur at multiple stages. Deep-seated painful umbilicated lesions with lymphadenopathy require a broader infectious differential.
This is the melanoma vs benign naevus discrimination section.
The photograph is deliberately difficult: a dark, raised, keratotic lesion can be a benign seborrhoeic keratosis, but irregular outline, asymmetry or evolution keeps melanoma in the differential. “Stuck-on” texture is reassuring only when the whole lesion is convincingly typical; dermoscopy and biopsy—not visual confidence alone—settle an equivocal changing lesion.
ABCDE criteria for melanoma:
| Criterion | Benign Naevus | Melanoma |
|---|---|---|
| Asymmetry | Symmetric | Asymmetric |
| Border | Regular, smooth | Irregular, notched |
| Colour | Uniform (one shade) | Variegated (multiple shades) |
| Diameter | Usually < 6 mm | Usually > 6 mm |
| Evolution | Stable over time | Changing (size, shape, colour) |
- "Ugly duckling" sign: the mole that looks different from all the patient's other moles → suspicious [11]
- Subtypes (from supporting notes [11]): superficial spreading (most common in Caucasians), nodular (rapidly growing dome, may be amelanotic), lentigo maligna (elderly, sun-damaged), acral lentiginous (most common in HK/Asian populations) – palms, soles, subungual
In Hong Kong / Asian populations, acral lentiginous melanoma is the most common subtype. Look for irregular pigmentation on palms, soles, or under the nail. [1][11]
The pictured facial lesion has the classic nodular BCC pattern: a shiny translucent/pearly papule with surface telangiectasia and focal central crust or ulceration. Pigment may be present, especially in darker skin. DDx of a pigmented facial lesion:
- Seborrhoeic keratosis – "stuck on" appearance, waxy surface, horn cysts; benign; most common benign skin tumour in elderly
- Dermatosis papulosa nigra – variant of seborrhoeic keratosis; small, dark papules on face of darker-skinned individuals
- Pigmented BCC – pearly edge, telangiectasia, pigmentation common in Asians [11]
- Melanoma – ABCDE criteria apply
Bleeding/crusting is a warning sign, not a diagnosis. Describe whether the lesion is pearly and rolled (BCC), keratotic/indurated or everted (SCC/keratoacanthoma), or bright-red and friable (pyogenic granuloma), then arrange tissue diagnosis for a suspicious lesion. Think malignancy or vascular lesion:
- Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) – indurated nodule/plaque with hyperkeratotic or ulcerated surface, everted edge, contact bleeding; sun-exposed areas; risk factors: UV, immunosuppression, chronic wounds (Marjolin ulcer) [11]
- Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) – rodent ulcer with rolled pearly edge, telangiectasia, central ulceration; most common skin cancer; locally invasive, rarely metastasises [11]
- Pyogenic granuloma – rapidly growing, friable, bright red nodule that bleeds easily; benign vascular proliferation; often at sites of trauma
- Keratoacanthoma – rapidly growing dome-shaped nodule with central keratin plug; may mimic SCC; some consider it a well-differentiated SCC variant
| Feature | BCC | SCC | Melanoma |
|---|---|---|---|
| Border | Rolled, pearly | Everted | Irregular |
| Surface | Smooth, telangiectasia | Hyperkeratotic/ulcerated | Variable pigmentation |
| Growth | Slow | Moderate | Variable (nodular = fast) |
| Metastasis | Extremely rare | Yes (especially if > 2 cm, poorly differentiated) | High risk |
| Most common site | Face (medial canthus) | Sun-exposed (face, hands) | Acral in Asians |
| Asian appearance | Often pigmented (not pearly/pale) | Red-brown | Dark, irregular |
D. THE EXTREMITIES
| Diagnosis | Features | Key Point |
|---|---|---|
| Paronychia (acute) | Painful, red, swollen nail fold; may have pus collection | Most common: S. aureus; I&D if abscess; oral antibiotics |
| Paronychia (chronic) | Boggy, non-tender nail fold; intermittent flares | Often Candida; associated with wet work (dishwashers, bartenders) |
| Herpetic whitlow | Painful grouped vesicles on fingertip | HSV-1 or HSV-2; do NOT incise (risk of secondary bacterial infection and viral dissemination); self-limiting or aciclovir |
| Verruca vulgaris (viral wart) | Firm, rough-surfaced, skin-coloured papule on fingertip/periungual area; may have black dots (thrombosed capillaries) | HPV-induced; cryotherapy, salicylic acid; distinguish from herpetic whitlow (wart is non-tender, no vesicles) |
| Felon | Intense throbbing pain in fingertip pulp; swollen, tense | Closed space infection of finger pad; needs urgent I&D to prevent osteomyelitis |
Herpetic Whitlow vs Felon
Do NOT incise a herpetic whitlow! It looks like a felon but has vesicles. Incision risks superinfection and viral spread. A felon has a tense, uniformly swollen pulp without vesicles and needs urgent surgical drainage. [1]
DDx of painful, swollen finger joints:
- Rheumatoid arthritis – symmetrical, MCP and PIP joints, morning stiffness > 30 min, swan-neck/boutonnière deformities in chronic disease
- Osteoarthritis – DIP (Heberden nodes) and PIP (Bouchard nodes), bony swelling, first CMC joint
- Gouty tophi – firm, white/yellow deposits near joints; associated with chronic gout
- Psoriatic arthritis – asymmetric, may involve DIP, dactylitis ("sausage digit"), nail pitting, associated skin psoriasis
- Trigger finger – painful clicking/locking of finger in flexion; thickened A1 pulley
Read the three hand photographs as patterns:
- Bilateral MCP/PIP synovitis with ulnar drift supports chronic rheumatoid arthritis; DIP disease is unusual.
