Anxiety
Anxiety is a state of excessive apprehension and worry accompanied by physiological arousal, often disproportionate to the actual threat, that can impair daily functioning.
Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD) & Anxiety Disorders
Anxiety is a normal emotional response characterised by a subjective sense of unease, dread, or apprehension accompanied by a constellation of autonomic and somatic symptoms. It becomes pathological — an anxiety disorder — when it is excessive in degree, prolonged in duration, and causes significant functional impairment or distress disproportionate to any actual threat [1][2].
Breaking down the terminology:
- "Anxiety" derives from Latin anxietas ("to choke, to distress") — quite literally the feeling of being squeezed or suffocated.
- "Generalised" means the anxiety is continuous and not restricted to particular circumstances (contrast with phobic anxiety, which is intermittent and situational).
Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD) is specifically defined as a condition characterised by excessive, uncontrollable worry about a variety of everyday topics (often described as "free-floating anxiety"), persisting for most days over at least 6 months (DSM-5) or a period of weeks (ICD-10/11), accompanied by psychological and somatic symptoms of arousal [1][2].
Key Distinction
There is no clear dividing line between GAD and normal anxiety [2]. The diagnosis rests on the anxiety being more severe (extent), more prolonged (duration), and causing significant impairment or distress compared with usual worry. This is a clinical judgement, not a binary cut-off.
2. Epidemiology
- Lifetime prevalence ~4.3–5.9% in European populations [1].
- In Hong Kong, community studies suggest anxiety disorders collectively affect ~4–8% of the adult population, with GAD being one of the most common presentations in primary care and psychiatric outpatient clinics.
- GAD is one of the most common psychiatric disorders encountered in general practice — patients often present with somatic complaints rather than declaring "I'm anxious."
- M:F ≈ 1:2 — females are roughly twice as likely to be affected [1].
- Median age of onset ~30 years — notably later than other anxiety disorders (specific phobias typically onset in childhood, social phobia in adolescence, panic disorder in early adulthood) [1].
- More common in socially disadvantaged groups: including those with ↓income, unemployment, divorce, separation [1].
- In Hong Kong specifically, contributing social stressors include high housing costs, academic pressure, long working hours, and the cultural stigma surrounding mental health help-seeking.
This is extremely high yield. GAD rarely travels alone:
- Depression: The most important comorbidity. May present as mixed anxiety-depressive disorder (MADD) or comorbid major depressive disorder (MDD). Comorbid depression is associated with ↑severity, ↑functional impairment, and ↑duration of illness [1].
- Other anxiety disorders [1]:
- Social phobia: 23.2–34.4% comorbidity
- Specific phobia: 24.5–35.1% comorbidity
- Panic disorder: 22.6–23.5% comorbidity
- Other associations: substance abuse (SA), OCD, PTSD, chronic physical illness, medically unexplained symptoms [1].
Clinical Pearl
When you diagnose GAD, always screen for depression (and vice versa). The two conditions share genetic vulnerability and neurotransmitter pathways. Up to 60–70% of GAD patients will have a lifetime episode of MDD.
3. Relevant Neuroanatomy and Function
Understanding anxiety requires understanding the fear circuitry — the neural architecture that evolved to detect and respond to threat.
- The amygdala is a bilateral almond-shaped nucleus (amygdala = Greek for "almond") in the medial temporal lobe.
- It is the central hub that activates the anxiety/fear response via several downstream pathways [3]:
- → Hypothalamus (autonomic activation: tachycardia, sweating, GI disturbance)
- → Periaqueductal grey (freezing behaviour, pain modulation)
- → Locus coeruleus (noradrenaline release → arousal, hypervigilance)
- → Cortical areas (conscious perception of fear)
- Dorsomedial hypothalamus/perifornical region coordinates rapid mobilisation of behavioural, autonomic, respiratory, and endocrinological responses to stress [3].
- Activates the HPA axis (hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal):
- Hypothalamus releases CRH → anterior pituitary releases ACTH → adrenal cortex releases cortisol
- Cortisol sustains the stress response, increases blood glucose, suppresses immune function.
- Also activates the sympatho-adrenal-medullary (SAM) axis:
- Sympathetic nervous system → adrenal medulla releases adrenaline and noradrenaline
- This produces the classic "fight-or-flight" response.
- Insula: Interoceptive awareness — processes internal body signals (heartbeat, gut feelings). Hyperactivity here may explain why anxious patients are excessively aware of bodily sensations [3].
- Dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC): Conflict monitoring and error detection — drives the "something is wrong" feeling [3].
- Ventromedial prefrontal cortex (VMPFC): Acts as a regulatory inhibitory role — essentially the "brake" on the amygdala. When VMPFC function is impaired, the amygdala runs unchecked → persistent anxiety [3].
| Neurotransmitter | Role in Anxiety | Clinical Relevance |
|---|---|---|
| Serotonin (5-HT) | Modulates mood, anxiety, fear circuits | SSRIs increase 5-HT → first-line treatment |
| Noradrenaline (NA) | Drives arousal, hypervigilance, fight-or-flight | SNRIs target NA; beta-blockers block peripheral NA effects |
| GABA | Major inhibitory neurotransmitter — "calms" neural activity | Benzodiazepines enhance GABA → rapid anxiolysis |
| Glutamate | Major excitatory neurotransmitter | Imbalance may contribute to anxiety pathophysiology |
| CRH/Cortisol | Stress hormone axis | Chronic cortisol elevation → hippocampal atrophy, sustained anxiety |
First Principles: Why Does Anxiety Cause Physical Symptoms?
The amygdala activates the hypothalamus → SAM axis and HPA axis → adrenaline/cortisol release → tachycardia (β1 cardiac stimulation), tremor (β2 skeletal muscle), sweating (sympathetic cholinergic), dry mouth (sympathetic vasoconstriction of salivary glands), GI upset (parasympathetic withdrawal reduces peristalsis, blood diverted away from gut), urinary frequency (detrusor hyperactivity), hyperventilation (respiratory centre stimulation → respiratory alkalosis → paraesthesiae, light-headedness). Every somatic symptom of anxiety traces back to autonomic activation.
4. Aetiology (with Hong Kong Focus)
The aetiology of anxiety disorders follows the classic biopsychosocial model. Think of it as a matrix of predisposing, precipitating, and perpetuating factors across biological, psychological, and social domains.
4.1 Biological Factors
- Genes play a significant yet moderate role in GAD aetiology [2].
- Twin studies: MZ > DZ concordance rate, but results are inconsistent — heritability estimated at ~30–40% [2][3].
- For panic disorder, the inherited risk is approximately 40% with a 5× risk in first-degree relatives [3].
- GAD shares heritability with other anxiety disorders, major depression, and neurotic personality [2] — this explains the massive comorbidity overlap.
- Specific gene candidates [2][3]:
- 5-HT transporter polymorphism (SLC6A4): short allele → ↓serotonin reuptake capacity → ↑vulnerability to stress
- Glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) polymorphism: GAD enzyme converts glutamate → GABA; variants may lead to ↓GABA production → ↑excitatory tone
- COMT (catechol-O-methyltransferase): degrades catecholamines; Val/Met polymorphism affects dopamine/NA clearance in prefrontal cortex [3]
- TMEM132D: transmembrane protein implicated in panic disorder [3]
For GAD:
- Functional neuroimaging shows hyperactivity of amygdala and insula with reduced VMPFC inhibitory control.
- ↓GABA levels in cortex on MR spectroscopy.
For panic disorder specifically [3]:
- Structural: inconsistent changes in volumes of amygdala and cingulate cortex
- Functional: abnormalities in baseline perfusion and during panic provocation in various elements of fear-related circuitry
- Neurotransmitters: ↓cortical 5-HT1A binding, ↓cortical GABA levels
4.2 Psychological Factors
- Neuroticism: associated with poor stress resilience, manifests as ↑reactivity to life stressors [3]. Neuroticism is the single strongest personality predictor of anxiety disorders.
- ↑Anxiety sensitivity: the fear of anxiety symptoms and catastrophic cognition regarding bodily sensations (e.g., misattribution of rapid heartbeat as heart attack) [3]. This is particularly relevant in panic disorder but also plays a role in GAD.
- Trait worry and intolerance of uncertainty are core psychological vulnerabilities in GAD.
