Common Fractures And Dislocations
Common fractures and dislocations are frequently encountered musculoskeletal injuries involving breaks in bone continuity or displacement of articulating surfaces from their normal joint alignment, typically resulting from trauma, falls, or repetitive stress.
Common Fractures and Dislocations
A fracture is a break in the continuity of bone, occurring when the applied force exceeds the bone's ability to withstand it. A dislocation is a complete disruption of the articular surfaces of a joint such that they are no longer in contact. A subluxation is a partial loss of congruence. A fracture-dislocation combines both — a fracture adjacent to or involving a joint that has also dislocated.
Understanding this distinction matters because the management, complications, and prognosis differ significantly:
- Fractures primarily threaten bone healing and limb alignment.
- Dislocations primarily threaten soft tissue (ligaments, capsule, neurovascular structures) and joint stability.
- Fracture-dislocations carry the combined risks of both.
The word "fracture" comes from Latin fractura ("a breaking"), while "dislocation" is from Latin dis- (apart) + locare (to place) — literally "put out of place."
Epidemiology and Risk Factors
- Fractures account for a significant proportion of Emergency Department presentations worldwide. In Hong Kong, the ageing population means a dual burden:
- Young adults: high-energy trauma (road traffic accidents [RTAs], sports injuries, falls from height) — these tend to cause complex fractures and fracture-dislocations.
- Elderly: low-energy trauma (simple falls from standing height) — these are fragility fractures in osteoporotic bone.
- The most common fractures overall include: distal radius (Colles'), hip (neck of femur), ankle, proximal humerus, and vertebral compression fractures [2].
- Fracture is more common than dislocation in children because the paediatric bone is weaker than the ligaments and growth plates are mechanically vulnerable [3].
| Category | Risk Factors | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Age | Elderly (> 65), very young | Osteoporosis in elderly; growth plate vulnerability in children |
| Sex | Female (post-menopausal) | Oestrogen deficiency → accelerated bone resorption via ↑RANKL:OPG ratio [6] |
| Bone quality | Osteoporosis, osteomalacia, Paget's disease, metastatic disease | Weakened bone fails under normal physiological loads ("pathological fracture") |
| Mechanism | High-energy trauma (RTA, fall from height), sports | Force exceeds normal bone tolerance |
| Lifestyle | Sedentary, smoking, alcohol excess, low calcium/vitamin D | Poor bone formation, ↑bone resorption, impaired healing |
| Medications | Glucocorticoids, aromatase inhibitors, anticonvulsants, heparin | Drug-induced osteoporosis [6] |
| Previous fracture | History of fragility fracture | Single best predictor of future fracture — indicates already compromised bone |
| Anatomical/biomechanical | Joint hyperlaxity, malalignment (genu valgum/varum), high Q angle | Predispose to dislocations (e.g. patellar dislocation) [1] |
| Sport/occupation | Contact sports, manual labour, repetitive loading | ↑exposure to injurious forces, stress fractures |
- Hong Kong has one of the world's most rapidly ageing populations. Osteoporotic hip fractures are a major public health burden — prevalence in HK women: 1 in 6 aged 60–69, 1 in 5 aged 70–79, 1 in 4 aged ≥ 80 [6].
- Road traffic accidents remain a significant cause of high-energy fractures and dislocations, particularly motorcyclists and pedestrians.
- High-energy trauma (e.g. fall from height, RTA) is a common mechanism for pelvic fractures, tibial plateau fractures, and fracture-dislocations [4][5].
Anatomy and Function
Understanding anatomy is crucial because it dictates fracture pattern, neurovascular complications, and management strategy. Below is a region-by-region summary of key anatomical concepts relevant to common fractures and dislocations.
Upper Limb
- Clavicle: S-shaped bone bridging the sternum (sternoclavicular joint, SCJ) and acromion (acromioclavicular joint, ACJ). It protects the brachial plexus and subclavian vessels beneath.
- Middle third is the thinnest and most commonly fractured (~80%) [2].
- Sternocleidomastoid (SCM) attaches medially → pulls medial fragment superiorly after fracture.
- Weight of the arm pulls lateral fragment inferiorly.
- Proximal humerus: four segments — greater tuberosity (rotator cuff attachment), lesser tuberosity (subscapularis), articular segment (humeral head), and humeral shaft.
- Axillary nerve (C5, C6) wraps around surgical neck → vulnerable in surgical neck fractures and anterior shoulder dislocations → test by checking sensation over "regimental badge area" (lateral deltoid) and deltoid contraction.
- Axillary artery runs close to surgical neck → injury may be masked by extensive collateral circulation (thoracoacromial trunk, circumflex scapular artery) preserving distal pulses even when the artery is damaged [2].
- Suprascapular nerve: innervates supraspinatus and infraspinatus — can be injured in proximal humerus fractures.
- Three articulations: ulnohumeral (hinge), radiocapitellar (pivot), proximal radioulnar joint (PRUJ).
- Radiocapitellar line: a line drawn through the centre of the radial shaft should always pass through the capitellum on every view — disruption implies radial head dislocation (key in Monteggia fractures) [2].
- Anterior humeral line: a line along the anterior cortex of the humerus on lateral view should pass through the middle third of the capitellum — disruption implies supracondylar fracture (especially important in children).
- Equilateral triangle of elbow (olecranon, medial and lateral epicondyles) — disrupted in elbow dislocation.
- Ulnar nerve runs posterior to the medial epicondyle in the cubital tunnel → at risk in elbow fractures and dislocations.
- Radius and ulna are linked by the interosseous membrane — an injury to one bone often implies injury to the other or to a radioulnar joint. This is the concept behind fracture-dislocations (Galeazzi, Monteggia).
- The forearm functions as a unit for pronation and supination — hence displaced forearm fractures almost always need ORIF to restore rotational anatomy [2].
- Scaphoid: most commonly fractured carpal bone. Blood supply enters distally (dorsal branch of radial artery) and flows retrograde → proximal pole at high risk of avascular necrosis (AVN) after fracture.
- Lunate: central keystone of the carpus; also at risk of AVN (Kienböck's disease).
- Distal radius: the most common fracture site overall. Articulates with the scaphoid and lunate proximally (radiocarpal joint) and the ulna medially (distal radioulnar joint, DRUJ).
Lower Limb
- Arterial supply is retrograde: medial circumflex femoral artery (MCFA, main supply) and lateral circumflex femoral artery (LCFA) are branches of profunda femoris → ascend along the femoral neck under the capsule [2].
- Intracapsular fractures disrupt these retinacular vessels → high risk of AVN of femoral head.
- Extracapsular fractures (intertrochanteric, subtrochanteric) generally spare the blood supply → low AVN risk but high blood loss risk.
- Ligamentum teres: contains the artery to the head of femur (foveal artery) — significant blood supply in children but minor in adults.
- Nerve supply: sciatic, femoral, obturator — same nerves innervate the knee → hip pathology can present as knee pain (referred pain via Hilton's law) [2].
- Tibial plateau: the flat top of the tibia that articulates with the femoral condyles. Lateral plateau is more commonly fractured because normal valgus alignment directs forces laterally [2].
- Popliteal artery: tethered behind the knee → vulnerable in tibial plateau fractures and knee dislocations → must always assess distal pulses.
- Common peroneal nerve: wraps around the fibular neck → vulnerable in lateral tibial plateau fractures and fibular neck fractures → foot drop.
- Ankle mortise: formed by the tibial plafond (roof), medial malleolus, and lateral malleolus (fibula). The talus sits within this mortise — any widening (even 1mm) significantly reduces contact area and accelerates arthritis.
- Deltoid ligament (medial): strong, rarely torn in isolation — injury implies significant force.
- Lateral ligament complex: anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL, weakest, most commonly injured), calcaneofibular ligament (CFL), posterior talofibular ligament (PTFL).
- Calcaneus: most commonly fractured tarsal bone. Böhler's angle (25–40° normal) is measured on lateral X-ray — flattening indicates compression fracture.
- Talus: second most commonly fractured tarsal bone. Relies heavily on extraosseous blood supply → high risk of AVN [2].
- Lisfranc joint (tarsometatarsal joint): base of 2nd metatarsal sits in a mortise between medial and middle cuneiforms, stabilised by the Lisfranc ligament (2nd MT to medial cuneiform) [2].
- Three-column model (Denis):
- Anterior column: anterior longitudinal ligament + anterior half of vertebral body
- Middle column: posterior half of vertebral body + posterior longitudinal ligament
- Posterior column: pedicles, lamina, facets, spinous processes, posterior ligamentous complex
- Instability = involvement of ≥ 2 columns.
The immature skeleton differs from the adult skeleton in several critical ways [3]:
| Feature | Paediatric Bone | Adult Bone |
|---|---|---|
| Density | Less dense, more porotic, more vascular | Dense cortical bone |
| Periosteum | Thick periosteum — acts as a "sleeve" that helps maintain reduction and accelerates healing | Thin periosteum |
| Growth plate (physis) | Present — mechanically weakest link in the musculoskeletal chain | Fused |
| Elasticity | More elastic — allows incomplete fracture patterns | Less elastic — complete fractures |
| Healing | Faster healing | Slower healing |
| Remodelling | Greater remodelling potential (especially in the plane of motion of an adjacent joint and in younger children) | Limited remodelling |
Unique paediatric fracture patterns [3]:
- Greenstick fracture: one cortex breaks, the other bends (like breaking a green twig)
- Plastic deformation (bowing): bone bends without a visible fracture line
- Torus (buckle) fracture: compression of one cortex causing a "buckle" — stable, treated with splint
- Physeal (growth plate) injuries: classified by the Salter-Harris classification (see Classification section)
Because ligaments are stronger than the growth plate in children, fracture is more common than dislocation, and physeal injury is more common than ligament injury [3].
Etiology and Pathophysiology
Etiology — Mechanisms of Injury
| Mechanism | Description | Common Examples |
|---|---|---|
| FOOSH (Fall On OutStretched Hand) | Axial load transmitted through the upper limb | Distal radius (Colles'/Smith), scaphoid, radial head, supracondylar (children), proximal humerus, clavicle |
| Direct blow | Force applied directly to the bone | Clavicle, ulna (nightstick fracture), patella |
| Axial loading | Compressive force along the long axis | Calcaneus (fall from height), tibial plateau, vertebral compression, tibial pilon |
| Twisting/rotational | Torsional force | Spiral fractures of tibia/fibula, ankle fractures |
| Avulsion | Muscle/ligament pulls off a bony fragment | Olecranon (triceps), tibial tuberosity (patellar tendon), 5th MT base (peroneus brevis) |
| High-energy trauma | RTA, fall from height | Pelvic fractures, femoral shaft, tibial plateau, acetabular fractures, open fractures |
| Valgus/varus force | Lateral or medial angulating force | Tibial plateau (valgus), ankle fractures |
| Type | Pathophysiology | Key Points |
|---|---|---|
| Stress fracture | Small repetitive stress on normal bone exceeding its repair capacity → microfracture accumulation → complete fracture. Common in military recruits, distance runners. Common sites: tibia, fibula, metatarsal [2] | Two subtypes: fatigue fractures (normal bone, abnormal load) and insufficiency fractures (abnormal bone, normal load) |
| Pathological fracture | Fracture in diseased bone due to malignant or non-malignant conditions. Bone is structurally weakened so fails under physiological loads [2] | Must always consider metastatic disease if fracture occurs above T5 or with constitutional symptoms. Common causes: osteoporosis, metastases, myeloma, Paget's disease |
| Fragility fracture | A subtype of pathological fracture — fracture resulting from forces equivalent to a fall from standing height or less. Common sites: hip, distal radius (Colles'), lumbosacral spine [2] | Hallmark of osteoporosis. In HK, major public health concern in the elderly |
Pathological fractures in children [3]:
- Skeletal dysplasia (771 disorders associated with 552 genes, 41 groups — abnormal bone and cartilage formation)
- Osteogenesis imperfecta
- Simple bone cysts, aneurysmal bone cysts
- Malignancy: osteosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma
- Metabolic: rickets, renal osteodystrophy
- Neuromuscular conditions (e.g. cerebral palsy — disuse osteoporosis)
Pathophysiology — What Happens When Bone Breaks?
-
Energy absorption and failure: When force exceeds bone strength, the bone absorbs energy and fails. The pattern of failure depends on the type of force:
- Tension → transverse fracture (bone pulls apart perpendicular to the force)
- Compression → buckle/impaction fracture
- Bending → wedge/butterfly fragment (tension failure on one cortex, compression on the other)
- Torsion → spiral fracture
- Combined → oblique, comminuted, or segmental fractures
- High energy → comminuted fractures (multiple fragments) with extensive soft tissue damage
-
Haematoma formation (hours): disrupted vessels bleed → fracture haematoma forms. This is actually beneficial — it serves as a scaffold for healing.
-
Inflammatory phase (days 1–7): cytokines recruit macrophages and inflammatory cells → debris clearance. Osteoclasts resorb necrotic bone ends.
-
Soft callus formation (weeks 1–3): chondroblasts and fibroblasts lay down cartilaginous callus (fibrocartilage) bridging the fracture gap.
-
Hard callus formation (weeks 3–12): osteoblasts replace cartilage with woven bone via endochondral ossification.
-
Remodelling (months to years): osteoclasts and osteoblasts remodel woven bone into organised lamellar bone along lines of stress (Wolff's law).
Why do children heal faster? Thicker, more vascular periosteum provides a richer blood supply and more osteoprogenitor cells. Greater remodelling potential means minor angulation can correct over time.
- A joint dislocates when the applied force exceeds the restraining strength of the capsule, ligaments, and surrounding muscles.
- The direction of dislocation depends on the direction of force and the anatomy of the joint:
- Shoulder: anterior dislocation most common (~95%) because the anterior-inferior capsule is weakest and the humeral head is forced out when the arm is abducted + externally rotated.
- Elbow: posterior dislocation most common (~90%) because FOOSH drives the ulna posteriorly.
- Hip: posterior dislocation most common (~90%) because dashboard injury drives the flexed femur posteriorly.
- Patella: lateral dislocation because of the natural valgus vector of the quadriceps (Q angle) [1].
Classification
General Fracture Classification
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Complete | Fracture extends through the entire bone — two or more fragments |
| Incomplete | Fracture extends through part of the bone only — greenstick, torus (buckle), plastic deformation (unique to children) [3] |
| Pattern | Mechanism | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Transverse | Tension/bending | Fracture line perpendicular to long axis |
| Oblique | Combined bending + compression | Fracture line at an angle |
| Spiral | Torsion/rotation | Fracture line spirals around the bone |
| Comminuted | High energy | > 2 fragments |
| Segmental | High energy | Two fracture lines isolating a segment of bone |
| Avulsion | Traction by tendon/ligament | Bony fragment pulled off |
| Impacted | Compression/axial load | Fragments driven into each other |
| Butterfly | Bending | Wedge-shaped fragment on compression side |
| Type | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Closed | Skin intact | Lower infection risk |
| Open (compound) | Fracture communicates with the external environment through a skin wound | High infection risk, requires urgent debridement and antibiotics [4] |
- Undisplaced / Minimally displaced: fragments in acceptable alignment
- Displaced: described by translation (medial/lateral, anterior/posterior), angulation, rotation, shortening, and distraction
- Diaphyseal (shaft), Metaphyseal (flared region near the joint), Epiphyseal (within the joint), Intra-articular (involves the joint surface) vs Extra-articular
This is one of the most important classifications in paediatric orthopaedics. The mnemonic is SALTR:
| Type | Mnemonic | Description | Prognosis |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | Slipped / Straight across | Fracture through the physis only (growth plate separation) | Good — growth disturbance rare |
| II | Above | Fracture through physis + metaphyseal fragment (Thurston-Holland fragment) | Good — most common type (~75%) |
| III | Lower | Fracture through physis + epiphyseal fragment (intra-articular) | Risk of growth arrest, requires anatomical reduction |
| IV | Through / Together | Fracture through metaphysis, physis, AND epiphysis | High risk of growth arrest — requires ORIF |
| V | Rammed / cRushed | Crush injury to the physis | Worst prognosis — growth arrest almost inevitable, often diagnosed retrospectively |
Why does crossing the physis matter? The physis (growth plate) is responsible for longitudinal bone growth. Damage to the germinal layer of chondrocytes can cause premature physeal closure → limb length discrepancy or angular deformity. Types III, IV, and V carry the highest risk.