- Hard bony enlargement at DIP/PIP joints supports osteoarthritis rather than soft, boggy synovitis.
- A whole swollen digit (dactylitis) together with a scaly plaque or nail pitting supports psoriatic arthritis.
- Mallet finger – drooping DIP; extensor tendon rupture at distal phalanx; cannot actively extend DIP; caused by forced flexion injury (e.g., ball striking fingertip)
- Ganglion cyst ("There's a lump over the back of my hand") – firm, non-tender, fluctuant, transilluminant swelling, most commonly dorsum of wrist; benign, from joint capsule or tendon sheath; treatment: reassurance, aspiration, or excision if symptomatic [1]
- Plantar fasciitis – heel pain worst with first steps in the morning; tenderness at medial calcaneal tubercle
- Hallux valgus (bunion) – lateral deviation of great toe with medial bony prominence at 1st MTP; may be painful with shoe wear
- Gout – acutely red, hot, swollen 1st MTP (podagra); exquisitely tender; monosodium urate crystals (negatively birefringent under polarised microscopy)
- Ingrown toenail (onychocryptosis) – nail edge grows into periungual skin; pain, erythema, granulation tissue; great toe
- Verruca plantaris (plantar wart) – HPV-induced; firm, hyperkeratotic, may have black dots (thrombosed capillaries); painful on lateral compression (vs callus which hurts on direct pressure)
The slide places callus, plantar wart and corn side by side:
| Finding | Surface / skin lines | Pain pattern | Typical site |
|---|---|---|---|
| Callus | Broad, even hyperkeratosis; dermatoglyphics continue through it | Direct vertical pressure | Diffuse pressure-bearing area |
| Plantar wart | Rough focus that interrupts skin lines; pinpoint black/red dots after paring | Side-to-side compression | Any plantar site, often clustered |
| Corn (clavus) | Small, sharply circumscribed lesion with a central translucent hard core | Direct pressure over the core | Bony prominence or between toes (soft corn may be macerated) |
Avoid paring a suspected wart/corn in patients with impaired sensation, peripheral arterial disease or high-risk diabetic feet; uncertainty or ulceration warrants podiatry/foot assessment.