Cognitive theory of a downward spiral of anxiety in panic attacks [3]:
- Fears about serious physical or mental illness are more frequent among patients who experience panic attacks than among anxious patients who do not have panic attacks
- Anxiety → physical symptoms of anxiety → activates fears of illness → generates ↑anxiety
- 'Safety behaviours' (e.g., avoidance) prevent disconfirmation of these fears — the patient never learns that the feared catastrophe does not actually occur.
For GAD specifically, Dugas's Intolerance of Uncertainty Model proposes that GAD patients have a core inability to tolerate ambiguity → they engage in chronic worry as a (maladaptive) coping strategy to "prepare" for potential negative outcomes.
Borkovec's Avoidance Theory of Worry: Worry is actually a cognitive avoidance strategy — by worrying in words/thoughts, patients avoid the more distressing somatic and imagistic components of anxiety. This paradoxically maintains the disorder.
- Classical conditioning: A neutral stimulus becomes associated with fear (e.g., a supermarket where a panic attack occurred becomes a conditioned stimulus).
- Operant conditioning: Avoidance of the feared situation reduces anxiety (negative reinforcement), strengthening avoidance behaviour.
- Mowrer's Two-Factor Theory: Combines classical conditioning (acquisition of fear) and operant conditioning (maintenance through avoidance).
4.3 Social Factors
- Early adverse experience is more common in panic disorder [3].
- Examples: History of physical or sexual abuse, smoking in childhood, asthma [3].
- Childhood adversity (neglect, emotional abuse, parental psychopathology) is strongly associated with GAD.
- Attachment theory: Insecure attachment styles (anxious-preoccupied) predispose to anxiety disorders.
- Life stress is a significant precipitant [3].
- Acute stressors (job loss, bereavement, relationship breakdown) can precipitate GAD onset.
- Chronic stressors (financial difficulties, caregiving burden, chronic illness) are particularly relevant for maintaining GAD.
- Academic pressure: Hong Kong's education system is highly competitive — anxiety is extremely prevalent among secondary school and university students.
- Housing stress: Among the world's least affordable housing → chronic financial and spatial stress.
- Work culture: Long working hours, job insecurity in certain sectors, high cost of living.
- Cultural factors: Mental health stigma remains significant in Chinese culture — patients often present with somatic complaints ("somatisation") rather than psychological symptoms. The term "neurasthenia" (神經衰弱) is still culturally recognised and may be a more acceptable way for patients to express anxiety/depression.
- COVID-19 legacy: Pandemic-related anxiety, social isolation, and economic uncertainty have contributed to increased anxiety disorder prevalence.
- Political and social stressors: Events since 2019 have been associated with increased population-level anxiety and depression in Hong Kong.
Hong Kong Clinical Pearl
In Hong Kong, always consider the presentation of anxiety through a somatisation lens. Patients may describe chest tightness (胸悶), dizziness (頭暈), insomnia (失眠), poor appetite (食慾不振), or generalised aches without volunteering psychological symptoms. Ask specifically about worry and psychological distress — it may not be offered spontaneously.
5. Classification of Anxiety Disorders
Classification of anxiety disorders (ICD-10) [1]:
A. Phobic Anxiety Disorders — anxiety is intermittent and arising in particular circumstances:
- Agoraphobia: triggered by situations where escape is difficult, e.g., away from home, crowded, confined
- ICD-10: specified with or without panic disorder
- DSM-5: panic disorder, if present, is coded as comorbidity
- Social phobia: triggered by social situations
- Specific phobia: triggered by specific objects/situations
B. Other Anxiety Disorders — anxiety is not related to particular circumstances:
- Panic disorder: anxiety is intermittent but not related to particular circumstances
- GAD: anxiety is continuous
- Mixed anxiety-depressive disorder (MADD): both anxiety and depressive features are present and similarly prominent
- Only present in ICD-10, diagnosed when not meeting criteria for both conditions
The ICD-11 (implemented from 2022) has restructured anxiety disorders:
- Separation Anxiety Disorder and Selective Mutism now included under anxiety disorders (previously under childhood disorders).
- OCD and PTSD have been removed from anxiety disorders and placed in their own categories.
- Agoraphobia is no longer subordinate to panic disorder in DSM-5/ICD-11.
| Disorder | Nature of Anxiety | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|
| GAD | Continuous, free-floating | Excessive worry about multiple topics |
| Panic Disorder | Episodic, unprovoked | Recurrent unexpected panic attacks |
| Agoraphobia | Situational | Fear of situations where escape is difficult |
| Social Anxiety Disorder | Situational (social) | Fear of scrutiny/embarrassment in social situations |
| Specific Phobia | Situational (specific) | Fear of specific object or situation |
| Separation Anxiety Disorder | Situational | Excessive fear of separation from attachment figures |
6. Clinical Features
6.1 Symptoms
Clinical features of GAD are classically divided into psychological and somatic (physical) symptoms. The key teaching point: every somatic symptom can be traced to autonomic nervous system activation.
| Symptom | Pathophysiological Basis |
|---|---|
| Worry/apprehension: generally excessive and persistent compared with normal people [1] | Prefrontal cortex overactivity with rumination; ↓VMPFC inhibition of amygdala |
| Content: generally widespread and not focused on a specific issue ('trivial' worries) [1] | "Free-floating" anxiety — not anchored to a specific threat; reflects generalised threat appraisal |
| Irritability [1] | Chronic autonomic arousal → ↓frustration tolerance; amygdala hyperactivity lowers threshold for negative emotional responses |
| Poor concentration [1] | Attentional resources hijacked by worry; prefrontal "bandwidth" consumed by threat monitoring |
| Sensitivity to noise [1] | Heightened sensory processing due to locus coeruleus–noradrenaline system hyperactivation → hypervigilance |
| Feeling on edge / restlessness | Sustained sympathetic activation → inability to relax |
| Sleep disturbance (initial insomnia, frequent waking) | Arousal system (reticular activating system, noradrenaline) remains active → difficulty transitioning to sleep |
| Fear of losing control or "going crazy" | Catastrophic misinterpretation of anxiety symptoms (cognitive model) |
Important Distinction
Try to distinguish between poor concentration vs poor memory [1]. Dementia may present with anxiety as first presentation (BPSD) [1]. In an elderly patient presenting with anxiety and apparent cognitive complaints, always consider whether the primary problem is actually a neurodegenerative process. A formal cognitive assessment (e.g., MoCA) is essential.
These are the symptoms that bring patients to the GP or ED rather than to psychiatry. They are mediated by sympathetic nervous system activation and HPA axis hyperactivation.
Somatic features of GAD [1]:
| System | Symptom | Pathophysiological Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Cardiovascular | Palpitations, tachycardia | β1-adrenergic stimulation of sinoatrial node → ↑heart rate |
| Chest pain/tightness | Intercostal muscle tension; oesophageal spasm; hyperventilation-induced coronary vasospasm | |
| Respiratory | Dyspnoea, sighing | Medullary respiratory centre stimulation → ↑respiratory rate |
| Hyperventilation | ↑Respiratory rate → ↓pCO2 → respiratory alkalosis → cerebral vasoconstriction → dizziness, paraesthesiae | |
| GI | Dry mouth | Sympathetic activation → vasoconstriction of salivary gland blood supply; ↓parasympathetic salivation |
| Nausea, "butterflies" | Vagal activation; blood diversion away from splanchnic circulation | |
| Diarrhoea / frequency | ↑Gut motility from parasympathetic activation (NB: GI system has complex dual innervation — both sympathetic inhibition and parasympathetic stimulation can occur) | |
| Difficulty swallowing ("globus") | Pharyngeal muscle tension | |
| Musculoskeletal | Muscle tension, aches | Sustained motor neuron activation → chronic muscle contraction → pain |
| Tremor | β2-adrenergic stimulation of skeletal muscle | |
| Tension headache | Sustained contraction of temporalis, frontalis, and cervical muscles | |
| Neurological | Dizziness, light-headedness | Hyperventilation → ↓pCO2 → cerebral vasoconstriction |
| Paraesthesiae (tingling, numbness) | Respiratory alkalosis → ↓ionised calcium (more calcium binds to albumin at alkalotic pH) → neuronal hyperexcitability | |
| Blurred vision | Sympathetic mydriasis; ciliary muscle tension | |
| Genitourinary | Urinary frequency | Detrusor muscle irritability from autonomic dysregulation |
| Erectile dysfunction | Sympathetic dominance inhibits parasympathetic-mediated erection | |
| Autonomic | Sweating | Sympathetic cholinergic fibres to eccrine sweat glands |
| Hot flushes / cold chills | Vasomotor instability from autonomic dysregulation | |
| General | Fatigue | Chronic arousal → sympathetic exhaustion; cortisol dysregulation; poor sleep quality |
Why Hyperventilation Causes Paraesthesiae — First Principles
Anxiety → hyperventilation → blows off CO2 → respiratory alkalosis (↑pH) → at higher pH, more H+ dissociates from albumin → albumin has increased negative charge → albumin binds more Ca²⁺ → ↓free ionised calcium → neuronal membrane hyperexcitability → paraesthesiae (especially perioral and distal extremities) and even tetany (Trousseau's sign, Chvostek's sign in severe cases). This is why anxious patients get tingling in their fingers and around their lips.