Specific Fracture Classifications by Region
-
Allman classification (clavicle fracture — by anatomical location) [2]:
- Type 1: Middle 1/3 (80%) — generally stable
- Type 2: Lateral 1/3 (15%) — often unstable if displaced
- Type 3: Medial 1/3 (5%) — high incidence of pneumothorax/haemothorax
-
Neer classification (proximal humerus fracture) [2]: Based on displacement of the 4 main segments (greater tuberosity, lesser tuberosity, articular segment, humeral shaft). A segment is considered a "part" if displaced > 1 cm or angulated > 45°. Classified as 2-part, 3-part, or 4-part fractures.
- Mason classification (radial head fractures):
- Type I: Non-displaced
- Type II: Displaced > 2mm or angulated
- Type III: Comminuted
- Type IV: Associated elbow dislocation
- Mayo classification (olecranon fractures):
- Type I: Undisplaced
- Type II: Displaced, stable
- Type III: Unstable
GRIMUS Mnemonic for Forearm Fracture-Dislocations
Galeazzi = distal Radius fracture + DRUJ Injury (ulnar styloid fracture) Monteggia = proximal Ulnar fracture + PRUJ injury (radial head diSlocation)
Remember: Galeazzi = Radius, Monteggia = Ulna. "GRIMUS" — Galeazzi: Radius, Inferior (distal); Monteggia: Ulna, Superior (proximal).
| Galeazzi fracture-dislocation | Monteggia fracture-dislocation | |
|---|---|---|
| Fracture | Distal radius shaft | Proximal ulna shaft |
| Dislocation | DRUJ (distal radioulnar joint) | PRUJ — radial head dislocation |
| Radiological clue | Shortening of distal radius, widening of DRUJ space | Disrupted radiocapitellar line |
| Associated nerve injury | — | Posterior interosseous nerve (PIN) injury (branch of radial nerve) |
| Treatment | ORIF | ORIF |
- Nightstick fracture: isolated ulnar shaft fracture (from direct blow — like being hit with a nightstick) [2].
| Colles' fracture (MC, > 90%) | Smith fracture | |
|---|---|---|
| MOI | FOOSH forwards → landing on palmar wrist | FOOSH backwards → landing on dorsal wrist |
| Displacement | Dorsal angulation + displacement | Volar angulation + displacement |
| Deformity | Dinner fork deformity | Garden spade deformity |
| Nerve injury | Low median nerve injury: lateral 3½ fingers + palm numbness | — |
| Radiological features (×6) | Shortened radius, ulnar styloid fracture, dorsal angulation + displacement, radial angulation + displacement | Shortened radius, ulnar styloid fracture, volar angulation + displacement, radial angulation + displacement |
- Barton's fracture: intra-articular fracture of distal radius with associated radiocarpal dislocation [2].
- Both Colles' and Smith fractures are extra-articular by definition (Barton's is intra-articular).
- By location [2]:
- Intracapsular (high AVN risk): subcapital, transcervical, basicervical
- Extracapsular (low AVN risk): intertrochanteric, subtrochanteric (within 5 cm of lesser trochanter)
- Garden classification (intracapsular #NOF — by displacement):
- Garden I: Incomplete/valgus impacted — trabeculae are angulated
- Garden II: Complete but undisplaced — trabeculae align normally
- Garden III: Complete, partially displaced — trabeculae don't align
- Garden IV: Complete, fully displaced — no trabecular contact
- Simplified: Garden I–II = "undisplaced"; Garden III–IV = "displaced"
- Schatzker classification [2]:
- Type I: Lateral split
- Type II: Lateral split-depression (most common)
- Type III: Pure lateral depression
- Type IV: Medial plateau fracture (higher energy, worse prognosis)
- Type V: Bicondylar
- Type VI: Dissociation of metaphysis from diaphysis
- Weber classification (based on fibula fracture level relative to the syndesmosis):
- Weber A: Below the syndesmosis — usually stable
- Weber B: At the level of the syndesmosis — may be stable or unstable
- Weber C: Above the syndesmosis — unstable, syndesmosis disrupted
- Böhler's angle: measured on lateral X-ray between two lines — normal 25–40°. Flattened in calcaneal compression fractures.
- Sanders classification: based on CT coronal cuts through the posterior facet.
- Hawkins classification (talar neck fractures — predicts AVN risk) [2]:
- Type I: Undisplaced — 0–15% AVN risk
- Type II: Subtalar dislocation — 20–50% AVN risk
- Type III: Subtalar + tibiotalar dislocation — 90–100% AVN risk
- Type IV: Subtalar + tibiotalar + talonavicular dislocation — 100% AVN risk
- Hardcastle and Myerson classification [2]
- Young and Burgess classification (by mechanism):
- Lateral compression (LC): most common, internal rotation of hemipelvis
- Anteroposterior compression (APC): "open book" injury, external rotation
- Vertical shear (VS): vertical displacement of hemipelvis
- Combined mechanism (CM)
- Key concept: pelvis is a ring — if there is one fracture, there must be another [5]
Dislocation Classification
- Anterior (~95%): most common. MOI = forced abduction + external rotation.
- Posterior (~2–5%): classically associated with seizures and electrocution (internal rotators overpower external rotators). Often missed on AP X-ray — need axillary or Y-view.
- Inferior (least common): MOI = hand outstretched in cycling accident → luxatio erecta (humeral head displaced downward, arm hyper-abducted) → hold injured arm above head → highest incidence of axillary nerve injury [2].
Risk Factors for Recurrent Instability After First-Time Anterior Shoulder Dislocation
Risk factors for recurrent dislocation after first dislocation [1]:
- Aged 40 years and under: 13 times more likely
- Men: 3 times more likely
- Greater tuberosity fracture: 7 times less likely (paradoxically protective — the fracture heals and tightens the capsule)
- Hyperlaxity: 3 times more likely
- High recurrent instability in young patients (65–95%) — particularly in competitive and contact sports [1]
- Usually posterior (MOI: FOOSH) [2]
- 50% associated with bony injury
- Terrible triad of the elbow: elbow dislocation + radial head fracture + coronoid process fracture — high risk of instability and stiffness.
- Posterior (~90%): classic "dashboard injury" — flexed hip + axial load (knee hits dashboard). Limb is shortened, flexed, adducted, internally rotated. Risk: sciatic nerve injury, AVN.
- Anterior (~10%): forced abduction + external rotation. Limb is extended, abducted, externally rotated.
- Severe torsional force on plantarflexed foot [2]
Clinical Features
| Symptom | Pathophysiological Basis |
|---|---|
| Pain (at fracture/dislocation site) | Periosteum is richly innervated — disruption stimulates nociceptors. Haematoma causes local tissue distension. Muscle spasm around the injury adds to pain. |
| Inability to bear weight / use limb | Structural failure of bone means it can no longer transmit mechanical load. Dislocated joint has lost its fulcrum for movement. |
| Swelling | Haematoma from disrupted vessels + inflammatory exudate → local oedema |
| Feeling of "something giving way" or "pop" | Sudden ligament rupture or bone failure — often described in dislocations and ACL tears |
| Referred pain | Hip fractures can present as knee pain (femoral/obturator nerve shared innervation via Hilton's law [2]). Always examine the joint above and below. |
| Numbness/tingling (in the distribution of an adjacent nerve) | Direct nerve injury by displaced fragment or stretching. E.g., median nerve in Colles' fracture, axillary nerve in shoulder dislocation, common peroneal nerve in fibular neck fracture |
| History of mechanism | Critical for predicting injury pattern — FOOSH, RTA, fall from height, twisting injury, etc. |
| Inability to actively move a joint | Structural disruption of the tendon-bone-joint unit. E.g., inability to extend elbow against gravity = olecranon fracture (triceps insertion disrupted) [2] |
Signs
| Sign | Pathophysiological Basis |
|---|---|
| Tenderness (localised over fracture site) | Periosteal pain from fracture |
| Swelling and bruising | Fracture haematoma + soft tissue injury |
| Deformity | Displacement of fracture fragments by the deforming force + pull of muscles. E.g., dinner fork deformity in Colles' (dorsal displacement), shortened and externally rotated limb in #NOF (pull of hip external rotators and gravity) |
| Crepitus | Grinding of fracture fragments against each other — do NOT elicit deliberately! |
| Abnormal mobility | Movement at a site that should be rigid — indicates complete fracture |
| Loss of function | Pain inhibits muscle contraction + structural failure prevents load transmission |
| Shortening | Muscle pull telescopes the fragments (e.g., femoral shaft fracture shortened by quadriceps/hamstrings) |
| Threatened skin | Tented, tethered, non-blanching skin due to sharp fracture fragment pressing from within — impending conversion to open fracture. Seen in clavicle fractures (pull of SCM and arm) [2] |
Site-Specific Signs
- Anterior dislocation: loss of normal rounded deltoid contour → "squared-off" shoulder. Humeral head palpable anteriorly. Arm held in slight abduction and external rotation. Patient resists internal rotation.
- Regimental badge area numbness → axillary nerve injury (test before and after reduction!)
- Associated injuries: Bankart lesion (avulsion of anteroinferior glenoid labrum — the reason dislocations recur), Hill-Sachs lesion (posterolateral humeral head compression fracture from impaction against the glenoid rim) [1][2]
- Posterior dislocation: arm held in adduction and internal rotation. Loss of external rotation. Classically missed on AP X-ray — "lightbulb sign" (humeral head appears round like a lightbulb because it is internally rotated). Need axillary or Y-view.
- Inferior dislocation: patient holds arm above head (luxatio erecta) [2]
- Focal tenderness, visible/palpable deformity
- Medial fragment displaced superiorly (SCM pull), lateral fragment inferiorly (arm weight) [2]
- Look for threatened skin, neurovascular status (brachial plexus, subclavian vessels)
- Auscultate for pneumothorax (especially medial 1/3 fractures)
- Extensive bruising (tracks down the arm and chest wall)
- Test axillary nerve (sensation over deltoid, deltoid contraction) and suprascapular nerve (supraspinatus — initiation of abduction, infraspinatus — external rotation) [2]
- Test distal pulses (axillary artery injury)
- Elbow effusion: positive fat pad sign on lateral X-ray (posterior fat pad raised = always abnormal; anterior "sail sign" = suggestive of effusion). Why? Because intra-articular haematoma pushes the fat pads out of the fossae [2].
- Olecranon fracture: inability to extend elbow against gravity (because the triceps insertion on the olecranon is disrupted) [2]
- Elbow dislocation: disrupted equilateral triangle (olecranon, medial epicondyle, lateral epicondyle normally form an equilateral triangle in flexion). Effusion. Limited pronation-supination. Check ulnar nerve (posterior to medial epicondyle) [2]
- Terrible triad: posterior dislocation + radial head fracture + coronoid fracture → grossly unstable elbow
- Supracondylar fracture (children): most common elbow fracture in children. High risk of Volkmann's ischaemic contracture (see Complications) [2]. Check brachial artery (anterior to the elbow), anterior interosseous nerve (FPL — can't make OK sign), median nerve, radial nerve.
- Pain on forearm rotation (pronation/supination)
- Galeazzi: tenderness over distal radius shaft + DRUJ instability (pain/widening at wrist)
- Monteggia: tenderness over proximal ulna + radial head palpable/dislocated. Check PIN (wrist/finger extension — "wrist drop" or isolated finger drop) [2]
- Colles' fracture: dinner fork deformity (dorsal displacement of distal fragment makes the wrist look like the lateral profile of a fork). Check median nerve: ask about numbness in lateral 3½ fingers and palm [2]
- Smith fracture: garden spade deformity (volar displacement) [2]
- Scaphoid fracture: anatomical snuffbox tenderness (between EPL and EPB/APL tendons), scaphoid tubercle tenderness (volar), pain on telescoping the thumb (axial compression). Initial X-rays may be negative — if clinical suspicion high, treat as scaphoid fracture and re-image at 10–14 days (fracture line becomes visible as bone resorbs at the fracture site) [2].
- Mallet finger: flexed DIP joint that cannot be actively extended (passive ROM intact) — injury to the terminal extensor tendon (Zone 1) when an extended finger is forcibly flexed (e.g., ball strikes fingertip) [2]
- Jersey finger: rupture of FDP — failed DIP flexion when making a fist (finger stays extended while others flex) [2]
- Boxer's fracture: fracture of 5th metacarpal neck due to direct trauma to a clenched fist (punching) [2]
- Bennett's fracture: fracture of 1st metacarpal base due to forced abduction of 1st metacarpal in clenched fist — intra-articular, unstable [2]
- Skier's thumb: ulnar collateral ligament rupture → increased ROM of thumb at MCPJ (loss of pinch grip strength) [2]
- Tendon sheath infections → Kanavel signs [2]:
- Tenderness over flexor sheath
- Pain on passive extension
- Flexed posture of digit
- Fusiform (sausage-shaped) swelling of digit
- Shortened, externally rotated limb (pull of short external rotators — piriformis, obturator externus/internus, gemelli, quadratus femoris). The lower limb naturally falls into external rotation due to gravity when the femoral neck is fractured and can no longer resist.
- Unable to straight leg raise (SLR)
- Tenderness over groin
- May present as isolated knee pain (referred pain — same nerve supply)
- Intracapsular fractures: less deformity if impacted (Garden I)
- Extracapsular fractures: more swelling and bruising (fracture is outside the capsule, so blood tracks into soft tissues rather than being contained)
- Severe pain, obvious deformity, swelling
- Significant blood loss (can lose > 1.5L into the thigh) → haemodynamic instability
- Always check for ipsilateral femoral neck fracture (10% incidence — often missed)
- Check distal neurovascular status
- Sudden onset knee pain, unable to bear weight
- Significant swelling: lipohaemarthrosis (fat globules from bone marrow + blood in the joint — pathognomonic of intra-articular fracture; on lateral X-ray, may see a fat-fluid level in the suprapatellar pouch)
- Associated injuries: popliteal artery (compartment syndrome risk), common peroneal nerve [2]
- Patella apprehension test: pain/apprehension when patella is pushed laterally [2]
- Visible lateral displacement of patella (may have spontaneously reduced by the time of examination)
- Effusion (haemarthrosis from osteochondral injury)
- Severe pain, unable to bear weight
- High risk of open fracture: the anteromedial surface of the tibia is subcutaneous (no muscle covering) [2]
- High risk of compartment syndrome: 6 Ps (Pain out of proportion — especially pain on passive dorsiflexion of great toe, Pressure/tenseness of compartment, Paraesthesia, Paralysis, Pallor, Pulselessness — late sign) [2]
- Swelling, bruising, inability to bear weight
- Palpate both malleoli, the fibula along its full length (Maisonneuve fracture = proximal fibula fracture with distal syndesmotic disruption — easy to miss!), the base of the 5th metatarsal, the navicular
- Ottawa Ankle Rules: X-ray indicated if:
- Bone tenderness at posterior edge or tip of either malleolus in the distal 6 cm, OR
- Inability to bear weight (4 steps) immediately and in the Emergency Department, OR
- Bone tenderness at base of 5th metatarsal or navicular (Ottawa Foot Rules)
- History of fall from height → heel pain
- Bilateral calcaneal fractures → always assess for associated lumbar spine fracture (10% incidence — axial load transmitted cranially)
- Flattened Böhler's angle (< 25°) on lateral X-ray [2]
- Swelling, bruising, inability to bear weight
- Ankle forced into dorsiflexion → talus presses against tibial plafond → talar neck fracture [2]
- Pain, swelling, inability to bear weight
- High index of suspicion for AVN (especially if displaced)
- Pain, inability to bear weight
- Do NOT spring the pelvis (can displace clots and worsen haemorrhage) — gentle compression AP and lateral only
- Look for haemodynamic instability (pelvic fractures can cause massive haemorrhage — > 2L into the retroperitoneum)
- Assess for urethral injury (blood at meatus, high-riding prostate, perineal bruising → do NOT catheterise without urethrogram)
- Morel-Lavallée lesion: internal degloving injury — skin and subcutaneous tissues separated from underlying fascia. Seen over greater trochanter and pelvis in high-energy injuries [2].
- Associated injuries: bladder rupture, urethral injury, lumbosacral plexus injury
- Acute mechanical back pain ± radiation
- Height loss, progressive kyphosis (in chronic cases)
- Neurological deficit if posterior cortex retropulsion → spinal canal compromise
- Distinguish from pathological fracture (metastasis, myeloma) — suspect if above T5 or constitutional symptoms [2]
The Neurovascular Exam — Never Skip It!