- Tinea pedis (athlete's foot) – interdigital maceration, scaling, fissuring between toes (especially 4th-5th web space); may be vesicular or moccasin type
- Pitted keratolysis – multiple small pits on sole; bacterial (Corynebacterium, Kytococcus); associated with hyperhidrosis and occlusive footwear; classically malodorous
- Hyperhidrosis – excessive sweating → secondary bacterial overgrowth → odour
E1. "Look at my nails" [1]
Nail Anatomy Recap (useful for describing nail findings precisely) [1]:
- Nail plate – the hard keratinised structure
- Nail bed – tissue beneath the nail plate
- Nail matrix – proximal growth zone (damage → permanent nail dystrophy)
- Lunula – visible pale crescent of the distal matrix
- Proximal nail fold (eponychium) – skin fold overlying the matrix
- Cuticle – thin skin at the junction of proximal nail fold and nail plate
- Lateral nail fold – skin bordering the nail plate laterally
| Nail Finding | Description | Associated Conditions |
|---|---|---|
| Onychomycosis | Thickened, discoloured (yellow-white), crumbly nail with distal/lateral onycholysis and subungual debris | Confirm fungal infection with microscopy/culture or another validated mycological test before systemic treatment; oral terbinafine is commonly used when appropriate |
| Nail pitting | Small depressions on nail surface | Psoriasis (most common association), alopecia areata, eczema |
| Onycholysis | Separation of nail plate from nail bed (distal) | Psoriasis, fungal infection, thyrotoxicosis, trauma |
| Oil-drop sign | Yellow-brown translucent discolouration under nail | Psoriasis |
| Subungual hyperkeratosis | Thickening of nail bed keratin | Psoriasis, onychomycosis |
| Beau's lines | Transverse ridges/grooves | Severe systemic illness (reflects temporary arrest of nail growth) |
| Koilonychia (spoon nails) | Concave nail | Iron deficiency anaemia |
| Clubbing | Increased angle between nail fold and nail plate ( > 180°), fluctuation of nail bed | Lung cancer, bronchiectasis, cyanotic heart disease, IBD, cirrhosis |
| Splinter haemorrhages | Linear, dark-red streaks in nail bed | Infective endocarditis (but also trauma – most common cause) |
| Terry's nails | Proximal 2/3 white, distal 1/3 pink | Liver cirrhosis, heart failure, DM |
| Lindsay's nails (half-and-half) | Proximal white, distal brown | Chronic kidney disease |
| Melanonychia | Longitudinal brown-black streak | Benign (common in dark-skinned), but consider subungual melanoma if irregular, Hutchinson sign (pigment on proximal nail fold) |
What the nail photographs are teaching:
- Yellow-brown distal/lateral change, crumbling, onycholysis and subungual debris form the visual pattern of onychomycosis, but psoriasis and trauma can mimic it—confirm before oral antifungal therapy.
- Multiple pinpoint depressions are nail pitting (classically psoriasis); one or more transverse depressions across the full plate are Beau's lines, which date a temporary arrest of matrix growth.
- Nail pitting is a clue rather than a diagnosis: correlate with scalp/extensor plaques, joint symptoms and other nails.
F. MORE CUES – GENERAL APPEARANCE
These photographs are not a syndromic-facies quiz. They reinforce that facial expression is part of the first-look assessment: does the patient appear in pain, frightened, guarded, breathless, confused, withdrawn or acutely unwell? Use that observation to open a respectful question and complete the clinical assessment. A single expression cannot diagnose depression, cognitive impairment, pain severity or capacity.
In an OSCE, verbalise the observation without judgement: “The patient appears distressed/guarded; I would assess pain, vital signs, mental state and immediate safety, then ask what is worrying them.”
The images show a wheelchair user and a child with Down syndrome. The clinical lesson is to identify and offer reasonable adjustments, not to infer diagnosis, cognition or decision-making capacity from appearance.
- Ask the patient how they prefer to communicate and what assistance they need; speak to the patient directly, even when a carer is present.
- Establish the carer's role and obtain consent before sharing information. Capacity is decision-specific and must be assessed, not assumed.
- Consider physical access, positioning, sensory needs, extra consultation time, easy-read material or an interpreter/communication aid.
- Recognising Down syndrome can prompt syndrome-related preventive care, but the immediate encounter still begins with the patient's presenting concern and priorities.