| Sign | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Tachycardia (resting HR > 100) | Sympathetic β1 stimulation |
| Elevated blood pressure | Sympathetic vasoconstriction + ↑cardiac output |
| Tremor (fine, postural) | β2-adrenergic stimulation of skeletal muscle |
| Sweating (palms, axillae) | Sympathetic cholinergic activation of eccrine glands |
| Hyperreflexia | Generalised CNS hyperexcitability |
| Sighing respiration | Attempt to "reset" breathing pattern during hyperventilation |
| Restlessness / fidgeting | Motor manifestation of arousal — unable to sit still |
| Tense, furrowed brow / anxious facies | Sustained frontalis/corrugator muscle contraction |
| Dry mouth (if examined) | Sympathetic-mediated salivary gland vasoconstriction |
| Cold, clammy hands | Peripheral vasoconstriction + sweating |
On mental state examination (MSE):
- Appearance/Behaviour: Restless, fidgeting, poor eye contact, tense posture, wringing hands
- Speech: May be rapid, pressured, or hesitant
- Mood: "Anxious," "worried," "on edge" (subjective); objectively anxious
- Thought: Content — worries about multiple domains (health, finances, family, work); Form — may show circumstantiality (going round and round the same worries)
- Perception: Usually normal (distinguish from psychotic anxiety); may report depersonalisation/derealisation during panic
- Cognition: Subjectively impaired concentration; formal testing usually normal (distinguishing from dementia)
- Insight: Usually preserved — patients recognise their worry is excessive but cannot control it
A panic attack is a discrete episode of intense fear or discomfort that reaches a peak within minutes, accompanied by ≥4 of 13 characteristic symptoms (DSM-5):
- Palpitations
- Sweating
- Trembling
- Shortness of breath
- Choking sensation
- Chest pain
- Nausea
- Dizziness
- Chills or hot flushes
- Paraesthesiae
- Derealisation/depersonalisation
- Fear of losing control
- Fear of dying
Panic attacks can occur in any anxiety disorder (and indeed in other psychiatric and medical conditions). A panic attack is NOT the same as panic disorder.
Panic disorder requires recurrent, unexpected panic attacks + persistent concern about future attacks or maladaptive behavioural change (e.g., avoidance) for ≥1 month.
This is a critical clinical point. Some physical illnesses tend to have anxiety as part of their symptomatology [2]:
| Condition | Key Features | Distinction from Primary Anxiety |
|---|---|---|
| Thyrotoxicosis | Associated with constant anxiety but other signs should be obvious (weight loss, heat intolerance, tremor, exophthalmos, goitre, tachycardia/AF) [2] | Check TFTs |
| Phaeochromocytoma | Associated with episodic anxiety → more likely to mimic phobic disorder or panic disorder [2] | Episodic hypertension, headache, sweating, pallor; 24h urine catecholamines |
| Hypoglycaemia | Associated with episodic anxiety → more likely to mimic phobic disorder or panic disorder [2] | Tremor, sweating, confusion, relieved by glucose; check capillary glucose |
| Cardiac arrhythmias (SVT, AF) | Palpitations, dizziness, chest discomfort | ECG |
| Temporal lobe epilepsy | Episodic fear, déjà vu, automatisms | EEG |
| Asthma/COPD | Dyspnoea, chest tightness | PFTs, SpO2 |
| Substance use/withdrawal | Alcohol withdrawal, caffeine excess, stimulant use, benzodiazepine withdrawal | Drug history, toxicology |
Clinical Pearl
Anxiety may be secondary to distressing symptoms of medical conditions. Mis-attributing these symptoms to anxiety may lead to failure to recognize medical conditions [2]. Always perform a basic medical screen (TFTs, FBC, glucose, ECG) before diagnosing a primary anxiety disorder, especially in first presentations or atypical features.
A useful clinical trick: asking whether anxious patients with physical symptoms know anyone who has had similar symptoms is a useful way to distinguish between anxiety-induced and genuine physical symptoms [2]. If the patient says "My uncle had a heart attack with similar chest pain," their anxiety may be driven by catastrophic cognition rather than organic disease — but you still need to rule out the organic cause.
Anxiety may be secondary to distress due to other psychopathologies, e.g., manic symptoms, psychotic symptoms, or as part of symptomatology of other mental illnesses, e.g., psychotic disorder, dementia [2].
Anxiety disorders are generally not diagnosed if it can be fully explained by other mental disorders, and does not occur outside of duration of other psychopathologies [2].
For example:
- A patient with schizophrenia may be anxious due to persecutory delusions → this is not GAD.
- A patient with mania may appear agitated and restless → this is not an anxiety disorder.
- A patient experiencing alcohol withdrawal with tremor and tachycardia → this is substance-induced anxiety.
Substance/medication-induced anxiety symptoms that are present most severely in the morning (when withdrawal is typically most severe) may be due to effects of a substance [2]. This is a useful temporal clue — ask when the anxiety is worst. Morning anxiety → consider substance withdrawal (especially alcohol, benzodiazepines).
High Yield Summary
Definition: GAD = excessive, persistent, free-floating worry about multiple topics, continuous (not situational), lasting ≥6 months (DSM-5), with psychological + somatic symptoms of arousal.
Epidemiology: Lifetime prevalence ~5%, F:M = 2:1, median onset ~30y, associated with social disadvantage. High comorbidity with depression (most important), other anxiety disorders, SA.
Neuroanatomy: Amygdala (alarm) → Hypothalamus (coordinator) → SAM + HPA axes. Insula (interoception), dACC (error detection), VMPFC (brake). Key neurotransmitters: 5-HT, NA, GABA.
Aetiology: Biopsychosocial — genetics (~30-40% heritability, shared with depression), neuroticism, anxiety sensitivity, cognitive catastrophising, safety behaviours (avoidance), life stress, early adversity.
Classification (ICD-10): Phobic (agoraphobia, social, specific) vs Other (panic disorder, GAD, MADD).
Clinical features: Psychological (worry, irritability, poor concentration, noise sensitivity) + Somatic (every system — cardiovascular, respiratory, GI, MSK, neuro, GU, autonomic). All somatic symptoms trace to autonomic activation.
Critical points: (1) No clear line between normal anxiety and GAD — clinical judgement. (2) Always rule out physical causes (thyrotoxicosis = constant anxiety; phaeochromocytoma/hypoglycaemia = episodic anxiety mimicking panic). (3) Distinguish poor concentration (anxiety) from poor memory (dementia). (4) Morning anxiety → think substance withdrawal.
Active Recall - Anxiety (Definition, Epidemiology, Aetiology, Clinical Features)
[1] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p173 — GAD classification, epidemiology, clinical features) [2] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p175 — Aetiology of GAD, physical illness mimicking anxiety, distinguishing from other mental illnesses) [3] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p180 — Aetiology of panic disorder, neurobiological factors, cognitive theories)
Differential Diagnosis of Anxiety
The differential diagnosis of anxiety is one of the most important clinical exercises in psychiatry — and indeed in all of medicine — because anxiety is a symptom that cuts across virtually every diagnostic category. The patient who presents with anxiety could have a primary anxiety disorder, a mood disorder, a psychotic illness, a medical condition, or a substance-related problem. Your job is to systematically work through these possibilities before settling on a diagnosis.