For EVERY fracture and dislocation, before and after ANY intervention:
- Distal pulses (capillary refill, colour, temperature)
- Sensation (specific nerve territories)
- Motor function (specific nerve-muscle groups)
- Compartment assessment (pain on passive stretch, compartment tension)
Document findings clearly. Failure to detect neurovascular compromise early leads to irreversible damage.
Common Fracture-Nerve Injury Associations
| Fracture/Dislocation | Nerve at Risk | Clinical Test |
|---|---|---|
| Anterior shoulder dislocation | Axillary nerve (C5,6) | Regimental badge sensation, deltoid contraction |
| Proximal humerus (surgical neck) | Axillary nerve | Same as above |
| Humeral shaft (mid-shaft/spiral) | Radial nerve | Wrist drop, loss of finger/thumb extension, sensation in anatomical snuffbox |
| Supracondylar fracture (children) | Anterior interosseous nerve (AIN), median nerve | AIN: can't flex DIP of index + FPL (can't make OK sign). Median: sensation lateral 3½ fingers |
| Monteggia fracture-dislocation | Posterior interosseous nerve (PIN) | Finger/wrist extension weakness (but sensation preserved — PIN is purely motor) |
| Elbow dislocation | Ulnar nerve | Sensation little finger, interossei weakness |
| Colles' fracture | Median nerve (in carpal tunnel) | Lateral 3½ finger numbness |
| Hip dislocation (posterior) | Sciatic nerve | Foot drop + posterior thigh/leg numbness |
| Knee dislocation | Common peroneal nerve | Foot drop (dorsiflexion/eversion weakness), sensation loss over dorsum of foot |
| Tibial plateau / fibular neck fracture | Common peroneal nerve | Same as above |
Though these conditions are not common, we need to be cautious. Treatment for the underlying cause is important [3].
Suspect NAI when:
- Injury pattern inconsistent with the given history
- Delay in presentation
- Multiple fractures at different stages of healing
- Fractures in non-ambulatory children (< 1 year old)
- Specific high-risk fracture patterns: metaphyseal corner fractures ("bucket-handle"), posterior rib fractures, scapular fractures, spinous process fractures, sternal fractures
- Associated soft tissue injuries: bruises in unusual locations, burns
- Always consider safeguarding and involve the multidisciplinary child protection team
High Yield Summary
Key Concepts:
- Paediatric bone is less dense, more porous, more vascular, has a thick periosteum → unique fracture patterns (greenstick, torus, plastic deformation) → heals faster → fracture more common than dislocation in children [3].
- Salter-Harris classification (SALTR): Types III, IV, V cross the physis → risk of growth arrest.
- Forearm fracture-dislocations: Galeazzi = Radius fracture + DRUJ injury; Monteggia = Ulnar fracture + radial head dislocation (PIN injury). GRIMUS mnemonic. All need ORIF [2].
- Colles' fracture: FOOSH forward, dorsal displacement, dinner fork deformity, 6 radiological features, median nerve injury. Smith = opposite direction (volar) [2].
- #NOF: intracapsular = high AVN risk (retinacular vessels disrupted); extracapsular = low AVN risk but more blood loss. Hip pain may present as knee pain [2].
- Shoulder dislocation: anterior (95%) → Bankart + Hill-Sachs lesions, axillary nerve injury. Recurrence rates very high in young patients (65–95%) [1][2].
- Tibial shaft fracture: high risk of open fracture (subcutaneous anteromedial surface) and compartment syndrome [2].
- Talar neck fractures: Hawkins classification predicts AVN risk (Type I: 0–15%, Type IV: 100%) [2].
- Lisfranc injury: plantar bruising is pathognomonic, fleck sign on X-ray [2].
- Pelvic ring: if one break, look for a second. High-energy injury, massive haemorrhage potential [5].
- Risk factors for recurrent shoulder instability: age ≤ 40 (13× more likely), male (3×), hyperlaxity (3×), greater tuberosity fracture (7× less likely) [1].
- Always check neurovascular status before and after intervention — document it.
- Pathological fractures in children: consider skeletal dysplasia (771 disorders, 552 genes, 41 groups) [3].
- Non-accidental injury: be cautious — treat the underlying cause [3].
Active Recall - Common Fractures and Dislocations
[1] Lecture slides: GC 236. Common Shoulder Problems [Updated in 2025].pdf (p18, p69) [2] Senior notes: maxim.md (Sections on shoulder dislocation, clavicle fracture, proximal humerus fracture, elbow injuries, forearm fractures, distal radius fractures, hand injuries, hip anatomy/trauma, tibial plateau fracture, tibial shaft fracture, talar fracture, Lisfranc injury, calcaneal fracture, acetabular fracture, pathological fractures) [3] Lecture slides: GC 232. Paediatric Musculoskeletal Injury [Updated in 2025].pdf (p5, p15, p65, p68, p79) [4] Lecture slides: GC 231. High Energy Trauma Open Fracture_Part 2.pdf [5] Lecture slides: Ryan Ho Radiology.pdf (p1, p6 — pelvic trauma, trauma imaging) [6] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Endocrine.pdf (p47–48 — osteoporosis, bone remodelling, causes and risk factors)
Differential Diagnosis of Common Fractures and Dislocations
The differential diagnosis (DDx) of a suspected fracture or dislocation is not simply "is it broken or not?" — it is a systematic process of distinguishing the specific injury from other conditions that can mimic it. The approach varies by anatomical region, patient age, and mechanism. Below we work through this from first principles: what else could cause the same presentation?
The key principle is: pain, swelling, deformity, and loss of function around a bone or joint can be caused by fracture, dislocation, soft tissue injury, infection, crystal arthropathy, tumour, or referred pathology. Your job is to narrow this down using history (mechanism, timeline, risk factors), examination, and targeted investigations.
When a patient presents with an acutely painful, swollen, deformed, or non-functional limb, the broad differential is:
| Category | Examples | Why It Mimics Fracture/Dislocation |
|---|---|---|
| Fracture | Traumatic, stress, pathological, fragility | Obvious — this is the diagnosis you're trying to confirm or exclude |
| Dislocation / Subluxation | Glenohumeral, elbow, hip, patella, Lisfranc | Loss of joint congruence → pain, deformity, loss of function |
| Fracture-dislocation | Galeazzi, Monteggia, terrible triad, Barton's, Bennett's | Combined bony + joint injury |
| Ligament injury / Sprain | ACL/PCL/MCL/LCL tear, ankle sprain (ATFL), UCL thumb | Swelling, effusion, instability — can mimic fracture on exam. Obvious long bone fracture and knee dislocation are uncommon findings in knee sports injuries [7] — most knee sports injuries are ligamentous |
| Tendon rupture | Achilles, quadriceps, biceps, rotator cuff, extensor tendon (mallet finger), FDP (jersey finger) | Sudden loss of function ± "pop" — resembles avulsion fracture |
| Muscle strain / Contusion | Quadriceps contusion, hamstring strain, calf strain | Pain, swelling, loss of function — but no bony tenderness, X-ray normal |
| Septic arthritis | S. aureus (most common non-gonococcal), gonococcal | Hot, swollen, painful joint with restricted ROM — can mimic intra-articular fracture or dislocation. Must always exclude in an acute monoarthritis [8][9] |
| Crystal arthropathy | Gout (1st MTP, midfoot, ankle, knee), pseudogout (knee) | Acutely inflamed joint — can be intensely painful with swelling and redness mimicking fracture or septic arthritis [8][9] |
| Haemarthrosis | Intra-articular fracture, ACL tear, coagulopathy (e.g. haemophilia), anticoagulant therapy, intra-articular tumour | Rapid joint swelling after injury — the cause of the haemarthrosis must be determined [8][9] |
| Pathological fracture (underlying bone disease) | Osteoporosis, metastasis, myeloma, Paget's, bone cyst, osteosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma | Fracture with minimal or no trauma → suspect underlying disease. Suspect bone metastasis if fracture above T5, constitutional symptoms [2] |
| Stress fracture | Tibial, metatarsal, fibular | Insidious onset pain in an athlete or military recruit — initial X-ray often normal |
| Referred pain | Hip pathology → knee pain; cervical radiculopathy → shoulder/arm pain; lumbar pathology → leg pain | No local signs over the "painful" area; pain pattern follows dermatome or nerve distribution |
| Vascular injury | Acute limb ischaemia (embolism, thrombosis, arterial injury from fractures/dislocations → intimal tear → thrombus formation [10]) | Limb pain, pallor, pulselessness — can coexist with or mimic fracture. Compartment syndrome must be in the DDx of worsening limb pain after injury [11] |
| Non-accidental injury (children) | Multiple fractures at different healing stages, metaphyseal corner fractures | History inconsistent with injury pattern — must consider in all paediatric fractures |
| Osteoarthritis | Weight-bearing joints — can present with acutely painful synovitis mimicking other diagnoses [8][9] | Chronic condition with acute flares — deformity and loss of ROM can mimic fracture |
The Must-Not-Miss DDx
In ANY acute monoarthritis (hot, swollen, painful joint), you must rule out septic arthritis before attributing it to trauma or crystal disease. Septic arthritis is a surgical emergency — a delay of even hours can result in irreversible cartilage destruction. Aspirate the joint and send for Gram stain, culture, crystal analysis, and cell count.
Region-Specific Differential Diagnosis
| Diagnosis | Key Distinguishing Features |
|---|---|
| Anterior shoulder dislocation | Squared-off deltoid, arm in abduction/external rotation, loss of internal rotation, regimental badge numbness (axillary nerve). X-ray confirms |
| Posterior shoulder dislocation | Arm held in adduction/internal rotation, loss of external rotation. Often missed on AP X-ray — need axillary/Y-view. "Lightbulb sign" on AP |
| Proximal humerus fracture | Extensive bruising tracking down arm/chest wall, focal tenderness at surgical neck, axillary nerve/artery injury [2] |
| Clavicle fracture | Focal tenderness, visible deformity, medial fragment elevated (SCM pull) [2] |
| ACJ dislocation | Localised tenderness over ACJ, step deformity, increased coracoclavicular distance on X-ray [2] |
| Rotator cuff tear / syndrome | Pain during activity, passive ROM > active ROM, external rotation spared (infraspinatus + teres minor intact) [2] |
| Frozen shoulder (adhesive capsulitis) | Global limitation of both active AND passive ROM (especially external rotation), night pain, DM association [2] |
| Cervical radiculopathy | Neck pain radiating to arm, dermatomal pattern, weakness, may have Spurling's test positive [2] |
| Biceps tendon rupture | Sudden "pop", Popeye sign (bulging muscle belly), weakness of flexion/supination [2] |
| Diagnosis | Key Distinguishing Features |
|---|---|
| Radial head fracture | FOOSH, elbow effusion (fat pad sign on lateral X-ray), limited pronation/supination [2] |
| Olecranon fracture | Unable to extend elbow against gravity (triceps insertion disrupted), palpable gap, effusion [2] |
| Elbow dislocation | Disrupted equilateral triangle, obvious deformity, limited pronation-supination. Terrible triad: dislocation + radial head fracture + coronoid fracture [2] |
| Supracondylar fracture (children) | S-shaped arm, disrupted anterior humeral line on lateral X-ray, neurovascular compromise (AIN, brachial artery) [2] |
| Epicondylitis (lateral = tennis elbow; medial = golfer's elbow) | Chronic overuse, localised epicondylar tenderness, pain on resisted wrist extension (lateral) or flexion (medial). DDx includes cervical radiculopathy, OA elbow, radial tunnel syndrome [2] |
| Olecranon bursitis | Focal swelling over olecranon, fluctuant, may be septic (erythema, warmth) — joint ROM preserved |
| Diagnosis | Key Distinguishing Features |
|---|---|
| Distal radius fracture (Colles'/Smith/Barton's) | FOOSH, classic deformity (dinner fork/garden spade), 6 radiological features [2] |
| Scaphoid fracture | Anatomical snuffbox tenderness, scaphoid tubercle tenderness, pain on thumb telescoping. DDx: distal radius fracture, fracture of other carpal bones / base of 1st MC, wrist sprain, De Quervain's tenosynovitis [2] |
| De Quervain's tenosynovitis | Pain at radial styloid, positive Finkelstein's test. DDx: 1st CMCJ OA (Grind test+), Wartenberg's syndrome (neuritis of superficial radial nerve), intersection syndrome [2] |
| Mallet finger | Flexed DIP that cannot be actively extended, passive ROM intact — DDx: FDP rupture (jersey finger: can't flex DIP) [2] |
| Boxer's fracture | 5th MC neck fracture from punching — dorsal angulation [2] |
| Bennett's fracture | 1st MC base intra-articular fracture — forced abduction of thumb [2] |
| Tendon sheath infection | Kanavel signs (flexed digit, fusiform swelling, flexor sheath tenderness, pain on passive extension) — surgical emergency [2] |
| Diagnosis | Key Distinguishing Features |
|---|---|
| #NOF (intracapsular) | Shortened, externally rotated leg, groin tenderness, pain on internal rotation. Garden classification. High AVN risk [2] |
| #NOF (extracapsular) | Similar but more swelling/bruising (haematoma not contained by capsule) [2] |
| Acetabular fracture | High-energy injury, similar to #NOF presentation, Morel-Lavallée lesion, Judet views [2] |
| Hip dislocation (posterior) | Shortened, flexed, adducted, internally rotated limb — opposite to #NOF (externally rotated). Dashboard injury. Sciatic nerve at risk |
| Pubic ramus fracture | Low-energy in elderly, groin/anterior thigh pain, tenderness over pubic rami — often missed or coexists with #NOF |
| Septic arthritis of hip | Fever, acutely painful restricted ROM (especially internal rotation), inflammatory markers raised |
| OA hip | Chronic pain, insidious onset, pain on weight-bearing with stiffness, X-ray: loss of joint space, osteophytes |
| AVN femoral head | Groin pain, loss of ROM, risk factors (steroids, alcohol, sickle cell, hip fracture) — MRI diagnostic |
| Referred pain from lumbar spine | Back pain, radiculopathy, dermatomal pattern — hip exam may be normal |
The differential diagnosis of knee pain is extensive and location-dependent [7]:
| Location | Differential Diagnoses |
|---|---|
| Anterior | Patellofemoral pain syndrome, patellar subluxation/dislocation, quadriceps tendonitis, chondromalacia patellae, tibial apophysitis (Osgood-Schlatter), patellar tendonitis (jumper's knee), prepatellar bursitis (housemaid's knee), arthritis [7] |
| Medial | MCL sprain, medial meniscal tear, pes anserine bursitis, medial plica syndrome [7] |
| Lateral | LCL sprain, lateral meniscal tear, iliotibial band tendonitis [7] |
| Posterior | Popliteal cyst (Baker's cyst), PCL injury [7] |
| Specific DDx | Key Features |
|---|---|
| Patella fracture | Direct fall or sudden quadriceps contraction, inability to SLR, palpable defect. DDx: other fractures (tibial plateau, distal femur), cruciate/collateral ligament injury, quadriceps tendon rupture [2] |
| Patella dislocation | Lateral displacement, apprehension test positive with lateral push. Risk factors: young obese female, patella alta, wide Q angle, genu valgum, shallow patellofemoral groove [2] |
| Tibial plateau fracture | High-energy, lipohaemarthrosis, popliteal artery/common peroneal nerve at risk [2] |
| Distal femur fracture | Knee effusion (intra-articular extension), severe distal thigh pain [2] |
| Knee dislocation | A majority of post-knee dislocation X-rays appear "normal" because of spontaneous reduction — high degree of suspicion is required to make the correct diagnosis [7]. Must assess popliteal artery (CT angiography) and common peroneal nerve |
| Ligament injuries (ACL/PCL/MCL/LCL) | Mechanism-dependent, instability testing (Lachman, anterior/posterior drawer, valgus/varus stress). Obvious long bone fracture and knee dislocation are uncommon findings in knee sports injuries [7] |
Knee Dislocation — Don't Miss the Vessel!