| Related Lecture | Connection |
|---|---|
| GC 125 – The Red Eye [7] | Detailed management of red eye causes; acute angle-closure glaucoma emergency pathway |
| GC 126 – Trauma and Ocular Emergency | Foreign body, chemical injury, globe rupture |
| GC 122 – Chronic Visual Loss [3] | Cataract, glaucoma, DR, AMD – gradual visual loss; complements this lecture's acute red eye section |
| CFB OPHTH01 – Common Eye Diseases | Conjunctivitis types, glaucoma classification |
| Derm General Clerkship Part 1 [4] | Detailed dermatology morphology, psoriasis, eczema, skin cancer |
| CFB FM02 – Differentiating Normal from Abnormal [2] | Framework for deciding when a presentation is "abnormal" |
| GC 019 – Family in FM [5] | System 1 thinking / pattern recognition in primary care; spot diagnoses as examples |
| Trap | How to Avoid |
|---|---|
| Diagnosing rosacea as acne | Look for comedones – absent in rosacea |
| Diagnosing eczema when it's tinea | Check for annular border + central clearing; "two feet one hand" = tinea |
| Confusing episcleritis with scleritis | Episcleritis: mild discomfort, blanches with phenylephrine. Scleritis: severe boring pain, does NOT blanch, violaceous |
| Calling all nail thickening "fungal" | Psoriasis causes pitting, onycholysis, oil-drop sign; onychomycosis = subungual debris + discolouration; confirm with KOH |
| Missing melanoma because "it's just a mole" | Use ABCDE + ugly duckling sign; in Asians, check acral sites |
| Incising a herpetic whitlow | Vesicles = viral → do NOT incise; treat with antivirals |
| Forgetting to check for orbital cellulitis signs | Proptosis + ophthalmoplegia + vision loss = posterior to septum = emergency |
High Yield Summary
- Describe before diagnosing: location/distribution, morphology, colour, surface/border, size, consistency and associated signs. [1]
- Red-eye triage: pain, photophobia or reduced vision overrides a reassuring label and requires urgent assessment. [1][16]
- AACG: severe painful red eye, headache/nausea, hazy cornea and fixed mid-dilated pupil = ophthalmic emergency. [1]
- Acne vs rosacea: comedones support acne; central erythema/telangiectasia without comedones supports rosacea. [1]
- Scaly plaques: psoriasis is sharply bordered on extensor/scalp sites; eczema is poorly defined and often lichenified; tinea has an active annular edge. [1]
- Vesicles: unilateral dermatomal pain = zoster; crops at multiple stages on the trunk = varicella; pearly umbilicated papules without febrile crops = molluscum. [1][18]
- Skin cancer: describe the lesion, apply ABCDE/evolution, and arrange tissue diagnosis for suspicious or bleeding lesions. [1][11]
- Hands and feet: vesicles distinguish whitlow from felon; joint distribution separates RA/OA/PsA; skin lines and pressure pattern help separate wart, callus and corn. [1]
- Nails: correlate pitting/onycholysis with psoriasis and confirm suspected fungus before systemic treatment. [1]
- Look at the whole person: expression and disability are cues to assess and adapt communication—not licences to infer diagnosis or capacity. [1]
Active Recall - Visual Spot Diagnoses
[1] Lecture slides: GC 022. Visual Spot Diagnoses - Survival Guide for Primary Care [Updated 20250425].pdf (all pages) [2] Lecture slides: CFB (FM02) Introduction to common problems - Differentiating the normal from the abnormal.pdf (p2) [3] Lecture slides: GC 122. Chronic Visual Loss.pdf (p44) [4] Lecture slides: Derm General Clerkship 2026 Part1.pdf [5] Lecture slides: GC 019. The Family in Family Medicine [Pre-Lecture Reading 3].pdf (p6) [6] Senior notes: Block A - Dermatology PBL 1.pdf [7] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Opthalmology.pdf (p20, p39, p43, p45, p60, p64) [8] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Endocrine.pdf (p96) [9] Senior notes: Block A - Dermatology PBL 2.pdf (p1, p6) [10] Senior notes: Block A - Dermatology Pictorial Tour.pdf (p22) [11] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Rheumatology.pdf (p147, p187, p190, p193) [12] Senior notes: Maksim Medicine Notes.pdf (p78) [13] Past papers: 2019 Fourth Summative MCQ.pdf (p2) [14] Past papers: 2024 Fourth Summative MCQ.pdf (p31, Q83) [15] Past papers: 2025 Fourth Summative MCQ.pdf (p43, Q21) [16] NHS. Red eye: urgent and emergency warning features (updated 2025). https://www.nhs.uk/symptoms/red-eye/ [17] NICE NG12. Suspected cancer: recognition and referral – oral cancer recommendations 1.8.2-1.8.3 (current online guidance). [18] US CDC. Clinical Features of Chickenpox (Varicella) (updated 2024). https://www.cdc.gov/chickenpox/hcp/clinical-signs/index.html
GC021 Upper Respiratory Tract Infections
Upper respiratory tract infections are acute infections affecting the nasal passages, pharynx, larynx, and sinuses, most commonly caused by viruses, presenting with symptoms such as nasal congestion, sore throat, cough, and malaise.
GC023 A Cyanotic, Dyspneic Elderly Man: Respiratory Failure
Respiratory failure is a condition in which the respiratory system fails to maintain adequate gas exchange, resulting in hypoxemia with or without hypercapnia, often presenting with cyanosis and dyspnea, particularly in elderly patients with compromised cardiopulmonary reserve.