The approach taught in HKU follows a hierarchical structure: first exclude organic/medical causes, then substance-related causes, then other psychiatric disorders, before diagnosing a primary anxiety disorder [1][2].
The Golden Rule of Psychiatric Differential Diagnosis
Anxiety disorders are generally not diagnosed if the anxiety can be fully explained by other mental disorders, and does not occur outside of the duration of other psychopathologies [2]. Always work from "organic" → "substance" → "other psychiatric" → "primary anxiety disorder." This hierarchy prevents you from slapping a GAD label on someone whose anxiety is actually driven by an undiagnosed thyrotoxicosis or a psychotic illness.
The first step once you've established that this is a primary anxiety disorder is to determine which one. The key discriminating features are: (1) Is the anxiety continuous or episodic? (2) If episodic, is it situational or unprovoked? (3) What is the content/focus of the anxiety?
| Diagnosis | Nature of Anxiety | Focus/Content | Key Differentiating Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| GAD | Continuous, free-floating | Widespread, not focused on a specific issue ('trivial' worries) [1] | NOT markedly increased by or restricted to any particular set of circumstances [1]. Worry is about possible future events across multiple life domains |
| Panic disorder | Intermittent, unpredictable | Fear of dying, going mad, or catastrophic consequences of attacks | Occurs unpredictably (not restricted to particular circumstances) [1]. May develop anticipatory anxiety and concurrent agoraphobia [1] |
| Agoraphobia | Intermittent, situational | Fear of panic/unavailable help/escape | Usually triggered by circumstances that are (1) away from home (2) crowded (3) confined with difficulty for immediate escape [1]. Often has prior Hx of panic attacks (95%) and often feel ↓anxious when accompanied [1] |
| Social phobia | Intermittent, situational | Fear of scrutiny, humiliation or embarrassment | May be isolated (e.g., public speaking, performance) or generalized (all situations) [1]. Cf usual shyness: excessive, severe and a/w significant impairment [1] |
| Specific phobia | Intermittent, situational | Fear of specific object/situation | Often a/w anticipatory anxiety and subsequently avoidance [1] |
| MADD | Mixed | Both anxiety and depressive features | Symptoms of both anxiety + depression are present, a/w some autonomic symptoms [1]. Consider which symptoms were dominant/first → dx of depression should take precedence if anxiety symptoms only present in context of depressive episode [1] |
B. Differentiating GAD from Other Conditions
This is the bread and butter of the exam. Each differential has specific discerning features that you need to articulate clearly [3][4].
| Feature | GAD | Depression |
|---|---|---|
| Content of rumination | GAD pt tends to worry about possible future events [3] | Depressive pt tends to brood self-critically on previous events and circumstances [3] |
| Temporal sequence | Anxiety often primary, persistent | If anxiety only in context of depressive episode → depression |
| Somatic features | Autonomic arousal, muscle tension | Early am wakening, diurnal variation in mood, suicidal thoughts are uncommon in GAD [3] |
| Course | Chronic, fluctuating | Episodic (weeks to months) |
| Comorbidity | GAD + depression can co-exist [3] | — |
Why this matters pathophysiologically: GAD and depression share serotonergic and noradrenergic dysfunction, which is why they co-occur so frequently and both respond to SSRIs/SNRIs. The shared genetic vulnerability (5-HT transporter polymorphism) explains the massive overlap.
High Yield Exam Point
| Feature | GAD | Panic Disorder |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of anxiety | Continuous | Episodic, intermittent |
| Panic attacks | Can occur from escalating worry, but unexpected (uncued) panic attacks are unusual in GAD [3] | Recurrent, unexpected panic attacks [5] — by definition not cued by a specific trigger |
| Content of fear | More persistent, less specific chronic complaints involving multiple organ systems or concerning usual life circumstances [3] | Episodic and calamitous thoughts about presumed life-threatening acute illnesses ('fear of dying, going mad') [3] + anticipatory anxiety about the next attack |
| ICD-10 rule | GAD is not diagnosed if criteria for panic disorder were met [3] | Takes diagnostic precedence |
| DSM-5 rule | Both can be diagnosed simultaneously [3] | — |
The underlying mechanism: In panic disorder, there is a sudden, massive surge of sympathetic activation (likely originating from brainstem locus coeruleus and parabrachial nucleus) that triggers the full "fight-or-flight" cascade. In GAD, the amygdala-VMPFC circuit is chronically dysregulated, producing a tonic rather than phasic anxiety state.
In social anxiety disorder, the worry is mainly concerning social situations in which they must perform or be evaluated by others. The individual often has anticipatory anxiety focused upon upcoming social situations. [4]
In GAD, the individual worries whether or not they are being evaluated. [4]
In ICD-10, GAD is not diagnosed if criteria for phobic anxiety were met, but this is possible in DSM-5. [4]
So the critical question is: Does the anxiety persist outside of social situations? If yes → more likely GAD. If the anxiety is exclusively about social performance and evaluation → social anxiety disorder.
| Feature | GAD | OCD |
|---|---|---|
| Content of intrusive thoughts | Tends to be more day-to-day worries (finances, work, health, family) [4] | Concerning more primal fears (e.g., contamination or harm) [4] |
| Compulsions | Checking may occur but usually directly related to preventing feared outcome and is not usually excessive/time consuming [4] | Typically ritualistic/rule driven (to be done in a certain way) and may be unrelated to the feared outcome they are intended to prevent and/or clearly excessive [4] |
| ICD-10 rule | GAD is not diagnosed if criteria for OCD were met [4] | Takes diagnostic precedence |
Why this distinction matters: OCD involves a specific dysfunction in the cortico-striato-thalamo-cortical (CSTC) loop — particularly the orbitofrontal cortex and caudate nucleus — producing stereotyped, repetitive thought-behaviour patterns. GAD involves more diffuse prefrontal-amygdala dysregulation. Different circuits, different phenomenology, different treatment nuances.
Prominent anxiety symptoms may be present in PTSD/adjustment disorder. However, a diagnosis of PTSD takes precedence if they can explain the anxiety symptoms, and the diagnosis of adjustment disorder is only made when other diagnoses (including GAD) cannot be made. [4]
For adjustment disorder specifically:
- There must be a clear temporal relationship to a stressor (onset ≤3 months) [8]
- Severity is out of proportion to original stressor [8]
- It is a residual category — should NOT be diagnosed if another specific disorder (including GAD) can be diagnosed [8]
For PTSD:
- The stressor must be traumatic in nature
- Characterized by re-experiencing (flashbacks, nightmares, intrusive images), avoidance, and hyperarousal [1]
- Anxiety is part of the hyperarousal cluster but is accompanied by the characteristic re-experiencing and avoidance features
GAD is commonly associated with concerns about medically unexplained symptoms, but GAD is usually characterized by worries about multiple different things, whereas hypochondriacal pt worry principally about illness. [4]
The key distinction: In GAD, health worry is one of many worries (alongside work, finances, relationships). In hypochondriasis/illness anxiety disorder, the dominant preoccupation is with having or acquiring a serious illness.
Both are marked by high levels of anxiety and somatic symptoms, but anxiety is pervasive over multiple aspects of life in GAD [9]. In somatic symptom disorder, the excessive thoughts, feelings, and behaviours are specifically directed toward the somatic symptoms themselves.
C. Secondary Causes — Must-Exclude Differentials
These are conditions that mimic primary anxiety disorders and must be ruled out before making a psychiatric diagnosis.