A majority of post-knee dislocation X-rays appear "normal" because of spontaneous reduction [7]. If you suspect knee dislocation (multi-ligament injury pattern, significant instability), you MUST get a CT angiogram to rule out popliteal artery injury — even if the X-ray looks normal and pulses are palpable. An intimal tear can occlude hours later.
| Diagnosis | Key Features |
|---|---|
| Ankle fracture (Weber A/B/C) | Malleolar tenderness, inability to weight-bear, X-ray confirms |
| Ankle sprain (lateral ligament) | ATFL most common, anterior drawer test positive, no bony tenderness (use Ottawa rules to decide on X-ray) |
| Tibial pilon fracture | High-energy axial load (fall from height/RTA), severe ankle deformity, talus punches up onto tibial plafond [2] |
| Calcaneal fracture | Fall from height, heel pain, flattened Böhler's angle, associated lumbar spine fracture (10%) [2] |
| Talar fracture | Forced dorsiflexion, high AVN risk (Hawkins classification) [2] |
| Lisfranc injury | Midfoot pain/swelling, plantar bruising, piano-key sign, fleck sign on X-ray, widened 1st-2nd MT interval [2] |
| 5th MT base fracture | Avulsion by peroneus brevis, lateral foot tenderness — part of the Ottawa Foot Rules |
| Achilles tendon rupture | Sudden "pop" in calf, positive Thompson test (no plantarflexion on calf squeeze), palpable gap |
| Stress fracture (metatarsal, navicular) | Insidious onset pain in athlete, localised tenderness, initial X-ray often normal — MRI or bone scan needed |
The differential diagnosis of back pain is broad [12]:
| Category | Examples |
|---|---|
| Mechanical pain (~97%) | Back sprain ( > 70%), lumbar disc degeneration, lumbar disc herniation, spondylolisthesis, fracture (vertebral body, spondylolysis) [12] |
| Non-mechanical pain (~3%) | Neoplasia, inflammatory arthritis (AS/spondyloarthropathy), infection [12] |
| Non-spinal (referred) | Pelvic inflammatory disease, endometriosis, nephrolithiasis, pyelonephritis, aortic aneurysm [12] |
For vertebral compression fractures specifically, distinguish:
- Osteoporotic fragility fracture: low-energy, elderly, known risk factors [2]
- Pathological fracture from metastasis: suspect if above T5, constitutional symptoms, night pain, weight loss [2]
- Traumatic fracture: adequate mechanism (fall from height, RTA)
- Chance fracture (seatbelt fracture): horizontal fracture of upper lumbar spine, distraction injury of posterior column in passenger with lap belt only [5]
When a patient with a known fracture has worsening or disproportionate pain, consider these critical DDx:
| Complication | Key Features | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Compartment syndrome | Severe pain disproportional to clinical picture, unrelieved by analgesia. Pain on passive stretching of digits. Severe swelling, tense and shiny skin. Sensory deficit, later paralysis. Pulses always palpable [11] | Fracture haematoma + tissue oedema within a non-expansile fascial compartment → ↑intracompartmental pressure → muscle and nerve ischaemia. Pulses are always palpable because compartment pressure rarely exceeds systolic arterial pressure — absence of pulse is a VERY late sign |
| Acute limb ischaemia | 6 Ps: Pain, Pallor, Pulselessness, Paraesthesia, Paralysis, Poikilothermia | Fractures/dislocations → arterial stretching → intimal tear → thrombus formation [10]. Direct vessel laceration by fracture fragment |
| Fat embolism syndrome | Petechiae (axillae, conjunctivae), respiratory distress, confusion — 24–72h after long bone fracture | Fat globules from bone marrow enter the venous system → lodge in pulmonary and cerebral vasculature |
| Deep vein thrombosis | Calf/thigh swelling, tenderness, warmth | Immobility + endothelial injury + hypercoagulable state (Virchow's triad) |
| Infection | Increasing pain, erythema, discharge, fever — especially in open fractures | Direct contamination of wound → bacterial colonisation |
Compartment Syndrome — The Key DDx Point
Compartment syndrome is mainly a clinical diagnosis [11]. Do NOT wait for absent pulses — pulses are always palpable because compartment pressure exceeds venous/capillary pressure but rarely exceeds arterial pressure. The earliest reliable sign is pain on passive stretching of the affected muscles (e.g., passive dorsiflexion of great toe for anterior compartment of leg). If in doubt, measure compartment pressure (Stryker monitor) — fasciotomy is indicated if pressure > 30 mmHg or within 30 mmHg of diastolic pressure (delta pressure < 30 mmHg).
The following flowchart illustrates the DDx approach to an acute limb injury:
In children, the differential is different because of the unique biology of the immature skeleton:
| Condition | Why It's in the DDx |
|---|---|
| Physeal (growth plate) injury | May be radiographically occult (Type I Salter-Harris = no fracture line visible on X-ray). Tenderness over the growth plate in a child = physeal injury until proven otherwise, even with normal X-rays |
| Greenstick / Torus fracture | Incomplete fractures can be subtle on X-ray — look carefully at the cortex |
| Pulled elbow (nursery maid's elbow) | Subluxation of the annular ligament over the radial head in toddlers — no fracture, no X-ray abnormality. Diagnosis is clinical (sudden arm disuse after traction on an extended, pronated forearm). Treated by supination-flexion manoeuvre |
| Osteomyelitis | Fever, bony tenderness, refusal to use limb — mimics fracture. Must exclude in a child with limb pain and fever |
| Non-accidental injury | Unexplained or inconsistent injuries, multiple fractures at different stages of healing |
| Bone tumours | Osteosarcoma (metaphyseal, around the knee, age 10–20), Ewing sarcoma (diaphyseal, "onion-skin" periosteal reaction). Present with pain ± pathological fracture |
| Perthes disease | Idiopathic AVN of femoral epiphysis, boys 5–10, hip pain with loss of internal rotation — DDx of hip pain in children |
| SCFE | Slipped capital femoral epiphysis, obese boys 10–15, hip/knee pain, loss of internal rotation. DDx of hip/knee pain in adolescents |
High Yield Summary
DDx Framework for Fractures and Dislocations:
- Always consider the 5 categories: Fracture/dislocation → Soft tissue injury (ligament/tendon/muscle) → Infection (septic arthritis) → Crystal arthropathy → Pathological/referred.
- Acute monoarthritis = must rule out septic arthritis (aspirate the joint) before anything else [8][9].
- Knee sports injuries: fracture and dislocation are uncommon — most injuries are ligamentous [7].
- Post-knee dislocation X-rays often appear normal due to spontaneous reduction — maintain high suspicion and get CT angiography [7].
- Compartment syndrome: pain disproportional to injury, unrelieved by analgesia, pain on passive stretch, pulses always palpable [11]. Clinical diagnosis — do not wait for late signs.
- Pathological fracture: suspect if minimal/no trauma, above T5, constitutional symptoms → investigate underlying cause [2].
- Scaphoid fracture: clinical suspicion may outweigh normal initial X-ray → treat with thumb spica and re-image at 14 days [2].
- In children: physeal injury until proven otherwise if tenderness over growth plate; always consider NAI, osteomyelitis, bone tumours.
- Referred pain: hip → knee (shared innervation); cervical spine → shoulder/arm; lumbar spine → leg [2].
- Mechanical back pain accounts for ~97% of back pain; non-mechanical (~3%) includes neoplasia, infection, and inflammatory arthritis [12].
Active Recall - DDx of Common Fractures and Dislocations
References
[2] Senior notes: maxim.md (Sections on shoulder dislocation, clavicle fracture, proximal humerus, elbow injuries, forearm fractures, distal radius, hand injuries, scaphoid fracture, De Quervain's, hip anatomy/trauma, #NOF, patella fracture/dislocation, tibial plateau, tibial shaft, calcaneus, talus, Lisfranc, acetabular fracture, spine DDx, pathological fractures, epicondylitis, radial head fracture) [5] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Radiology.pdf (p1, p6 — pelvic trauma, Chance fracture) [7] Lecture slides: GC 230. Knee Sport Injuries_Part 1.pdf (p62, p65) [8] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Fundamentals.pdf (p406 — Approach to Acute Monoarthritis) [9] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Rheumatology.pdf (p28 — Approach to Acute Monoarthritis) [10] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Cardiology.pdf (p208 — Acute Limb Ischaemia, arterial trauma) [11] Lecture slides: GC 231. High Energy Trauma Open Fracture_Part 3.pdf (p4 — Compartment syndrome) [12] Lecture slides: GC 226. Lumbar Spine Pathology_Part E (2).pdf (p2 — DDx of back pain)
Diagnostic Criteria, Diagnostic Algorithm, and Investigation Modalities
Unlike many medical conditions (e.g., diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis) that have formal diagnostic criteria with sensitivity/specificity data, fractures and dislocations are diagnosed through a combination of clinical assessment (history + examination) and imaging confirmation. There are no "diagnostic criteria" in the traditional sense (no scoring systems or point-based classification) — instead, the diagnosis rests on:
- Clinical suspicion based on mechanism of injury, symptoms, and signs
- Imaging confirmation (primarily plain radiography)
- Classification of the confirmed injury to guide management
The key diagnostic challenge is not "is it broken?" when a deformity is obvious, but rather:
- Detecting occult fractures (normal initial X-ray but fracture present — e.g., scaphoid, stress fractures, undisplaced #NOF)
- Detecting associated injuries (neurovascular injury, compartment syndrome, second fracture in ring structures)
- Detecting underlying pathology in atraumatic or low-energy fractures (osteoporosis, metastasis)
- Recognising spontaneously reduced dislocations that appear normal on imaging — a majority of post-knee dislocation X-rays appear "normal" because of spontaneous reduction — high degree of suspicion is required to make the correct diagnosis [7]
Clinical Decision Rules
While fractures and dislocations lack formal "diagnostic criteria," several validated clinical decision rules guide the need for imaging:
These rules were developed to reduce unnecessary X-rays for ankle injuries. An ankle X-ray is indicated if there is:
- Any pain in the malleolar zone AND any one of:
- Bone tenderness at distal 6 cm of posterior edge of tibia or tip of medial malleolus
- Bone tenderness at distal 6 cm of posterior edge of fibula or tip of lateral malleolus
- Inability to bear weight immediately after injury AND in the Emergency Department for 4 steps
Why posterior edge? Because the most clinically significant malleolar fractures involve the posterior cortex of the distal tibia and fibula. Tenderness over the anterior border is more likely to represent a ligament injury.
A foot X-ray is indicated if there is:
- Midfoot pain AND any one of:
- Bone tenderness at the base of the 5th metatarsal
- Bone tenderness at the navicular
- Inability to bear weight immediately and in the Emergency Department for 4 steps
The Ottawa rules have a sensitivity of ~98–100% for significant fractures (very few false negatives) but moderate specificity (~40%) — meaning they effectively rule out fracture when negative but still lead to many normal X-rays when positive.
A knee X-ray is indicated if any of:
- Age ≥ 55
- Isolated patella tenderness
- Tenderness at fibular head
- Inability to flex knee to 90°
- Inability to bear weight immediately and in the Emergency Department for 4 steps
Used to decide whether cervical spine imaging is needed after trauma (addressed in spine-specific notes but important in polytrauma context).
Radiographic Criteria for Specific Fractures
Once imaging is obtained, specific radiographic measurements serve as diagnostic and treatment-guiding criteria:
| Measurement | Normal Value | Criteria for Instability / Indication for ORIF |
|---|---|---|
| Radial height (AP view) | 11 mm | > 5 mm shortening |
| Radial inclination (AP view) | 22° | Change > 5° |
| Articular step-off (AP view) | Congruous | Intra-articular fracture with > 2 mm step-off |
| Volar tilt (Lateral view) | 11° volar | Dorsal angulation > 5° or > 20° difference from contralateral |
| Others | — | Associated ulnar fracture (NOT ulnar styloid #), comminuted fracture |
Why do these measurements matter? The distal radius articulates with the carpus and the ulna at the DRUJ. Any loss of radial height, inclination, or tilt changes the load distribution across the wrist joint → accelerates degenerative change and causes mechanical dysfunction. The threshold values represent the point beyond which functional outcomes significantly worsen if not corrected.
- On AP pelvis X-ray: a smooth curving line formed by the medial edge of the femoral neck and the inferior edge of the superior pubic ramus
- Disrupted Shenton's line = femoral neck fracture until proven otherwise
- Also look for: prominent lesser trochanter (external rotation), higher lesser trochanter (shortening)
- Garden I–II = undisplaced → internal fixation
- Garden III–IV = displaced → arthroplasty (elderly) or ORIF (young)
- Measured on lateral X-ray foot: angle between a line from the posterior tuberosity to the highest point of the posterior facet, and a line from this point to the highest point of the anterior process
- Normal: 25–40°
- Flattened (< 25°) = calcaneal compression fracture
- On any elbow X-ray view: a line through the centre of the radial shaft should always pass through the centre of the capitellum
- Disrupted line → radial head dislocation (key finding in Monteggia fracture-dislocation)
- On lateral elbow X-ray: a line along the anterior cortex of the humerus should pass through the middle third of the capitellum
- Displaced anteriorly or posteriorly → supracondylar fracture (especially important in children)
- C1 level: prevertebral soft tissue ≤ 10 mm
- C3 level: ≤ 7 mm (the "3×7=21 rule")
- C7 level: ≤ 21 mm
- Widening suggests haematoma from occult fracture
- 4 lines on lateral X-ray should be smooth: anterior vertebral line, posterior vertebral line, spinolaminar line, tips of spinous processes
- 3 lines on AP view should be smooth: spinous processes (midline), lateral masses, vertebral body margins
- Malalignment of any line → fracture or ligamentous injury until proven otherwise
Investigation Modalities — Comprehensive Guide
Plain X-ray is the first-line investigation because it requires no patient movement, is readily available, fast, inexpensive, and has the highest spatial resolution for detecting fractures [5][13].
Principles:
- Most films require ≥ 2 views because fractures may be detected only in one view [13] — typically AP + lateral as minimum
- X-ray can only distinguish between four densities: calcium (bone), water (soft tissue), fat, and air [13]
- 2-D representation of 3-D structures → overlapping may be present → use different angles to remedy [13]
- Always request imaging of the entire bone (including the joint above and below) — fractures can propagate, and associated injuries at distant sites can be missed
Standard Views by Region:
| Region | Standard Views | Special Views | What They Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shoulder | AP, Y-view (scapular lateral) | Axillary view | Axillary view essential for posterior dislocation (often missed on AP alone). Y-view shows direction of dislocation [2] |
| Clavicle | AP | Zanca view (15° cephalic tilt) | Zanca view for ACJ assessment [2] |
| Elbow | AP + lateral | — | Lateral must be true lateral (trochlea overlaps capitellum). Check anterior humeral line, radiocapitellar line, fat pad signs [2] |
| Forearm | AP + lateral (including wrist and elbow) | — | Must include both joints to detect Galeazzi (DRUJ) and Monteggia (PRUJ) injuries |
| Wrist | AP + lateral | Scaphoid view (30° extension, 20° ulnar deviation) | Scaphoid view for suspected scaphoid fracture [2][13] |
| Hand | AP, lateral, oblique | — | Oblique view helps detect subtle metacarpal fractures |
| Pelvis | AP | Judet views (45° obliques) for acetabular fracture, inlet/outlet views for pelvic ring | Pelvis is a ring: if there is one fracture, there must be another one [5] |
| Hip | AP + lateral (cross-table lateral) | — | Look for Shenton's line disruption, trabecular pattern (Garden classification) [2] |
| Femur | AP + lateral (entire femur including hip and knee) | — | 10% incidence of ipsilateral femoral neck fracture with shaft fracture [2] |
| Knee | AP + lateral | Skyline view (for patella) | Skyline view for patellar fracture/dislocation. Most significant X-ray findings in knee sports injuries may appear "subtle" [7] |
| Tibia/Fibula | AP + lateral (including knee and ankle) | — | Must include both joints |
| Ankle | AP, lateral, mortise view (20° internal rotation) | — | Mortise view provides a uniform joint space to assess talar shift and syndesmotic widening [2] |
| Foot | AP, lateral, oblique | Weight-bearing views if able | For Lisfranc injury: look for fleck sign, widened 1st–2nd MT interval [2] |
| C-spine | AP + lateral | Open-mouth (odontoid/peg) view | Lateral C-spine: C7-T1 must be visualised to detect Clay-Shoveler's fracture [5]. Open-mouth view for C1-2 assessment [14] |
| Thoracolumbar spine | AP + lateral | — | Look for compression fractures, vertebral body height loss, retropulsion |
Key X-ray Findings and Their Interpretation:
| Finding | Interpretation | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Fat pad sign / Sail sign (elbow lateral) | Elbow effusion → occult fracture (most commonly radial head fracture) | Intra-articular haematoma pushes fat pads out of the coronoid and olecranon fossae. Posterior fat pad is always abnormal; anterior "sail" suggests significant effusion [2] |
| Lipohaemarthrosis (knee lateral) | Intra-articular fracture (e.g., tibial plateau) | Fat from bone marrow + blood layer in the joint → fat-fluid level visible on horizontal-beam lateral view. Pathognomonic of intra-articular fracture [2] |
| Disrupted Shenton's line (pelvis AP) | Femoral neck fracture | The smooth arc is broken by displacement or angulation of the fracture fragments [2] |
| Disrupted radiocapitellar line (elbow) | Radial head dislocation (Monteggia) | The radius should always "point at" the capitellum on every view [2] |
| Disrupted anterior humeral line (elbow lateral) | Supracondylar fracture | Posterior displacement of the capitellum relative to the humeral shaft [2] |
| Flattened Böhler's angle (foot lateral) | Calcaneal compression fracture | Loss of the normal posterior facet height [2] |
| Fleck sign (foot AP) | Lisfranc ligament avulsion | Small bony fragment between 1st and 2nd MT bases = avulsed Lisfranc ligament [2] |
| Widened mediastinum (CXR) | Aortic injury | In the context of high-energy chest trauma — not a fracture finding per se but essential in polytrauma [5] |
| Lightbulb sign (shoulder AP) | Posterior shoulder dislocation | Internally rotated humeral head appears round/symmetric like a lightbulb — posterior dislocation is classically missed on AP X-ray |
Systematic X-ray Interpretation — The ABCS Approach:
| Step | Component | What to Assess |
|---|---|---|
| A | Adequacy + Alignment | Correct patient, correct side, adequate exposure, all relevant anatomy included. Alignment of bone/joint lines |
| B | Bone | Cortical continuity (fracture lines), bone density, periosteal reaction, lytic/scite lesions |
| C | Cartilage / Joint space | Joint space width (narrowing = OA/cartilage loss; widening = effusion/ligament injury), congruence of articular surfaces |
| S | Soft tissue | Soft tissue swelling, fat pad displacement (elbow), lipohaemarthrosis (knee), air in soft tissues (open fracture), foreign bodies |
Fracture X-ray Interpretation — Systematic Description [2]:
| Element | What to Report |
|---|---|
| Site | Which bone, which part (epiphyseal, metaphyseal, diaphyseal), intra-articular vs extra-articular |
| Integrity of skin | Closed (skin intact) vs Open (communication with external environment) |
| Morphology | Transverse (< 30°), Oblique (30–60°), Spiral, Butterfly, Comminuted ( > 2 fragments), Avulsion, Impacted/Compression |
| Alignment | Displacement (non-displaced, displaced, translated), Angulation (varus, valgus, apex anterior/posterior), Length (impacted, distracted), Rotation |
| Associated injuries | Fracture-dislocation (e.g., Monteggia, Galeazzi), second fracture in ring structures, joint incongruence |
Paediatric X-ray interpretation requires additional attention [2]:
- Specific morphology due to more active periosteum: bowing (plastic deformation), greenstick (one cortex breaks), buckled/torus (impacted cortex)
- Epiphyseal injury: physis is the weakest part → susceptible to fracture → Salter-Harris classification
- Comparison views of the contralateral limb may be needed to distinguish a physis from a fracture line (secondary ossification centres in children can mimic fractures)
The Invisible Fracture — When X-ray Is Normal But Fracture Is Present
Several fractures are notoriously difficult to see on initial X-ray:
- Scaphoid fracture: initial X-ray is normal in up to 20% of cases. Bone resorption at the fracture site makes the line visible on repeat X-ray at 10–14 days [2]
- Stress fracture: may not show until periosteal reaction/callus forms at 2–3 weeks
- Undisplaced #NOF: may need MRI for confirmation
- Posterior shoulder dislocation: often appears "normal" on AP X-ray — need axillary or Y-view
- Knee dislocation with spontaneous reduction: X-ray appears completely normal [7]
If clinical suspicion is high but X-ray is negative, treat the patient and get further imaging (MRI, CT, repeat X-ray). Do NOT discharge with false reassurance.
CT is the best modality for organ/vascular injury and provides superior bony detail compared to plain X-ray [5].
Indications in fractures/dislocations:
| Indication | Rationale | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-operative planning | CT shows fracture geometry in 3D — essential for complex intra-articular fractures | Tibial plateau (Schatzker), acetabular (Judet-Letournel), calcaneus (Sanders), proximal humerus (Neer), distal femur (Hoffa) |
| Occult fracture | Detects fractures invisible on plain X-ray | Scaphoid, #NOF (if MRI not available), C-spine fractures |
| Intra-articular extension | Determines if a fracture line enters the joint | Tibial shaft spiral fracture → CT to rule out posterior malleolus fracture [2] |
| Polytrauma / high-energy injury | CT is the workhorse of trauma assessment | CT: main role in pelvic fractures is to diagnose associated injuries including haematoma (vascular injury), visceral injury (bladder, bowel) [5] |
| CT angiography | Vascular injury assessment | Knee dislocation (popliteal artery), pelvic fracture (haemorrhage source), tibial plateau fracture |
| Spinal fracture | Clearer visualisation of fractures than plain X-ray but still cannot show soft-tissue injury [14] | Cervical, thoracic, lumbar fractures for operative planning |
Key CT Findings:
| Finding | Significance |
|---|---|
| Fracture lines not visible on X-ray | Confirms occult fracture |
| Articular step-off | Quantifies intra-articular incongruity → determines need for surgical reduction |
| Comminution | Determines fracture complexity → guides fixation strategy |
| Contrast extravasation (CT angiography) | Active bleeding → may need embolisation or surgical exploration [5] |
| Gas in bladder | Indicates bladder rupture in pelvic fractures [5] |
| Free pelvic fluid | Haemorrhage from pelvic fracture |
MRI excels at soft tissue assessment — it shows things that CT and X-ray cannot.
Indications:
| Indication | Rationale | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Occult fracture with negative X-ray | MRI detects bone marrow oedema at the fracture site — 100% sensitivity | Scaphoid, #NOF, stress fracture, insufficiency fracture |
| Ligament / tendon / meniscal injury | Soft tissue contrast is superior | ACL/PCL/MCL/LCL tears, meniscal tears, rotator cuff tears, Achilles tendon rupture, SLAP tear (MRI arthrogram) [2] |
| Avascular necrosis | Detects early AVN before X-ray changes appear | Femoral head AVN (post-#NOF), scaphoid AVN, talar AVN, Kienböck's disease (lunate AVN) [2] |
| Spinal cord / soft tissue compression | Difficult to arrange but shows soft-tissue lesion, cord oedema [14] | Disc herniation, epidural haematoma, ligamentous instability of spine |
| Bone tumour characterisation | Defines tumour extent, soft tissue involvement, skip lesions | Osteosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma, metastatic deposits |
| Non-accidental injury | Identifies occult fractures in multiple locations | Paediatric NAI — skeletal survey + MRI if needed |
Key MRI Findings:
| Finding | Significance |
|---|---|
| Bone marrow oedema (high T2/STIR signal) | Fracture, contusion, stress reaction, AVN |
| Disrupted ligament signal | Ligament tear (high signal within normally dark ligament on T2) |
| Joint effusion (high T2 signal) | Reactive effusion or haemarthrosis |
| AVN | Low signal on T1 in the femoral head/scaphoid/talus — death of bone |
| Cord signal change | Oedema (T2 bright) → cord compression/contusion in spinal injury |
| Indication | Rationale | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Free intra-abdominal fluid in trauma (FAST scan) | Presence indicates significant injury → should do further imaging or interventions. Location of fluid indicates site of injury [5] | Polytrauma assessment |
| Effusion detection | Quick bedside assessment | Hip effusion (children — septic arthritis vs transient synovitis), knee effusion |
| Tendon assessment | First-line for tendon pathology | Biceps tendon rupture (localise distal end), Achilles tendon rupture, rotator cuff tears [2] |
| DVT | Duplex USG for DVT screening | Delayed presentation of #NOF [2] |
| Guided aspiration | USG-guided joint aspiration for monoarthritis | Septic arthritis, crystal arthropathy |
USG advantages: fast. Disadvantages: operator dependent, often obscured by bowel gas [5]
| Indication | Rationale |
|---|---|
| Stress fracture | Increased uptake at the fracture site before X-ray changes appear (high sensitivity but low specificity) |
| Occult fracture (when MRI unavailable) | Detects increased bone turnover at fracture site |
| Pathological fracture work-up | Whole-body bone scan to identify multiple metastatic deposits |
| Infection (osteomyelitis) | Increased uptake but not specific — triple-phase bone scan helps differentiate |
| AVN | "Cold spot" (photopenic area) due to absent blood supply |
Not used for fracture diagnosis per se, but essential in the work-up of fragility fractures to diagnose and quantify osteoporosis [6]:
- T-score ≥ –1.0: Normal
- T-score between –1.0 and –2.5: Osteopenia
- T-score ≤ –2.5: Osteoporosis
- T-score ≤ –2.5 with fragility fracture: Established osteoporosis
T-score = (Patient's BMD – mean BMD of young adult women) / SD. Each 1 SD decrease in BMD = 2× increased risk of hip fracture [6].
Lab tests are not used to diagnose fractures themselves but are essential for:
| Investigation | Indication | Key Findings |
|---|---|---|
| FBC | Polytrauma (blood loss), infection | Anaemia (haemorrhage), leukocytosis (infection) |
| U&E, Creatinine | Crush syndrome, rhabdomyolysis | Hyperkalaemia (reperfusion injury), raised creatinine |
| CK / Myoglobin | Crush syndrome, compartment syndrome | Markedly elevated CK |
| Coagulation (PT, APTT) | Massive haemorrhage, anticoagulant therapy | Coagulopathy → correct before surgery |
| Group & Save / Cross-match | Anticipated blood loss (femoral shaft, pelvis) | — |
| Bone profile (Ca, PO₄, ALP, Vit D, PTH) | Pathological fracture, osteoporosis work-up | Hypercalcaemia (malignancy, hyperparathyroidism), low Vit D, raised ALP |
| Serum/urine protein electrophoresis | Suspected myeloma | Paraprotein band (M-spike) |
| Tumour markers (PSA, etc.) | Suspected metastatic disease | Raised PSA (prostate met) |
| ESR/CRP | Infection (osteomyelitis, septic arthritis) | Elevated inflammatory markers |
| Joint aspirate | Acute monoarthritis (septic vs crystal vs haemarthrosis) | WBC > 50,000 + positive Gram stain/culture = septic arthritis; negatively birefringent crystals = gout; positively birefringent rhomboid crystals = pseudogout; fat globules = intra-articular fracture |
| Compartment pressure (Stryker monitor) | Suspected compartment syndrome | Absolute pressure > 30 mmHg or delta pressure (diastolic – compartment pressure) < 30 mmHg → fasciotomy |
Special Investigation Scenarios — Decision Points
- Clinical features present (snuffbox tenderness, scaphoid tubercle tenderness, pain on thumb telescoping)
- Initial X-ray (AP, lateral, scaphoid view) → normal
- Treat as scaphoid fracture: thumb spica cast immobilisation
- Repeat X-ray at 10–14 days (bone resorption at fracture site → fracture line becomes visible)
- If still equivocal → MRI wrist (gold standard for occult scaphoid fracture)
- Elderly patient, fall, groin pain, unable to weight-bear, pain on internal rotation
- AP + lateral X-ray hip → normal
- MRI hip (within 24h if available) → bone marrow oedema confirms fracture
- If MRI unavailable → CT hip or bone scan (less sensitive than MRI for undisplaced fractures)
- Pelvic XR in primary survey → identify obvious fractures
- CT pelvis with contrast → assess for:
- Fracture extent and classification
- Haematoma / contrast extravasation (vascular injury → may need angiographic embolisation)
- Visceral injury (gas in bladder = bladder rupture)
- If haemodynamically unstable → pelvic binder → CT when stabilised → interventional radiology if active bleeding
- AP + lateral X-ray tibia/fibula → spiral fracture identified
- CT scan indicated to:
- Rule out fracture extension to posterior malleolus (intra-articular extension to the ankle)
- Assess for any other fracture lines
- Plain X-ray: readily available, shows obvious fracture and malalignment, can miss subtle fracture, cannot exclude ligamentous instability, cannot exclude soft-tissue compressive lesion (e.g., haematoma) [14]
- CT spine: reasonably available, still cannot show soft-tissue injury — but superior for bony detail [14]
- MRI spine: difficult to arrange but shows soft-tissue lesion, cord oedema — essential for detecting disc herniation, epidural haematoma, ligamentous injury, cord compression [14]
High Yield Summary
Investigations for Fractures and Dislocations — Key Principles:
- Plain X-ray is first-line — minimum 2 views; highest spatial resolution for bone but poor soft tissue contrast [5][13].
- Ottawa Ankle Rules: validated clinical decision rule — bone tenderness at posterior malleolar edges or inability to bear weight for 4 steps → X-ray indicated [2].
- Systematic X-ray interpretation: Site → Skin integrity → Morphology → Alignment → Associated injuries (ABCS approach) [2].
- Key radiographic lines: radiocapitellar line (Monteggia), anterior humeral line (supracondylar), Shenton's line (#NOF), Böhler's angle (calcaneus) [2].
- Distal radius instability criteria: > 5mm shortening, > 5° inclination change, > 2mm articular step-off, dorsal angulation > 5° → ORIF [2].
- CT: best for pre-operative planning (complex intra-articular fractures), polytrauma (associated injuries), and vascular assessment (CT angiography) [5].
- MRI: best for occult fractures (bone marrow oedema), soft tissue injuries, AVN, and spinal cord assessment — shows soft-tissue lesion and cord oedema [14].
- Occult fractures: if clinical suspicion high but X-ray negative → immobilise + repeat X-ray at 10–14 days or MRI [2].
- Lab investigations: not for fracture diagnosis but essential for assessing complications (crush syndrome, blood loss, compartment syndrome) and underlying pathology (osteoporosis, malignancy, infection).
- Post-knee dislocation X-rays are often normal due to spontaneous reduction — clinical suspicion + CT angiography is mandatory [7].
- DEXA: for osteoporosis diagnosis in fragility fracture work-up. T-score ≤ –2.5 = osteoporosis [6].
Active Recall - Diagnosis and Investigations of Common Fractures and Dislocations
References
[2] Senior notes: maxim.md (Fracture XR interpretation, distal radius fracture radiographic criteria, Frykman classification, scaphoid fracture investigations, #NOF investigation and radiological features, elbow XR lines, forearm fracture-dislocations, olecranon fracture, elbow dislocation, proximal humerus investigations, femoral shaft investigations, distal femur investigations, tibial plateau investigation, tibial shaft investigation, ankle sprain Ottawa rules, ankle fracture, calcaneal fracture investigations, talar fracture investigation, Lisfranc radiological features, ACJ dislocation XR, patella dislocation XR, cervical spine soft tissue rules, paediatric XR interpretation) [5] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Radiology.pdf (p1 — principles of trauma imaging, standard trauma series, modalities; p3 — rib fracture; p6 — pelvic fracture CT findings) [6] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Endocrine.pdf (p49 — DEXA interpretation, T-score, osteoporosis diagnosis) [7] Lecture slides: GC 230. Knee Sport Injuries_Part 1.pdf (p62 — fracture/dislocation uncommon in knee sports injuries; p64 — subtle X-ray findings) [13] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Diagnostic Radiology.pdf (p13 — plain film radiography principles, special views, spatial resolution) [14] Lecture slides: GC 110. Paraplegia Spinal cord compression Transverse myelitis Spinal dysraphism Neuroimaging III Spinal Cord.pdf (p14 — X-ray, CT, MRI of spine)
Management of Common Fractures and Dislocations
The management of fractures and dislocations follows a logical hierarchy dictated by threat to life, threat to limb, and then restoration of function. Every decision cascades from a simple question: what is the most dangerous thing happening right now?