Anxiety may be secondary to distressing symptoms of medical conditions. Mis-attributing these symptoms to anxiety may lead to failure to recognize medical conditions. [2]
| Condition | Mechanism | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Thyrotoxicosis | Excess T3/T4 → ↑basal metabolic rate, ↑β-adrenergic receptor sensitivity → mimics chronic sympathetic activation | Associated with constant anxiety but other signs should be obvious [2]: weight loss, heat intolerance, tremor, goitre, lid lag, AF |
| Phaeochromocytoma | Catecholamine-secreting tumour (from chromaffin cells of adrenal medulla) → episodic adrenaline/NA surges | Associated with episodic anxiety → more likely to mimic phobic disorder or panic disorder [2]. Classic triad: paroxysmal headache, sweating, palpitations [10]. 5Ps: Pressure (HTN), Pain (headache), Palpitation, Perspiration, Pallor (vasoconstriction) [10][11] |
| Hypoglycaemia | ↓Blood glucose → adrenergic counter-regulatory response (adrenaline release) → sympathetic symptoms | Associated with episodic anxiety → more likely to mimic phobic disorder or panic disorder [2]. Adrenergic symptoms: palpitation, sweating, anxiety, tremor, tachycardia [12] |
| Cardiac arrhythmias (SVT, AF) | Sudden change in heart rate/rhythm → palpitations, haemodynamic compromise | Episodic palpitations, may have syncope; ECG diagnostic |
| Heart failure, PE, COPD, asthma | Dyspnoea → anxiety secondary to respiratory distress [2] | Look for orthopnoea, PND, wheeze, pleuritic pain, hypoxia |
| Temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) | Ictal fear from amygdala focus | Episodic fear/anxiety with automatisms, déjà vu; EEG diagnostic |
| Cushing's disease | Chronic hypercortisolism → mood/anxiety symptoms | Cushing's facies, striae, proximal myopathy, buffalo hump |
| BPSD of dementia | Neurodegeneration of prefrontal-limbic circuits → anxiety, agitation | Dementia may present with anxiety as first presentation (BPSD) [1]. Cognitive decline on formal testing |
| Cerebral trauma, malignancies | Direct structural brain damage → disruption of fear circuitry | Focal neurology, history of trauma, constitutional symptoms |
Phaeochromocytoma vs Panic Disorder
Both present with episodic anxiety, palpitations, sweating, and pallor. The key distinguishing features of phaeochromocytoma: young-onset paroxysmal HT + postural hypotension [10], pressor response during procedures or with certain drugs (e.g., TCA, IV contrast) or food (cheese) [10], and pallor during attacks (panic patients tend to flush, not go pale — phaeochromocytoma patients go pale due to vasoconstriction from excess catecholamines). Phaeochromocytoma: sweat but do not flush [11].
Anxiety that occurs only in the context of substance/medication use and that are present most severely in the morning (when withdrawal is typically most severe) may be due to effects of a substance. [4]
| Category | Examples | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Intoxication | Alcohol, stimulants (amphetamines, cocaine, caffeine), cannabis, inhalants, hallucinogens (phencyclidine) [2] | Direct CNS stimulation, sympathomimetic effects, psychotomimetic effects |
| Withdrawal | Alcohol, sedatives/hypnotics (BZDs, opiates), caffeine, cocaine, nicotine [2] | Loss of CNS depressant effect → rebound excitation; GABA withdrawal → neuronal hyperexcitability |
| Side effects of drugs | Antidepressants (esp first 2 weeks), corticosteroids, sympathomimetics, T4, compound analgesics with caffeine, anticholinergics, antipsychotics (akathisia) [2] | Various — e.g., SSRIs initially increase 5-HT which paradoxically worsens anxiety before adaptation; akathisia from dopamine blockade produces subjective restlessness misdiagnosed as anxiety |
Akathisia vs Anxiety
Akathisia (from Greek a- = without, kathisis = sitting) is a medication side effect — most commonly from antipsychotics — that causes intense inner restlessness and a compelling need to move. It is frequently misdiagnosed as anxiety or agitation, leading to dose escalation of the very drug causing it. Always ask about recent medication changes in any patient presenting with new-onset anxiety. The key clue: akathisia involves a prominent motor component (inability to sit still, pacing, rocking) that is specifically related to medication timing.
Anxiety often occurs secondary to other psychopathologies [2]. The diagnostic principle: identify the theme of the anxiety to find the underlying disorder.
Noting the theme/focus of anxiety may be helpful in reaching diagnosis [2]:
| Focus of Anxiety | Suggested Diagnosis |
|---|---|
| Worry about gaining weight | Eating disorder [2] |
| Worry about having serious illness | Hypochondriacal disorder [2] |
| Fear of being poisoned or killed | Delusional beliefs in paranoid schizophrenia [2] |
| Ruminatory thoughts of guilt or worthlessness | Depression [2] |
| Associated with obsessional thoughts or resisting a compulsion | OCD [2] |
| Separation or abandonment | Borderline, dependent personality disorder [2] |
| Being rejected or inadequate | Avoidant personality disorder [2] |
This is an extraordinarily useful clinical framework. When a patient presents with anxiety, always ask: "What are you anxious about?" The content of the worry often points to the correct diagnosis.
Since panic disorder has its own distinct differential [5][6], it deserves separate elaboration:
| D/dx | Discerning Features |
|---|---|
| Other anxiety disorders | Panic attacks tend to be expected, e.g., triggered by social situations in social phobia, phobic situations in phobic anxiety disorder, worry in GAD, separation in separation anxiety disorder [5]. There must be at least one full-blown panic attack occurring over one month in panic disorder. Panic disorder is a/w persistent marked concern about having further attacks (anticipatory fear) and about catastrophic consequences of such attacks. [5] |
| Agoraphobia | If panic attacks occur with agoraphobia, then the diagnosis should be agoraphobia with panic attacks instead of both disorders under ICD-10 [5] |
| Cardiac conditions | Chest pain + palpitations in panic attack vs ACS — ECG, troponin essential. One must be careful to attribute a chest pain to psychogenic causes merely basing on features of anxiety, as the prospect of a heart disease is a frightening experience and organic heart diseases may coexist with anxiety [13][14] |
| Phaeochromocytoma/hypoglycaemia | Episodic sympathetic surges — see above |
| D/dx | Discerning Features |
|---|---|
| Agoraphobia | Focus of fear concerns the event of panic attacks and unavailability of help/escape rather than fearful of scrutiny. Also tends to persist when left alone in phobic situations [6] |
| Panic disorder | Fear concerns the embarrassment due to panic attacks rather than the social situation itself [6] |
| GAD | May have social worries but the focus is on the nature of ongoing relationships rather than scrutiny [6] |
| Normal shyness | Tends to be less severe and pervasive, and a/w little distress and functional impairment [6] |
| Avoidant personality disorder | Usually does not have a recognizable onset and have a broader avoidance pattern outside of social situations [6] |
| Lack of social skills, schizophrenia-spectrum, ↓IQ, ASD | Primarily due to lack of social skills vs social phobia pts usually have adequate social skills [6] |
| Depression and delusions related to negative evaluation | May have fears of being negatively evaluated but are usually arising from beliefs that they are bad or not worthy of being liked (cf from social behaviours or physical symptoms in social phobia) [6] |
Other features in GAD that are NEVER the most prominent feature and should suggest other diagnosis if present [1]:
- Tiredness (if dominant → depression, CFS)
- Depressive mood (if dominant → depressive disorder)
- Obsessional symptoms (if dominant → OCD)
- Depersonalisation (if dominant → dissociative disorder, panic disorder)
In ICD-10, GAD is not diagnosed if criteria for panic disorder, phobic anxiety, or OCD were met [3][4]. This is an important diagnostic hierarchy: these disorders take precedence over GAD.
| Category | Condition | Key Feature That Distinguishes from GAD |
|---|---|---|
| Primary anxiety disorders | Panic disorder | Unexpected, episodic panic attacks; fear of dying/going mad |
| Agoraphobia | Situational — crowded/confined/away from home; ↓anxiety when accompanied | |
| Social phobia | Anxiety restricted to social/performance situations | |
| Specific phobia | Anxiety restricted to specific object/situation | |
| OCD | Ritualistic compulsions; primal fears (contamination, harm) | |
| Mood disorders | Depression | Broods on past; early morning wakening; diurnal variation; suicidal ideation |
| MADD | Neither anxiety nor depression dominant; both present | |
| Bipolar disorder | Anxiety may accompany depressive or mixed episodes | |
| Stress-related | PTSD | Traumatic stressor; re-experiencing; avoidance; hyperarousal |
| Adjustment disorder | Residual category; onset ≤3 months of stressor; doesn't meet other criteria | |
| Somatoform | Hypochondriasis | Worry principally about having illness; symptoms often minimal |
| Somatic symptom disorder | Excessive attention to somatic symptoms specifically | |
| Organic | Thyrotoxicosis | Constant anxiety + weight loss, heat intolerance, goitre |
| Phaeochromocytoma | Episodic anxiety + paroxysmal HTN + pallor | |
| Hypoglycaemia | Episodic anxiety relieved by glucose | |
| TLE | Ictal fear, automatisms, EEG abnormalities | |
| Dementia (BPSD) | Progressive cognitive decline on formal testing | |
| Cardiac (arrhythmia, HF) | ECG abnormalities, haemodynamic signs | |
| Substance-related | Intoxication | Temporal relationship to substance use |
| Withdrawal | Worst in morning (especially alcohol, BZDs); improves through day | |
| Drug side effects | Temporal relationship to new medication (especially antidepressants, antipsychotics) |
High Yield Summary
Approach: Organic → Substance → Other psychiatric → Primary anxiety disorder. Always work hierarchically.
Key differentiators for GAD: (1) Anxiety is continuous, not episodic. (2) Free-floating, not situational. (3) Multiple trivial worries, not focused on one theme. (4) Early morning wakening is NOT GAD — think depression. (5) ICD-10 hierarchy: panic disorder, phobic anxiety, and OCD all take precedence over GAD.
Must-exclude organic causes: Thyrotoxicosis (constant anxiety), phaeochromocytoma and hypoglycaemia (episodic anxiety mimicking panic), TLE, BPSD of dementia, cardiac conditions.
Substance clue: Anxiety worst in the morning → think substance withdrawal (alcohol, benzodiazepines).
Theme of anxiety guides diagnosis: Weight → eating disorder. Illness → hypochondriasis. Poisoned/killed → paranoid schizophrenia. Guilt → depression. Obsessions + compulsions → OCD. Abandonment → borderline PD. Inadequacy → avoidant PD.
Never forget: Organic heart disease can coexist with anxiety — never dismiss chest pain as psychogenic purely because the patient is anxious.
Active Recall - Differential Diagnosis of Anxiety
References
[1] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p173 — GAD classification, epidemiology, clinical features, somatic features) [2] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p171 — Secondary causes of anxiety: medical conditions, substances, other psychiatric disorders, theme of anxiety) [3] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p174 — GAD differential diagnosis: depression, panic disorder) [4] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p175 — GAD differential diagnosis: social anxiety, OCD, stress-related disorders, hypochondriasis, substance-induced, physical illness) [5] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p178–179 — Panic disorder clinical features, diagnostic criteria, differential diagnosis) [6] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p184 — Social anxiety disorder and specific phobia differential diagnosis) [8] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p197–198 — Adjustment disorder clinical features, differential diagnosis) [9] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p203 — Somatic symptom disorder differential diagnosis) [10] Senior notes: maxim.md (section 435 — Phaeochromocytoma clinical features, 5Ps) [11] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Endocrine.pdf (p66 — Phaeochromocytoma, 5Ps, d/dx of episodic sweating/flushing) [12] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Endocrine.pdf (p94 — Hypoglycaemia clinical features: adrenergic and neuroglycopenic symptoms) [13] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Cardiology.pdf (p56 — Anxiety/psychogenic chest pain differential) [14] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Fundamentals.pdf (p201 — Anxiety/psychogenic chest pain)
Diagnostic Criteria, Diagnostic Algorithm, and Investigations for Anxiety Disorders
1. Diagnostic Criteria
Anxiety disorders are clinical diagnoses — there is no blood test, no imaging finding, and no biomarker that confirms the diagnosis. The diagnosis rests entirely on history, mental state examination, and meeting standardised criteria after excluding organic and substance-related causes. Investigations exist only to rule out mimics, not to "confirm" anxiety.
Let's walk through the formal criteria for the two most important anxiety disorders: GAD and Panic Disorder.
1.1 Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD)
Both ICD-10 and DSM-5 criteria are used in HKU teaching. You need to know both.
Suffer primary symptoms of anxiety for most days for at least several weeks at a time, and usually for several months.
Symptoms should involve elements of:
- (a) Apprehension (worries about future misfortunes, feeling 'on edge', difficulty in concentrating, etc.)
- (b) Motor tension (restless fidgeting, tension headaches, trembling, inability to relax)
- (c) Autonomic overactivity (lightheadedness, sweating, tachycardia/tachypnoea, epigastric discomfort, dizziness, dry mouth, etc.)
In children, frequent need for reassurance and recurrent somatic complaints may be prominent.
The transient appearance (for a few days at a time) of other symptoms (esp depression) does not r/o GAD as main diagnosis, but sufferer must not meet full criteria for depressive episode, phobic anxiety, panic disorder or OCD. [1]
| Criterion | Detail |
|---|---|
| A | Excessive anxiety and worry (apprehensive expectation), occurring more days than not for at least 6 months, about a number of events or activities (such as work or school performance) |
| B | The individual finds it difficult to control the worry |
| C | The anxiety and worry are a/w ≥3 of 6 symptoms (≥1 in children), with at least some symptoms having been present for more days than not for the past 6 months: |
| (1) restlessness or feeling keyed up or on edge | |
| (2) being easily fatigued | |
| (3) difficulty concentrating or mind going blank | |
| (4) irritability | |
| (5) muscle tension | |
| (6) sleep disturbance (difficulty falling or staying asleep, or restless, unsatisfying sleep) | |
| D | The anxiety, worry or physical symptoms cause significant distress or impairment in social, occupational or other important areas of functioning |
| E | Not attributable to SA or another medical condition |
| F | Not better explained by another mental disorder |
Understanding the DSM-5 Criteria — Why These 6 Symptoms?
The 6 symptoms in Criterion C all reflect different facets of sustained arousal:
- Restlessness = motor manifestation of sympathetic drive
- Fatigue = exhaustion from chronic arousal (the body cannot sustain fight-or-flight indefinitely)
- Poor concentration = attentional resources consumed by threat monitoring (prefrontal "bandwidth" hijacked)
- Irritability = lowered frustration threshold from chronic amygdala hyperactivation
- Muscle tension = sustained motor neuron firing from chronic sympathetic activation
- Sleep disturbance = arousal system (locus coeruleus, reticular activating system) fails to deactivate at bedtime
The mnemonic "RIMISC" or "WRIST-FM" (Worry, Restlessness, Irritability, Sleep disturbance, Tension, Fatigue, Mind going blank/poor concentration) can help remember these.
ICD-10 vs DSM-5 — Key Differences
| Feature | ICD-10 | DSM-5 |
|---|---|---|
| Duration | "Several weeks... usually several months" (vague) | ≥6 months (strict) |
| Symptom domains | 3 domains: apprehension, motor tension, autonomic overactivity | 6 specific symptoms (≥3 required) |
| Hierarchy | Must not meet criteria for depression, phobic anxiety, panic disorder, or OCD [1] | Not better explained by another mental disorder — can be comorbid |
| Comorbid diagnosis | More restrictive — GAD excluded if other criteria met | More permissive — allows comorbidity |
In practice, DSM-5 is the more commonly used system for research and clinical trials. ICD-10/11 is the official coding system in Hong Kong.