Life-threatening injuries take priority [15]:
- Non-orthopaedic: airway obstruction, tension pneumothorax, massive haemorrhage from non-skeletal sources
- Orthopaedic: haemorrhage, major crush injury, proximal amputation, multiple fractures [15]
Limb-threatening injuries come next [15]:
- Vascular injury
- Compartment syndrome
- Dislocation of major joints
- Open fractures [15]
Priorities in management of multiple fractures [15]:
- Open fractures with significant bleeding
- Unstable pelvic fractures
- Spinal fractures
- Femoral shaft fractures
- Other long bone fractures
The logic here is straightforward: stop the patient dying → stop the limb dying → fix the bone. An unstable pelvic fracture can exsanguinate a patient in minutes; a femoral shaft can lose > 1.5L of blood; open fractures with significant bleeding need urgent haemostasis. Spinal fractures are prioritised because further displacement can cause irreversible cord injury.
| Step | Action | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| ABC | Resuscitation (ATLS protocol) | Life before limb — always |
| Anti-swelling | RICE (Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation) | Reduce oedema, limit secondary soft tissue damage |
| Analgesics | Immobilisation is the best analgesic; pharmacological analgesia (paracetamol, NSAIDs, opioids) | Fracture fragments grinding = pain → muscle spasm → more displacement → more pain (vicious cycle). Immobilisation breaks this cycle |
| Anaesthesia | Prepare for theatre if operative management anticipated | NPO, consent, pre-op bloods |
| Anchorage | Temporary splinting (slab, Thomas splint for femoral shaft, neck collar for C-spine, pelvic binder) | Prevents further displacement, controls bleeding, reduces pain, protects neurovascular structures |
| Anti-sepsis | Wound cleansing and dressing (remove gross debris but NOT bone fragments); cover with sterile dressing; IV antibiotics for open fractures; tetanus prophylaxis | Prevents infection — the single greatest threat to outcome in open fractures |
The 3R Framework — Management of Closed Fractures [2]
Definition: restoring the fracture fragments to acceptable alignment.
Aims [2]:
- Tamponade bleeding (realigned bone ± splint compresses the fracture haematoma)
- Restore blood supply (displaced fragments can kink or stretch vessels)
- Reduce traction on nerves (displacement stretches nerves → neuropraxia)
- Reduce traction on soft tissue (displaced fragments increase compartment pressure)
When is reduction NOT indicated? [2]:
- No or little displacement (already in acceptable alignment)
- Reduction unlikely to succeed (e.g., compression fracture of vertebrae — you cannot "uncrush" cancellous bone)
Methods:
| Method | Description | Indications |
|---|---|---|
| Closed reduction | Apply traction in the long axis of the limb (Laplace's law — longitudinal traction counteracts the shortening force of muscles) + reposition fragments by reversing the original direction of trauma | First-line for most fractures; done under sedation/anaesthesia with fluoroscopic guidance |
| Open reduction | Surgical exposure of the fracture site to directly manipulate fragments under vision | When closed reduction fails or is inadequate |
NO CAST Mnemonic — Indications for Open Reduction
Open reduction is indicated when there is [2]:
- Non-union / Failed closed reduction
- Open fracture
- Neurovascular Compromise
- Intra-Articular fracture (risk of secondary OA, misalignment)
- Salter-Harris type III–V
- PolyTrauma
This mnemonic helps you remember why some fractures absolutely cannot be managed conservatively.
Post-reduction: ALWAYS check neurovascular status + obtain post-reduction X-ray to confirm alignment [2].
Purpose: Hold the reduced fracture in position while it heals. Immobilisation also serves as the best analgesic.
| Modality | Description | Indications | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Splint | Elastic, non-circumferential | Pre-hospital, initial immobilisation | Easy to apply, accommodates swelling | Allows some ROM at injury site |
| Brace | Elastic, circumferential | Functional bracing (e.g., humeral shaft after initial slab) | Allows controlled motion, load-sharing promotes callus | Not as rigid |
| Slab (backslab) | Rigid, non-circumferential | Acute fractures with significant soft tissue swelling (allows for swelling to expand without constriction) | Safe — cannot cause compartment syndrome from circumferential compression | Needs conversion to cast once swelling settles |
| Cast (plaster or fibreglass) | Rigid, circumferential | After swelling has settled, stable fractures requiring prolonged immobilisation | Superior immobilisation | Risk of compartment syndrome if applied too early (when limb is still swelling), pressure sores |
| Spica | Immobilises limb + trunk | Hip spica (paediatric femoral fractures), thumb spica (scaphoid fractures) | Excellent immobilisation of proximal segments | Cumbersome |
| Sling | Supports limb weight | Clavicle fracture (broad arm sling, figure-of-eight brace), proximal humerus, elbow injuries | Simple, comfortable | Limited immobilisation |
| Traction | Continuous pull along limb axis | Femoral shaft fracture (Kendrick traction device → change to skin traction ASAP to prevent skin necrosis at groin; contraindicated in hip/pelvic fracture) [2] | Realigns fracture, controls pain, controls blood loss | Prolonged bed rest, requires monitoring |
| External fixation | Bone stabilised by pins connected to an external frame at a distance from the fracture | Significant soft tissue injury, open fractures, temporary stabilisation ("damage control orthopaedics") | Minimal additional soft tissue disruption, allows wound access | Pin-site infection risk, bulky |
| Internal fixation | Surgical implants placed directly on/in the bone | Unstable fractures, multiple fractures, intra-articular fractures requiring anatomical reduction | Anatomical reduction, early mobilisation, rigid fixation | Periosteum stripping → affects healing; requires surgery |
Types of Internal Fixation [2]:
| Type | Examples | Best For | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Extramedullary | Plates and screws, lag screws, tension band wiring, K-wires | Intra-articular fractures, periarticular fractures, where anatomical reduction is paramount | Very stable, anatomical reconstruction; requires open approach → more soft tissue disruption |
| Intramedullary | Intramedullary nails (IMN) | Diaphyseal fractures (femoral shaft, tibial shaft, humeral shaft) | Semi-closed procedure, shorter OT time, allows direct full weight-bearing afterwards; load-sharing device |
Why does the choice of fixation matter? Different fractures have different biomechanical demands. A femoral shaft fracture needs a load-sharing device (IMN) that allows early weight-bearing. A tibial plateau fracture needs anatomical reduction of the joint surface (ORIF with plates/screws) to prevent post-traumatic arthritis. An olecranon fracture needs tension band wiring to convert the tensile pull of the triceps into a compressive force that promotes healing [2].
Rehabilitation begins from day 1, not after the cast comes off. The goals are:
- Prevent stiffness (immobilisation causes joint capsule contracture and muscle wasting)
- Restore ROM (physiotherapy)
- Strengthen muscles (progressive resistance exercises)
- Restore function (occupational therapy, return to activity)
- Prevent complications (DVT prophylaxis, pressure sore prevention, chest physiotherapy)
Specific Management by Region
Shoulder Dislocation — Anterior [2]:
- Closed reduction under sedation (multiple techniques: Hippocratic, Kocher, Stimson, traction-countertraction)
- Post-reduction: neurovascular check (axillary nerve — regimental badge area) + post-reduction X-ray
- Broad arm sling immobilisation × 2–3 weeks
- Physiotherapy: rotator cuff and periscapular strengthening
- Recurrent instability (especially in young patients): consider arthroscopic Bankart repair or Latarjet procedure (coracoid transfer for bone loss)
Clavicle Fracture [2]:
- Conservative (mainstay): sling immobilisation (e.g., figure-of-eight brace), physiotherapy (ROM exercise, muscle strengthening). Usually heal within 4–6 weeks.
- Operative indications: threatened skin (tented, tethered, non-blanching), open fracture, bilateral fracture (to permit weight-bearing) [2]
- Operative modalities: closed reduction with IM fixation, ORIF (plate and screws if unable to unite)
Proximal Humerus Fracture [2]:
- Non-operative (if no displacement): sling immobilisation then rehabilitation
- Operative (displaced, open, neurovascular compromise):
- Closed reduction with percutaneous pinning: preferred for surgical neck fractures
- ORIF: preferred for head-splitting fractures
- Hemiarthroplasty / Reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA): rare, for severely comminuted fractures in elderly
Humeral Shaft Fracture [2]:
- Non-operative (1st line): coaptation splint → functional bracing
- Acceptable limits: < 20° anterior angulation, < 30° varus/valgus, < 3 cm shortening
- Operative indications: open fracture, vascular injury, brachial plexus injury, pathologic fracture
- ORIF (plate and screws or IMN)
- Usually heal in 8–12 weeks
- Watch for Holstein-Lewis fracture (spiral fracture of distal third → radial nerve entrapment → wrist drop) [2]
Radial Head Fracture — Mason Classification and Management [2]:
- Type 1 (non-displaced / < 2 mm): elbow sling × 1 week in flexion → early mobilisation
- Type 2 (displaced > 2 mm / angulated): ORIF
- Type 3 (comminuted): ORIF ± LCL reconstruction; if ORIF not feasible → radial head excision with replacement
Olecranon Fracture [2]:
- Non-operative: minimally displaced < 2 mm / unfit for surgery → elbow sling × 1 week in flexion → early mobilisation
- Operative:
- Tension band wiring: if fracture is proximal to coronoid process → converts tensile force of triceps into compression at fracture site
- Olecranon plating: if fracture is at or distal to coronoid process
Elbow Dislocation [2]:
- Simple (no fracture): closed reduction (in-line traction or manipulation of olecranon) + splinting
- Complex (with fracture, e.g., terrible triad): ORIF of coronoid process and radial head + LCL/MCL reconstruction
Supracondylar Fracture (Children) [2]:
- Non-displaced: above-elbow backslab
- Displaced: closed reduction + percutaneous K-wire fixation (usually 2–3 lateral pins)
- Open reduction if closed reduction fails or if vascular compromise (brachial artery)
- Monitor closely for Volkmann's ischaemic contracture (compartment syndrome of forearm)
Forearm Shaft Fractures (including Galeazzi and Monteggia) [2]:
- Acute: RICE, analgesics, immobilisation by slab
- Definitive: Open reduction internal fixation (ORIF) is preferred because forearm fractures affect motion (supination, pronation) — you need anatomical reduction to restore the interosseous space and rotational axis [2]
- Nightstick fracture (isolated ulnar shaft): may be managed conservatively with cast if non-displaced
Colles' / Smith Fracture [2]:
- Stable extra-articular fracture: Closed reduction + short arm cast immobilisation × 6 weeks
- Closed reduction technique: traction + recreation of the deformity then reversal → mould the cast (3-point fixation)
- Unstable fracture (based on radiographic criteria — > 5 mm shortening, > 5° angulation change, > 2 mm step-off, comminution, associated ulnar fracture [NOT ulnar styloid]): ORIF with plating / K-wire fixation
- Open fracture: external fixation
Scaphoid Fracture [2]:
- Non-operative (undisplaced fracture, or normal XR but high clinical suspicion): thumb spica cast immobilisation + repeat XR at 14 days ± MRI
- Operative (displaced or proximal pole fracture): percutaneous screw fixation — needed because the proximal pole has the poorest blood supply and highest AVN risk
- Mallet finger [2]: DIP extension splint × 6–8 weeks; surgery if Type III (joint subluxation / > 50% articular surface)
- Boxer's fracture (5th MC neck): closed reduction + ulnar gutter splint; rarely needs surgery unless significant rotational deformity
- Bennett's fracture (1st MC base, intra-articular): ORIF or closed reduction with percutaneous K-wire fixation — must restore articular surface of the CMC joint
- Skier's thumb (UCL rupture): partial tear → thumb spica; complete tear (Stener lesion) → surgical repair
Salter-Harris Fractures (Paediatric Epiphyseal Injuries) [2]:
| Type | Stability | Management |
|---|---|---|
| I (Straight through physis) | Stable | Closed reduction + cast. SCFE: ORIF (exception) |
| II (Above — metaphyseal fragment) | Stable | Closed reduction + cast |
| III (Lower — epiphyseal fragment, intra-articular) | Unstable | ORIF (must restore articular surface) |
| IV (Through and through — both meta + epiphysis) | Unstable | ORIF |
| V (Rammed/crushed) | Unstable | No specific acute treatment; highest risk of growth arrest |
This is one of the most important management algorithms in orthopaedic surgery:
Key principles [2]:
- Intracapsular displaced → high AVN risk ( > 95%) because retinacular vessels are disrupted → in elderly patients, replacing the head (arthroplasty) is better than trying to fix it and risking AVN/non-union
- Extracapsular → blood supply preserved → fix the fracture (DHS or IMN) and let it heal
- Young patients with displaced intracapsular fractures → attempt ORIF urgently (within 6 hours ideally) to try to preserve the native hip — AVN risk is accepted because joint replacement in the young has limited lifespan
- Post-operative: DVT prophylaxis, early mobilisation, fall prevention measures, treatment of osteoporosis (bisphosphonates + lifestyle modifications) [2]
- Immediate: traction splinting (Kendrick traction device → change to skin traction ASAP)
- Contraindicated in hip or pelvic fracture [2]
- Operative (within 24–48h): antegrade intramedullary nail (with closed or open reduction) — the gold standard
- Non-operative (rare): long leg cast only if non-displaced with multiple comorbidities making surgery too high-risk
- Immediate: skin traction
- Operative (mainstay): retrograde IMN (simple) / ORIF (complex) / external fixation (open fracture)
- Peri-prosthetic fractures may require ORIF or distal femoral replacement
- Pelvic binder is usually NOT indicated (unlike pelvic ring fractures)
- Undisplaced: conservative management × 6–8 weeks (protected weight-bearing)
- Displaced:
- Young: ORIF (restore joint surface anatomy)
- Old: fracture fixation + total hip replacement
- Unstable pelvic fracture is a life-threatening injury — massive haemorrhage potential [15]
- Immediate: pelvic binder (reduces pelvic volume → tamponades venous bleeding)
- Haemodynamic instability: resuscitation, massive transfusion protocol, pelvic external fixation, angiographic embolisation if arterial bleeding on CT
- Definitive: ORIF once patient is stable
- Uncomplicated lateral plateau fracture: hinged knee brace × 8–12 weeks, physiotherapy, analgesics
- Complicated / Medial plateau fracture: ORIF + post-op hinged knee brace × 8–12 weeks
- Open fracture: external fixation → delayed definitive surgery
- Non-displaced: straight leg immobilisation by hinged knee brace → early weight-bearing in extension, quadriceps strengthening
- Significantly displaced / disrupted extensor mechanism: ORIF with tension band wiring — converts tensile force of the extensor mechanism into compression force to assist fracture healing
- Comminuted: partial/total patellectomy
- Acute: RICE, analgesics, reduction + above-knee backslab (anatomical reduction not necessary for shaft fractures — some overlap/shortening is acceptable). Monitor for compartment syndrome.
- Uncomplicated: closed reduction + intramedullary nail for early weight-bearing
- Proximal/distal with intra-articular extension: ORIF
- Open fracture: external fixation before definitive surgery
- Non-operative indications: non-displaced fracture, Weber A, Weber B without talar shift
- Closed reduction + below-knee backslab, repeat neurovascular exam + XR
- Operative indications: bimalleolar/trimalleolar fracture, Weber B with talar shift, Weber C, open fracture
- ORIF ± syndesmotic screw / tightrope fixation
Why does talar shift matter? Even 1 mm of lateral talar shift reduces tibiotalar contact area by ~40%, dramatically accelerating degenerative change. That's why Weber B fractures are only stable if the talus hasn't shifted — once it shifts, the syndesmosis is disrupted and surgical fixation is needed.
- Non-operative: closed reduction + below-knee backslab
- Operative (mainstay): staged approach — temporary external fixator → ORIF after 7–14 days (allowing soft tissue swelling to settle) ± ankle fixation by hindfoot nail
- Usually operative: closed reduction with percutaneous pinning or ORIF
- Assess posterior heel skin integrity — may require emergency surgery
- Type I (undisplaced): conservative (below-knee cast)
- Type II–IV (displaced): closed reduction + cast in A&E → urgent ORIF
The urgency here is because of the tenuous blood supply. Every hour of displacement further compromises the already precarious vascular supply → increases AVN risk.