1.2 Panic Disorder
Several severe attacks of autonomic anxiety occurred within a period of about 1 month:
- (a) In circumstances where there is no objective danger
- (b) Without being confined to known or predictable situations
- (c) With comparable freedom from anxiety symptoms between attacks (although anticipatory anxiety is common)
Should not be diagnosed when secondary to phobic disorders or depressive disorders. [5]
| Criterion | Detail |
|---|---|
| A | Recurrent unexpected panic attack, i.e. an abrupt surge of intense fear/discomfort that reaches a peak within minutes and during which time ≥4 of following symptoms occur: |
| (1) Palpitations, pounding heart or ↑HR | |
| (2) Sweating | |
| (3) Trembling or shaking | |
| (4) Sensations of SOB or smothering | |
| (5) Feelings of choking | |
| (6) Chest pain or discomfort | |
| (7) Nausea or abdominal distress | |
| (8) Feeling dizzy, unsteady, light-headed, or faint | |
| (9) Chills or heat sensations | |
| (10) Paraesthesias (numbness or tingling sensations) | |
| (11) Derealization or depersonalization | |
| (12) Fear of losing control or 'going crazy' | |
| (13) Fear of dying | |
| B | ≥1 attacks has been followed by ≥1mo of ≥1 of following: (1) persistent concern/worry about additional panic attacks or their consequences; (2) a significant maladaptive change in behaviour related to the attacks |
| C | Not attributable to substance or another medical condition |
| D | Not better explained by another mental disorder |
The 13 Panic Symptoms — Mechanism Map
Every single symptom is a direct consequence of acute, massive sympathetic activation:
- Symptoms 1–3 (palpitations, sweating, trembling) = catecholamine surge on heart (β1), sweat glands (sympathetic cholinergic), skeletal muscle (β2)
- Symptoms 4–6 (SOB, choking, chest pain) = respiratory centre stimulation + intercostal/chest wall muscle spasm
- Symptom 7 (nausea) = blood diverted from gut (sympathetic splanchnic vasoconstriction)
- Symptoms 8–10 (dizziness, chills/heat, paraesthesiae) = hyperventilation → ↓pCO2 → respiratory alkalosis → cerebral vasoconstriction + ↓ionised Ca²⁺
- Symptoms 11–13 (derealisation, fear of losing control, fear of dying) = prefrontal cortex overwhelmed by amygdala signals → catastrophic cognitive appraisal
| Disorder | Core Diagnostic Requirement |
|---|---|
| Agoraphobia | Marked fear/anxiety about ≥2 of: public transport, open spaces, enclosed places, standing in line/being in a crowd, being outside the home alone. The situations are avoided, require a companion, or endured with intense anxiety. ≥6 months. |
| Social Anxiety Disorder | Marked fear/anxiety about social situations where scrutiny is possible. Fear of acting in a way that will be negatively evaluated. ≥6 months. Specify if performance only. |
| Specific Phobia | Marked fear/anxiety about a specific object or situation. Phobic stimulus almost always provokes immediate anxiety. Avoidance or endured with intense fear. ≥6 months. |
The following algorithm represents the structured clinical approach to diagnosing anxiety — from initial presentation through to final diagnosis. The key principle: exclude organic → exclude substance → exclude other psychiatric → classify the primary anxiety disorder.
3. Clinical Assessment Components
Before any laboratory investigation, the clinical assessment is paramount. Anxiety is a clinical diagnosis — investigations serve only to exclude mimics.
The psychiatric history for anxiety should cover:
| Component | Specific Points |
|---|---|
| Presenting complaint | Nature of anxiety (continuous vs episodic), content of worry, triggers, duration |
| Somatic symptoms | System-by-system review: cardiovascular (palpitations, chest pain), respiratory (SOB), GI (nausea, diarrhoea), neurological (dizziness, paraesthesiae), musculoskeletal (tension, tremor) |
| Panic attacks | Frequency, triggers (or lack thereof), peak timing, associated symptoms (≥4 of 13) |
| Avoidance behaviour | Agoraphobic situations, social situations, specific phobias |
| Functional impact | Work, relationships, social life, self-care |
| Comorbid psychiatric symptoms | Depression screen (PHQ-9), suicidal ideation, OCD features, PTSD features |
| Substance history | Alcohol, caffeine, recreational drugs, prescription medications. Anxiety worst in the morning → think withdrawal [4] |
| Medical history | Thyroid disease, cardiac conditions, asthma/COPD, epilepsy, diabetes (hypoglycaemia) |
| Drug history | Antidepressants (esp first 2 weeks), corticosteroids, sympathomimetics, T4, compound analgesics with caffeine, anticholinergics, antipsychotics (akathisia) [2] |
| Family history | Anxiety disorders, depression, substance use |
| Developmental/social history | Childhood adversity, personality traits, current stressors |
Validated rating scales serve two purposes: (1) structured screening in primary care, (2) monitoring treatment response.
| Tool | What It Measures | Details |
|---|---|---|
| GAD-7 | GAD severity | 7 items, scores 0–21. Cut-offs: 5 (mild), 10 (moderate), 15 (severe). Sens 89%, Spec 82% for GAD at cut-off ≥10. |
| GAD-2 | Ultra-brief screen | First 2 items of GAD-7. Score ≥3 → warrants full assessment. |
| PHQ-9 | Depression severity | Essential for comorbidity screening — always pair with GAD-7. |
| HADS (Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale) | Both anxiety and depression | 14 items (7 anxiety, 7 depression). Widely used in medical settings. Score ≥8 on anxiety subscale suggests possible anxiety disorder. |
| Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI) | Anxiety severity | 21 items, focuses heavily on somatic symptoms — useful for distinguishing anxiety from depression. |
| Panic Disorder Severity Scale (PDSS) | Panic disorder severity | 7 items assessing panic frequency, distress, avoidance, impairment. |
| Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale (LSAS) | Social anxiety severity | 24 items rating fear and avoidance across social and performance situations. |
| SPIN (Social Phobia Inventory) | Social anxiety screen | 17 items, self-report. |
| Y-BOCS | OCD severity | Used when OCD features are present |
GAD-7: The Workhorse Screening Tool
The GAD-7 asks about the past 2 weeks:
- Feeling nervous, anxious, or on edge
- Not being able to stop or control worrying
- Worrying too much about different things
- Trouble relaxing
- Being so restless that it's hard to sit still
- Becoming easily annoyed or irritable
- Feeling afraid as if something awful might happen
Each scored 0 (not at all) to 3 (nearly every day). Total 0–21. This maps directly onto DSM-5 Criterion C symptoms. It's quick, validated, and should be used in every primary care setting.
| MSE Domain | Expected Findings in Anxiety | What to Look For |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance/Behaviour | Restless, fidgeting, tense posture, poor eye contact, hand wringing | Motor tension reflects sustained sympathetic drive |
| Speech | May be rapid/pressured or hesitant | Pressured speech from arousal; hesitancy from social anxiety |
| Mood (subjective) | "Anxious," "worried," "nervous," "on edge" | Patient's own words |
| Affect (objective) | Anxious, apprehensive, labile | Observe for tremor, sweating, tears |
| Thought content | Multiple worries (GAD), catastrophic fears (panic), specific fears (phobia) | Content guides diagnosis [2] |
| Thought form | Circumstantiality (circling same worries), rumination | Usually not formally disordered |
| Perception | Usually normal; derealisation/depersonalisation may occur in panic | If hallucinations → consider psychotic disorder |
| Cognition | Subjectively impaired concentration; formal testing usually normal | If abnormal formal testing → consider dementia [1] |
| Insight | Usually preserved — patients recognise worry is excessive | If insight absent and beliefs delusional → consider psychotic disorder |
| Judgement | May be impaired by avoidance behaviours | Avoidance reflects severity |
4. Investigations
Repeat the core principle: investigations in anxiety disorders exist to exclude organic mimics, NOT to confirm the psychiatric diagnosis. The depth of investigation depends on clinical suspicion based on history and examination.
Every patient presenting with significant anxiety symptoms for the first time should have a basic organic screen:
| Investigation | Rationale | Key Findings / Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Thyroid function tests (TFTs) | Thyrotoxicosis is a/w constant anxiety [4] — excess T3/T4 upregulates β-adrenergic receptors → mimics chronic sympathetic activation | ↓TSH, ↑free T4/T3 → thyrotoxicosis. Note: subclinical hyperthyroidism (low TSH, normal T4) can also cause anxiety symptoms |
| Full blood count (FBC) | Anaemia → fatigue, tachycardia, SOB mimicking anxiety; infection → delirium with agitation | Low Hb → investigate cause. ↑WCC → consider infection |
| Renal function tests (RFT) | Uraemia can cause agitation/confusion; electrolyte disturbance (esp hypocalcaemia) can mimic anxiety | ↑Urea/creatinine → uraemia. ↓Ca²⁺ → tetany, paraesthesiae (mimics hyperventilation syndrome) |
| Liver function tests (LFT) | Hepatic encephalopathy; also screens for alcohol-related liver disease in suspected substance misuse | ↑GGT disproportionate to ALP → alcohol. Deranged LFTs + confusion → hepatic encephalopathy |
| Random/fasting glucose | Hypoglycaemia is a/w episodic anxiety → more likely to mimic phobic disorder or panic disorder [4] | Low glucose coinciding with symptoms → Whipple's triad. Also screen for diabetes (can cause hypoglycaemia if overtreated) |
| ECG (12-lead) | Cardiac arrhythmias (SVT, AF, VT) cause palpitations mimicking panic; long QT is relevant if considering psychotropic medication | Irregularly irregular → AF. Short PR + delta wave → WPW. Prolonged QTc → caution with SSRIs/antipsychotics. Normal ECG reassures both clinician and patient |
| Urine drug screen | Intoxication (stimulants, cannabis) and withdrawal (BZDs, opiates, alcohol) cause anxiety [2] | Positive for amphetamines, cocaine, cannabis, benzodiazepines → substance-related anxiety |
The Minimum Screen
For exam purposes, the essential baseline investigations for a first presentation of anxiety are: TFTs, FBC, glucose, ECG. These cover the most common and dangerous organic mimics (thyrotoxicosis, anaemia, hypoglycaemia, arrhythmia). Add LFT/RFT and urine drug screen based on clinical suspicion.