- Non-displaced, ligamentous only: weight-bearing cast × 6 weeks + close follow-up with repeat imaging
- Displaced / bony Lisfranc: ORIF (anatomical reduction of the tarsometatarsal alignment is critical) or primary arthrodesis
- Medical: ABC support, DVT prophylaxis, stress ulcer prophylaxis, analgesics, urinary catheter [16]
- Non-surgical immobilisation only in stable injuries: spinal orthoses × 2–3 months [16]
- Problems: pressure sores, weakening of muscles, soft tissue contractures, decreased pulmonary function, chronic pain syndrome [16]
- Surgical treatment in unstable injuries [16]:
- Surgical decompression if a patient with normal cord function or incomplete cord lesion progressively deteriorates
- Reduction of fractures or dislocations
- Fixation of unstable spinal elements
- Methylprednisolone is associated with higher risk of morbidity and complications and should NOT be used [16]
Open fractures warrant specific, urgent management because the breach in skin introduces the risk of infection (osteomyelitis), which is devastating for bone healing.
Immediate Management:
- Photograph the wound (to avoid repeated exposure)
- Remove gross debris but NOT bone fragments (these may be needed for reconstruction)
- Cover with sterile, saline-soaked dressing — do not repeatedly inspect
- Urgent IV antibiotics [2]:
- Cefuroxime (covers skin flora: Staph, Strep) ± Metronidazole (covers anaerobes — important for soil-contaminated wounds)
- Timing: as soon as possible — within 1 hour of injury
- Tetanus prophylaxis (check immunisation status)
- Temporary immobilisation (backslab or external fixation)
- Surgical debridement within 12–24 hours (current best practice — previously "within 6 hours" was dogma, but evidence now supports effective debridement within a reasonable timeframe rather than a rigid 6-hour window)
- Definitive fixation: depends on fracture type — often staged: external fixation first → definitive internal fixation when soft tissues permit
Gustilo-Anderson Classification of Open Fractures:
| Type | Wound | Soft Tissue | Contamination | Bone Injury | Management |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I | < 1 cm | Minimal | Low | Simple pattern | Debridement + internal fixation usually possible |
| II | 1–10 cm | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate comminution | Debridement + internal fixation or external fixation |
| IIIA | > 10 cm | Severe but adequate soft tissue coverage possible | Severe | Severe comminution | Debridement + external fixation → staged internal fixation |
| IIIB | > 10 cm | Inadequate — requires flap coverage | Severe | Severe | External fixation + free flap (plastic surgery) |
| IIIC | Any | Associated vascular injury requiring repair | Any | Any | External fixation + vascular repair → highest amputation risk |
- Urgent closed reduction — dislocations are time-sensitive because:
- Compressed or stretched vessels cause ischaemia → tissue death
- Stretched nerves → neuropraxia or permanent injury
- Cartilage damage increases with time of incongruence
- Pre- and post-reduction neurovascular exam — document meticulously
- Post-reduction X-ray — confirm concentric reduction, look for associated fractures
- Immobilisation — duration depends on joint (shoulder: 2–3 weeks; hip: traction × 4–6 weeks)
- Rehabilitation — muscle strengthening to prevent recurrence
Specific dislocation management is covered in each regional section above.
Every fragility fracture is an opportunity to diagnose and treat osteoporosis. Failure to do so leads to recurrent fractures (the "fracture cascade").
Non-pharmacological [6]:
- Adequate dietary calcium (1000–1200 mg) and vitamin D (600–800 IU)
- Regular weight-bearing exercise
- Smoking cessation, moderate alcohol
- Fall prevention measures (home hazard assessment, vision correction, medication review, physiotherapy for balance)
Pharmacological [6]:
- Bisphosphonates (alendronate, risedronate, zoledronic acid): first-line; inhibit osteoclast activity (bind to hydroxyapatite → taken up by osteoclasts during resorption → induce osteoclast apoptosis)
- Side effects: GI upset (most common), osteonecrosis of the jaw, atypical femoral fractures (paradoxically — prolonged suppression of bone turnover → microdamage accumulation)
- Denosumab: anti-RANKL monoclonal antibody — blocks osteoclast differentiation
- Teriparatide (recombinant PTH 1-34): intermittent dosing stimulates osteoblasts > osteoclasts → anabolic effect
- Romosozumab: anti-sclerostin antibody — dual effect: ↑formation + ↓resorption (newest agent)
| Fracture/Dislocation | Non-operative | Operative | When to Operate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clavicle | Sling × 4–6 weeks | IM fixation / ORIF | Threatened skin, open, bilateral [2] |
| Proximal humerus | Sling → rehab | Percutaneous pinning / ORIF / RSA | Displaced, open, neurovascular compromise [2] |
| Humeral shaft | Coaptation splint → functional brace | ORIF | Open, vascular injury, brachial plexus injury, pathological [2] |
| Radial head | Sling × 1 week (Type 1) | ORIF (Type 2) / Excision + replacement (Type 3) | Displaced > 2 mm or comminuted [2] |
| Olecranon | Sling (< 2 mm displaced) | TBW / Plating | Displaced ≥ 2 mm [2] |
| Forearm shaft | Nightstick fracture only | ORIF (preferred for all others) | Almost always — rotation must be restored [2] |
| Distal radius | CR + short arm cast × 6 weeks | ORIF / K-wire / External fix | Unstable by radiographic criteria [2] |
| Scaphoid | Thumb spica (undisplaced) | Percutaneous screw | Displaced, proximal pole [2] |
| #NOF intracapsular | N/A | DHS/screws (undisplaced) / Arthroplasty (displaced elderly) / ORIF (displaced young) | All #NOF require surgery [2] |
| #NOF extracapsular | N/A | DHS (intertrochanteric) / IMN (subtrochanteric) | All require surgery [2] |
| Femoral shaft | Long leg cast (very rare) | Antegrade IMN (gold standard) | Almost always [2] |
| Tibial plateau | Hinged knee brace (uncomplicated lateral) | ORIF (complicated/medial) | Articular step-off, medial plateau, instability [2] |
| Patella | Hinged knee brace (undisplaced) | TBW / Partial patellectomy | Displaced or disrupted extensor mechanism [2] |
| Tibial shaft | Above-knee backslab (rare) | IMN (gold standard) | Almost always surgical [2] |
| Ankle | Below-knee backslab (Weber A/B no shift) | ORIF ± syndesmotic fixation | Bimalleolar, trimalleolar, Weber B + shift, Weber C [2] |
| Calcaneus | Rarely conservative | ORIF / Percutaneous pinning | Displaced intra-articular fractures [2] |
| Talus | Cast (Type I) | Urgent ORIF (Type II–IV) | Any displacement [2] |
High Yield Summary
Management Principles:
- Life-threatening before limb-threatening before function-restoring [15].
- Priority: open fractures with bleeding → unstable pelvic → spinal → femoral shaft → other long bone [15].
- 6A Framework: ABC, Anti-swelling, Analgesics, Anaesthesia, Anchorage, Anti-sepsis [2].
- 3R Framework: Reduction → Restraint → Rehabilitation [2].
- NO CAST mnemonic for open reduction: Non-union, Open fracture, neurovascular Compromise, intra-Articular, Salter-Harris III–V, polyTrauma [2].
- Forearm fractures almost always need ORIF to restore rotational anatomy [2].
- #NOF: intracapsular displaced → arthroplasty (elderly) / ORIF (young); extracapsular → DHS or IMN [2].
- Femoral shaft: gold standard = antegrade IMN. Traction splint first, contraindicated in hip/pelvic fracture [2].
- Open fractures: antibiotics within 1 hour (cefuroxime ± metronidazole), tetanus, debridement within 12–24h, staged fixation [2].
- Every fragility fracture → investigate and treat osteoporosis + fall prevention [6].
- Methylprednisolone should NOT be used in spinal cord injury [16].
- Tension band wiring (olecranon, patella) converts tensile forces into compressive forces at the fracture site [2].
Active Recall - Management of Common Fractures and Dislocations
References
[2] Senior notes: maxim.md (Sections on principles of trauma management, 6A framework, 3R framework, Salter-Harris management, clavicle fracture management, proximal humerus management, humeral shaft management, radial head fracture Mason classification and management, olecranon fracture management, elbow dislocation management, forearm fracture management, distal radius fracture management, scaphoid fracture management, hand injury management, #NOF management, femoral shaft fracture management, distal femur fracture management, acetabular fracture management, tibial plateau management, patella fracture management, tibial shaft fracture management, ankle fracture management, pilon fracture management, calcaneal fracture management, talar fracture management, Lisfranc management) [6] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Endocrine.pdf (p50 — osteoporosis treatment, FRAX, bisphosphonates) [15] Lecture slides: GC 231. High Energy Trauma Open Fracture_Part 1.pdf (p5 — life-threatening injury; p6 — limb-threatening injury; p9 — priorities in multiple fractures) [16] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Neurology.pdf (p177 — spinal fracture management, methylprednisolone contraindicated)
Complications of Common Fractures and Dislocations
Complications are the reason we treat fractures and dislocations aggressively. Understanding them from first principles means understanding why each complication happens — and once you understand the "why," the recognition and management become intuitive.
Complications can be classified by timing (early vs late), scope (local vs systemic), and specificity (general complications of any fracture vs site-specific complications).
| Early | Late | |
|---|---|---|
| Local | Neurovascular injury, compartment syndrome, wound infection, fracture blisters, open fracture conversion | Delayed union, malunion, non-union, AVN, heterotopic ossification, secondary OA, chronic osteomyelitis, CRPS, Volkmann's contracture, growth disturbance (children) |
| Systemic | Haemorrhagic shock, fat embolism syndrome, sepsis, DVT/PE, ARDS | Crush syndrome (rhabdomyolysis), chronic pain |
Early Local Complications
Pathophysiology: Displaced fracture fragments or dislocated joints can stretch, compress, or lacerate adjacent nerves and vessels. The severity depends on the type of force:
| Mechanism | Nerve Injury Type | Prognosis |
|---|---|---|
| Stretching (neuropraxia) | Temporary conduction block, axon intact | Full recovery expected (days to weeks) |
| Partial disruption (axonotmesis) | Axon disrupted but endoneurium intact | Slow recovery via axonal regrowth (~1mm/day) |
| Complete transection (neurotmesis) | Complete nerve disruption | No spontaneous recovery — requires surgical repair |
Key fracture-nerve associations (revisited here because they are complications):
| Fracture / Dislocation | Nerve at Risk | Clinical Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Supracondylar fracture (children) | Anterior interosseous nerve (most common in children) [3][17] | Cannot flex DIP of index finger + FPL (cannot make "OK sign") |
| Median nerve (posterolateral displacement), Radial nerve (posteromedial displacement) [2] | See below | |
| Humeral shaft (Holstein-Lewis — spiral distal 1/3) | Radial nerve (entrapment/neuropraxia) | High radial nerve palsy: wrist drop, finger drop (triceps intact), ↓sensation dorsal 1st web space [2] |
| Anterior shoulder dislocation / Proximal humerus fracture | Axillary nerve | Loss of regimental badge sensation, deltoid weakness [2] |
| Elbow dislocation | Ulnar nerve | Little finger numbness, intrinsic hand weakness [2] |
| Monteggia fracture-dislocation | Posterior interosseous nerve (PIN) | Finger extension weakness (sensation preserved — PIN is pure motor) [2] |
| Colles' fracture | Median nerve (low injury — like CTS + palm numbness) | Lateral 3½ finger numbness including palm [2] |
| Posterior hip dislocation | Sciatic nerve | Foot drop + posterior thigh/leg numbness [2] |
| Tibial plateau / Fibular neck fracture | Common peroneal nerve | Foot drop (weak dorsiflexion/eversion), numbness dorsum of foot [2] |
Vascular injury: displaced fracture fragments or dislocated joints can cause intimal tears → thrombus formation → acute limb ischaemia. Key associations:
- Supracondylar fracture (children): brachial artery injury → Volkmann's contracture (see below)
- Knee dislocation: popliteal artery injury (~40% incidence — the artery is tethered behind the knee) — must always get CT angiography
- Tibial plateau fracture: popliteal artery
- Fractures/dislocations → arterial stretching → intimal tear → thrombus formation [10]
- Proximal humerus: axillary artery injury — may be masked by extensive collateral circulation preserving distal pulse [2]
Always Document Neurovascular Status
Check and document neurovascular status before AND after every reduction, splinting, or surgical procedure. A nerve injury present before reduction is a pre-existing injury — one discovered only after manipulation may be iatrogenic and has medicolegal implications.
Definition: elevated pressure within a closed fascial compartment that compromises perfusion to the muscles and nerves within it.
- Fracture haematoma + tissue oedema within a non-distensible fascial compartment → ↑intracompartmental pressure → exceeds capillary perfusion pressure → muscle and nerve ischaemia → cell membrane damage → more fluid leaks into interstitial space → further ↑pressure (vicious cycle)
- Prolonged ischaemia ( ≥ 6 hours) + delayed revascularisation → fluid leaks out via damaged cell membrane → oedema → secondary ischaemia when pressure ≥ 30 mmHg or within 30 mmHg of diastolic BP [10]
- More common in legs (4 compartments) than thigh (3 compartments) [2]
- Anterior compartment is most commonly affected whereas involvement of posterior compartment is the most functionally devastating [17]
Clinical Features — The 6 Ps [2]:
| Sign | Details | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Pain (out of proportion) | Severe, unrelieved by analgesia, pain out of proportion to clinical situation (earliest symptom) [10] | EARLY |
| Pain on passive stretch | Most sensitive sign [10] — passive dorsiflexion of great toe (anterior compartment) or passive finger extension (forearm) | EARLY |
| Pressure (tenseness) | Tense, "woody" compartment on palpation | EARLY |
| Paraesthesia | Sensory nerve ischaemia — numbness in web space between 1st and 2nd toes suggestive of deep peroneal nerve compression [17] | INTERMEDIATE |
| Paralysis | Motor nerve ischaemia — inability to dorsiflex foot or extend fingers | LATE |
| Pulselessness | Pulses are almost always palpable — because compartment pressure rarely exceeds systolic arterial pressure. Absent pulse is a VERY LATE and unreliable sign [2][10] | VERY LATE |
Diagnosis: Primarily clinical. If physical examination is unreliable (e.g., obtunded patient), measure intracompartmental pressure with a Stryker monitor [2]:
- Absolute pressure > 30 mmHg, OR
- Delta pressure (diastolic BP minus compartment pressure) < 30 mmHg → fasciotomy indicated
Management [2]:
- Remove all constrictive dressings (cast, bandages)
- Limb elevation at the level of the heart (NOT above — this reduces perfusion pressure)
- Analgesia, O₂, IV fluids
- Emergency fasciotomy of all compartments [2]
- Leave skin incisions open for re-inspection after 48h ± remove necrotic tissue
- Post-op: monitor RFT, CK (rhabdomyolysis)
High-risk fractures for compartment syndrome [2]:
- Tibial shaft fracture (most common)
- Supracondylar fracture (children) — forearm compartment syndrome
- Forearm fractures (both-bone)
- High-energy fractures with significant soft tissue injury
Exam Trap: Don't Wait for Absent Pulses
Students commonly make the mistake of looking for absent pulses to diagnose compartment syndrome. Pulses are almost always palpable in compartment syndrome because compartment pressure exceeds venous and capillary pressure (causing muscle ischaemia) but almost never exceeds systolic arterial pressure. By the time pulses are lost, the limb is usually unsalvageable. The earliest sign is pain out of proportion, and the most sensitive sign is pain on passive stretch [10].
Definition: the end result of untreated/inadequately treated compartment syndrome of the forearm.
Pathophysiology [2]:
- Commonly found in supracondylar fracture in children [2]
- Brachial artery injury (or sustained compartment syndrome) → ischaemic necrosis of the forearm flexors → necrotic muscle is replaced by fibrous tissue → shortening and contracture → claw-like deformity of the hand
- The flexors are affected more than the extensors because the flexor compartment is deeper and has higher metabolic demands
Clinical features: wrist flexion, MCP hyperextension, IP flexion (flexed, clawed hand). Passive extension of the fingers is limited and worsened by wrist extension (tightens the fibrosed flexors further).
Prevention: early recognition and treatment of compartment syndrome is the ONLY way to prevent Volkmann's contracture. Once established, it is devastating and largely irreversible.
The most likely serious complication of an open fracture is infection [15].
This was specifically tested in the lecture slide: a 46-year-old male with a Grade II open tibia fracture — the most likely serious complication is infection (not compartment syndrome, malunion, or non-union) [15].
Why? The breach in skin exposes bone to environmental bacteria. Bone, once infected (osteomyelitis), is extremely difficult to treat because:
- Bone has relatively poor vascularity compared to soft tissue → antibiotics struggle to penetrate
- Dead bone (sequestrum) acts as a nidus for persistent infection
- Biofilm formation on dead bone/implants makes eradication very difficult
Prevention (as covered in the management section): urgent antibiotics (within 1 hour), tetanus prophylaxis, surgical debridement, staged wound closure.
Fracture blisters [2]:
- Formed by elevation of the epidermal layer from the dermis
- Indicate severe soft tissue injury
- Do NOT puncture — may lead to local infection
Early Systemic Complications
Pathophysiology: fractures disrupt intramedullary and periosteal vessels → bleeding into the fracture haematoma and surrounding soft tissues.
Estimated blood loss by fracture site:
| Fracture | Estimated Blood Loss |
|---|---|
| Pelvic ring | 1.5–5+ litres (life-threatening) |
| Femoral shaft | Up to 1.5 litres [2] |
| Tibial shaft | 0.5–1.5 litres |
| Humeral shaft | 0.5–1 litre |
| Closed ankle | 0.5 litre |
| Multiple fractures | Cumulative — can produce Class III/IV shock |
Pelvic fractures deserve special mention [5]: the pelvic retroperitoneum can accommodate massive blood volumes. The venous plexus (presacral, internal iliac) is the primary source. Management includes pelvic binder, resuscitation, angiographic embolisation for arterial bleeding.
Pathophysiology:
- Long bone fractures (especially femoral shaft) → fat globules from bone marrow enter the venous circulation → lodge in the pulmonary and cerebral microcirculation
- Two theories: (1) mechanical: physical obstruction of capillaries, (2) biochemical: free fatty acids released from fat globules cause endothelial damage → inflammation → capillary leak
- Results in a clinical triad: respiratory distress + neurological deterioration + petechial rash
Clinical features (classically 24–72 hours after long bone fracture):
- Respiratory: tachypnoea, hypoxia, ARDS
- Neurological: confusion, agitation, decreased GCS
- Dermatological: petechial rash (classically over chest, axillae, conjunctivae) — pathognomonic but often transient
Prevention: early fracture stabilisation (especially femoral shaft — IMN within 24–48h reduces FES risk).
Pathophysiology: Virchow's triad — (1) stasis (immobilisation), (2) endothelial injury (fracture, surgery), (3) hypercoagulability (acute phase response, post-operative state) → venous thrombosis → embolism to pulmonary vasculature.
Prevention: LMWH prophylaxis, mechanical prophylaxis (TED stockings, intermittent pneumatic compression), early mobilisation.
High-risk fractures: #NOF (prolonged immobility in elderly), pelvic fractures, femoral shaft fractures, spinal cord injury (loss of muscle pump).
Late Local Complications
| Complication | Definition | Pathophysiology | Causes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delayed union | Fracture has not healed within the expected time frame but shows radiological signs of ongoing healing (callus visible) | Healing is occurring but too slowly — inadequate blood supply, excessive motion at fracture site, infection | Inadequate immobilisation, poor blood supply, smoking, NSAID use, infection, wide fracture gap |
| Non-union | Fracture has failed to heal and shows no radiological evidence of further healing | Healing process has ceased — either biological failure (no blood supply) or mechanical failure (too much motion) | Two types: Atrophic (no callus — failure of biology) vs Hypertrophic (excessive callus — failure of stability, callus +++: the body is trying to heal but the fracture is too mobile) [2] |
| Malunion | Fracture heals in a wrong position — abnormal angulation, rotation, or shortening [2] | Inadequate reduction or loss of reduction during healing | Poor initial reduction, inadequate immobilisation, comminution |
| Refracture | Fracture at the same site after initial healing | Cortical atrophy due to prolonged fixation material in situ — stress shielding by the plate means bone doesn't remodel normally. Removed within 18 months after remodelling [2] | Premature return to activity, removal of fixation before adequate remodelling |
Cubitus varus — the most common complication of supracondylar fractures in children [3]:
- Resulted from mal-reduction/malunion or physeal damage
- Cosmetic deformity but little functional deficit [3]
- Also known as "gunstock deformity" [2]
Definition: death of bone tissue due to interruption of its blood supply.
Pathophysiology: fracture disrupts the articular/nutrient vessels → bone distal to the disruption dies → if not revascularised → collapse of the articular surface → secondary osteoarthritis.
High-risk fractures for AVN:
| Fracture | Why AVN Risk Is High | AVN Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Intracapsular #NOF (Garden III–IV) | Retinacular vessels (from MCFA) disrupted by displaced fracture within the capsule | > 95% for displaced [2] |
| Talar neck fracture (Hawkins II–IV) | Talus relies heavily on extraosseous blood supply entering distally → displaced fracture disrupts all routes | Type II: 20–50%, Type III: 90–100%, Type IV: 100% [2] |
| Scaphoid fracture (proximal pole) | Blood supply enters distally (dorsal branch of radial artery) and flows retrograde → proximal pole is a "watershed" area | ~30% for proximal pole fractures [2] |
| Proximal humerus fracture | Disruption of arcuate artery (from anterior circumflex humeral) → humeral head AVN [2] | |
| Posterior hip dislocation (fracture-dislocation highest risk) | Disruption of retinacular vessels [2] | |
| Lunate (Kienböck's disease) | Tenuous blood supply to the lunate → AVN from vascular disruption or repetitive trauma [2] |
Definition: formation of bone in abnormal locations, e.g., within muscle — also called myositis ossificans [2].
Pathophysiology: traumatised soft tissue (especially muscle around the elbow and hip) → pluripotent mesenchymal stem cells → metaplastic bone formation. The precise trigger is not fully understood but relates to the release of bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) from the fracture haematoma into adjacent soft tissues.
Common sites: elbow (most common), hip (especially after acetabular fractures, THA)
Prevention (in high-risk patients): indomethacin (NSAIDs inhibit prostaglandin-mediated osteogenesis) or low-dose radiation therapy.
Pathophysiology: any intra-articular fracture that heals with residual incongruity (articular step-off) → abnormal load distribution across the joint surface → accelerated cartilage wear → OA.
This is why intra-articular fractures demand anatomical reduction — even 2 mm of articular step-off significantly increases OA risk. Key examples:
- Tibial plateau fracture → OA knee [2]
- Distal radius fracture (if intra-articular with step-off) → radiocarpal OA [2]
- Calcaneal fracture → subtalar joint OA [2]
- Patella fracture → patellofemoral OA [2]
- Acetabular fracture → OA hip [2]
- Lisfranc injury → midfoot OA [2]
Previously called "reflex sympathetic dystrophy" or "Sudeck's atrophy."
Definition: a chronic pain syndrome characterised by pain disproportionate to the initial injury, associated with autonomic dysfunction (vasomotor and sudomotor changes), oedema, and trophic changes.
Pathophysiology: not fully understood — likely involves peripheral and central sensitisation, neurogenic inflammation, and sympathetic nervous system dysfunction. Occurs most commonly after distal radius fractures and tibial fractures.
Clinical features (Budapest criteria):
- Continuing pain disproportionate to the inciting event
- Sensory changes (allodynia/hyperalgesia)
- Vasomotor changes (temperature/colour asymmetry)
- Sudomotor/oedema changes (sweating, oedema)
- Motor/trophic changes (decreased ROM, weakness, hair/nail/skin changes)
Management: multidisciplinary — physiotherapy (most important), pharmacological (gabapentinoids, bisphosphonates, calcitonin), psychological support.
Pathophysiology: damage to the physis (growth plate), particularly the germinal layer of chondrocytes → premature physeal closure (physeal bar/bridge formation) → limb length discrepancy and/or angular deformity.
Salter-Harris classification predicts growth arrest risk [3]:
- Type I–II: Good prognosis [3]
- Type III: Poor prognosis — fracture through the germinal layer [3]
- Type IV: Poor prognosis — fracture crosses entire physis [3]
- Type V: Crush fracture of physis → worst prognosis [3]
Management of growth arrest: physeal bar resection (if < 50% of physis involved), corrective osteotomy, limb lengthening procedures, or contralateral epiphysiodesis (if approaching skeletal maturity).
14. Crush Syndrome (Rhabdomyolysis)
- Limb compressed for extended periods → muscle ischaemia → myonecrosis
- Upon release of compression (reperfusion injury): intracellular contents flood into systemic circulation:
- K⁺ → hyperkalaemia → cardiac arrhythmia (peaked T waves, widened QRS, VF)
- Myoglobin → precipitates in renal tubules (especially in acidic urine) → acute tubular necrosis → acute kidney injury
- CK → massively elevated (diagnostic marker)
- Lactic acid → metabolic acidosis
- Phosphate → hyperphosphataemia → secondary hypocalcaemia
- Aggressive hydration (dilute myoglobin, maintain renal perfusion)
- IV bicarbonate to alkalinise urine (↓myoglobin precipitation in tubules — myoglobin is less nephrotoxic at pH > 6.5) [17]
- Diuresis with mannitol
- Monitor and treat hyperkalaemia (calcium gluconate, insulin/dextrose, nebulised salbutamol)
- Dialysis if refractory
| Fracture / Dislocation | Key Complications |
|---|---|
| Clavicle | Malunion/delayed union (MC), brachial plexus injury, pneumothorax (medial 1/3), threatened skin [2] |
| Proximal humerus | AVN of humeral head, axillary nerve/artery injury [2] |
| Humeral shaft | Radial nerve palsy (Holstein-Lewis), non-union [2] |
| Supracondylar (children) | AIN injury (most common nerve) [3][17], brachial artery injury, Volkmann's contracture, cubitus varus (most common complication — from malunion/physeal damage) [3] |
| Radial head | Terrible triad (instability, stiffness, arthritis), Essex-Lopresti fracture, PIN injury [2] |
| Elbow dislocation | Terrible triad, ulnar nerve injury, recurrent instability, stiffness [2] |
| Forearm shaft | Loss of pronation/supination (if malunion), PIN injury (Monteggia) [2] |
| Distal radius (Colles') | Median nerve injury, EPL tendon rupture, malunion, DRUJ injury, TFCC injury, secondary OA, CRPS [2] |
| Scaphoid | AVN (30% proximal pole), SNAC (scaphoid non-union advanced collapse → progressive arthritis from prolonged non-union) [2] |
| Mallet finger | Swan neck deformity (if untreated — DIP flexion + PIP hyperextension) [2] |
| Shoulder dislocation | Recurrence (65–95% in young), Bankart/Hill-Sachs lesions, axillary nerve injury, rotator cuff injury, adhesive capsulitis, secondary OA [2] |
| #NOF (intracapsular) | AVN (Garden III–IV > 95%), non-union, DVT/PE, pressure sores, pneumonia, prosthesis infection (post-arthroplasty), prosthesis dislocation [2] |
| Femoral shaft | Haemorrhagic shock (up to 1.5L), fat embolism, nerve injury (pudendal, femoral), malunion, infection [2] |
| Posterior hip dislocation | AVN (fracture-dislocation highest risk), sciatic nerve injury [2] |
| Tibial plateau | Popliteal artery injury, common peroneal nerve injury, compartment syndrome, post-traumatic OA [2] |
| Patella fracture | Loss of ROM, patellofemoral OA [2] |
| Tibial shaft | Open fracture, compartment syndrome, limb ischaemia, malunion/non-union [2] |
| Ankle fracture | Syndesmotic instability (if unrecognised), post-traumatic OA, wound complications |
| Calcaneus | Subtalar joint OA, wound complications (posterior heel skin) [2] |
| Talar neck | AVN (Hawkins — up to 100% Type IV) [2] |
| Lisfranc | Midfoot OA, chronic pain, arch collapse |
| Pelvic fracture | Massive haemorrhage, bladder/urethral injury, lumbosacral plexus injury, Morel-Lavallée lesion [2][5] |
| Spine fracture | Spinal cord injury, neurological deficit, chronic pain, kyphotic deformity |
| Complication | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Bleeding | Surgical dissection, fracture haematoma |
| Infection (superficial/deep/implant) | Bacterial contamination at surgery; biofilm formation on metalwork |
| Implant failure | Hardware breakage, screw cut-out (especially DHS in osteoporotic bone), loosening |
| Leg length discrepancy | Inaccurate reduction, AVN with collapse |
| Prosthesis dislocation (post-arthroplasty) | Violation of precautions (hip flexion > 90°, adduction, internal rotation in posterior approach) — why patients are given abduction pillow and high-low chair instructions [2] |
| Prosthesis infection, AVN | Long-term complications of hip arthroplasty [2] |
| Aseptic loosening (joint replacement) | Periarticular foreign body reaction → osteolysis → loosening. Limited lifespan (usually > 15 years) |
| DVT/PE | Immobility + Virchow's triad |
| Pressure sores | Immobility, especially in elderly with #NOF |
| Pneumonia | Especially in elderly post-#NOF — reduced mobility → poor chest expansion → atelectasis → infection |
High Yield Summary
Must-Know Complications:
- Compartment syndrome: earliest symptom = pain out of proportion; most sensitive sign = pain on passive stretch; pulses almost always palpable — do NOT wait for pulselessness [10]. Treat with emergency fasciotomy [2].
- Volkmann's contracture: end result of untreated forearm compartment syndrome, most commonly associated with supracondylar fracture in children [2].
- Cubitus varus is the most common complication of supracondylar fractures in children — from malunion/physeal damage. Cosmetic deformity with little functional deficit [3].
- AIN injury is the most common nerve injury in supracondylar fractures in children [3][17].
- AVN: highest risk in intracapsular #NOF (Garden III–IV), talar neck (Hawkins III–IV), scaphoid proximal pole, proximal humerus [2].
- The most likely serious complication of an open fracture is infection [15].
- Fat embolism syndrome: 24–72h after long bone fracture, triad of respiratory distress + confusion + petechiae. Prevented by early fracture stabilisation.
- Non-union: atrophic (no callus = biology failure) vs hypertrophic (callus +++ = stability failure) [2].
- Crush syndrome/rhabdomyolysis: K⁺ → arrhythmia, myoglobin → AKI. Treat with aggressive hydration, bicarbonate, ± dialysis [17].
- Growth disturbance: Salter-Harris III–V have poor prognosis for physeal growth [3].
- Post-arthroplasty: prosthesis infection, dislocation (avoid flexion > 90°, adduction, internal rotation — use abduction pillow), aseptic loosening [2].
- Scaphoid non-union → SNAC (scaphoid non-union advanced collapse — progressive wrist arthritis) [2].
Active Recall - Complications of Common Fractures and Dislocations
References
[2] Senior notes: maxim.md (Sections on complications of trauma — classification, early/late, local/systemic; compartment syndrome; Volkmann's contracture; fracture healing complications; fracture blisters; heterotopic ossification; crush syndrome; supracondylar fracture complications; radial head fracture complications; elbow dislocation complications; forearm fracture complications; distal radius complications; scaphoid complications; mallet finger complications; shoulder dislocation complications; #NOF management and complications; femoral shaft complications; hip dislocation complications; tibial plateau complications; patella fracture complications; tibial shaft complications; calcaneal complications; talar fracture complications; post-arthroplasty complications) [3] Lecture slides: GC 232. Paediatric Musculoskeletal Injury [Updated in 2025].pdf (p25 — Salter-Harris classification prognosis; p58 — AIN injury in supracondylar fractures; p61 — cubitus varus as most common complication) [5] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Radiology.pdf (p6 — pelvic fracture associated injuries) [10] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Cardiology.pdf (p208, p212 — arterial trauma from fractures/dislocations, compartment syndrome mechanism and management, rhabdomyolysis) [15] Lecture slides: GC 231. High Energy Trauma Open Fracture_Part 3.pdf (p13 — infection as most likely serious complication of open fracture) [17] Senior notes: felixlai.md (Sections on compartment syndrome pathophysiology, rhabdomyolysis, reperfusion injury, anterior compartment most commonly affected)
Neurovascular Examination Of The Upper Limb
A systematic clinical assessment of the motor, sensory, and vascular integrity of the upper limb by evaluating peripheral nerve function, muscle strength, dermatome sensation, pulses, and capillary refill to detect neurological or vascular compromise.
AVN Of Hip
Avascular necrosis of the hip is the death of femoral head bone tissue due to disruption of its blood supply, leading to structural collapse and secondary degenerative arthritis.