These are NOT routine but should be ordered when specific clinical features raise suspicion for particular organic causes.
| Investigation | When to Order | Key Findings / Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| 24h urine fractionated metanephrines | Suspected phaeochromocytoma: episodic anxiety + paroxysmal hypertension + pallor + headache + sweating | Sens 98%, Spec 98% [11]. Elevated metanephrines/normetanephrines confirm catecholamine excess. Precaution: stop drugs affecting catecholamine secretion, e.g., TCAs, levodopa, α-agonist, amphetamine [11] |
| Plasma fractionated metanephrines | Alternative to 24h urine when urine collection impractical | Sens 96–100%, Spec 85–89% [11]. Higher sensitivity but lower specificity than urine (more false positives) |
| Serum calcium + PTH | Suspected hyperparathyroidism (anxiety, bone pain, renal stones, constipation) | ↑Ca²⁺ + ↑PTH → primary hyperparathyroidism. ↓Ca²⁺ → consider hypoparathyroidism (paraesthesiae mimicking hyperventilation) |
| 24h urinary cortisol / overnight dexamethasone suppression test | Suspected Cushing's disease: anxiety, weight gain, moon face, striae, proximal myopathy [2] | Elevated 24h urine cortisol; failure to suppress cortisol after 1mg dexamethasone → Cushing's syndrome |
| Urine 5-HIAA | Suspected carcinoid syndrome: episodic flushing + diarrhoea + wheeze [11] | Elevated → carcinoid tumour |
| Serum tryptase | Suspected systemic mastocytosis: episodic flushing, urticaria, anaphylaxis-like episodes [11] | Elevated → mastocytosis |
| Echocardiography | Suspected cardiac cause: murmur, signs of heart failure | Valvular disease, reduced LVEF, structural abnormalities |
| Pulmonary function tests (PFTs) | Suspected asthma/COPD causing dyspnoea misattributed to anxiety | Obstructive pattern; bronchodilator reversibility in asthma |
| EEG | Suspected temporal lobe epilepsy [2]: episodic fear, automatisms, déjà vu | Temporal spikes, sharp waves. Normal interictal EEG does not exclude TLE |
| CT/MRI brain | Suspected structural brain lesion: focal neurology, new-onset personality change, cerebral trauma [2] | Mass lesion, temporal lobe pathology, post-traumatic changes |
| MoCA / MMSE | Dementia may present with anxiety as first presentation (BPSD) [1] | Score < 26/30 on MoCA → cognitive impairment warranting further evaluation |
Phaeochromocytoma Investigation
24h urine for vanillylmandelic acid (VMA): now superseded as less accurate [11]. The gold standard is now 24h urine fractionated metanephrines or plasma fractionated metanephrines. Remember: metanephrines are the methylated metabolites of catecholamines (adrenaline → metanephrine; noradrenaline → normetanephrine) — they are more stable and have a longer half-life than the parent catecholamines, making them a more reliable biomarker.
Before initiating pharmacotherapy, certain baseline investigations are recommended:
| Investigation | Reason |
|---|---|
| Baseline ECG | QTc assessment before SSRIs (especially citalopram/escitalopram which have dose-dependent QTc prolongation) or any antipsychotic |
| FBC | Baseline before certain medications |
| LFT | Baseline hepatic function before medications metabolised hepatically |
| RFT + electrolytes | Baseline before medications; hyponatraemia risk with SSRIs (SIADH) — particularly in elderly |
| Weight, BMI, BP | Baseline metabolic parameters; some medications (mirtazapine, pregabalin) cause weight gain |
| Pregnancy test | If woman of childbearing age — many anxiolytics are teratogenic (especially benzodiazepines in first trimester) |
Understanding the natural history is important because it distinguishes GAD from transient anxiety or adjustment reactions [1]:
- Onset: usually gradual (full syndrome emerges after prolonged subsyndromal symptoms) [1]
- Early onset a/w more protracted course and usually a/w comorbid depression [1]
- Late onset usually more a/w demographic/psychosocial RFs [1]
- Course: usually chronic fluctuating, with ↓rates of remission in short/medium term [1]
- Prognosis: generally poor if disease lasts > 6mo (diagnostic cutoff in DSM-5), with only 60% having complete recovery after 12y and 50% of those recovering having subsequent relapses [1]
- Impact: a/w functional impairment and ↑CVS mortality [1]
Why Does GAD Increase Cardiovascular Mortality?
Chronic anxiety → sustained HPA axis activation → chronic cortisol elevation → metabolic syndrome (insulin resistance, visceral adiposity, dyslipidaemia), endothelial dysfunction, pro-inflammatory state, and sympathetic overdrive (↑HR, ↑BP) → accelerated atherosclerosis → ↑risk of MI and stroke. Additionally, anxious patients are more likely to smoke, drink excessively, and be physically inactive — all independent cardiovascular risk factors.
High Yield Summary
Diagnostic criteria: GAD requires ≥6 months (DSM-5) of excessive worry + ≥3/6 symptoms (restlessness, fatigue, poor concentration, irritability, muscle tension, sleep disturbance) + functional impairment + exclusion of organic/substance/other psychiatric causes. ICD-10 requires apprehension + motor tension + autonomic overactivity, with stricter hierarchy (cannot diagnose if panic/phobia/OCD/depression criteria met).
Panic disorder: Recurrent UNEXPECTED panic attacks (≥4 of 13 symptoms peaking within minutes) + ≥1 month of concern about further attacks or maladaptive behaviour change.
Investigations are to EXCLUDE mimics, not confirm diagnosis: Minimum screen = TFTs, FBC, glucose, ECG. Targeted: 24h urine fractionated metanephrines (phaeochromocytoma, Sens 98% Spec 98%), EEG (TLE), MoCA (dementia), cortisol (Cushing's).
Screening tools: GAD-7 (cut-off ≥10), always pair with PHQ-9 for depression comorbidity.
Prognosis: Chronic fluctuating course. Only 60% recover after 12 years. 50% of those who recover relapse. Associated with ↑CVS mortality.
Active Recall - Diagnostic Criteria, Algorithm, and Investigations
References
[1] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p173–174 — GAD classification, clinical features, diagnostic criteria ICD-10 and DSM-5, clinical course) [2] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p171 — Secondary causes of anxiety: substances, medications) [3] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p174 — DSM-5 criteria Criterion C symptoms) [4] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p175 — Differential diagnosis: substance-induced, physical illness) [5] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p179 — Panic disorder diagnostic criteria ICD-10 and DSM-5) [11] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Endocrine.pdf (p66 — Phaeochromocytoma investigation: urine/plasma metanephrines, VMA, precautions, d/dx episodic sweating/flushing)
Management of Anxiety Disorders
Before diving into specific treatments, let's establish the fundamental principles that guide anxiety management. Think of it as a framework with three layers:
- Psychoeducation — the foundation of everything. If the patient doesn't understand what's happening in their body and brain, no treatment will stick.
- Psychological therapy — the definitive treatment that addresses the maintaining mechanisms (cognitive distortions, avoidance, safety behaviours).
- Pharmacotherapy — modulates the neurochemical imbalance, particularly useful when severity precludes engagement with therapy or when therapy alone is insufficient.
The management approach follows a stepped-care model — start with the least intensive intervention appropriate to severity, and step up if insufficient response.
Approach to management [15]:
- First-line: usually either CBT or SSRIs with various self-help strategies
- Other drugs: other antidepressants (SNRIs, TCAs, MAOIs, mirtazapine), BZDs (alprazolam)
- Other psychotherapy: anxiety management (relaxation training)
The following algorithm integrates NICE (2020 updated), APA, and local HKU teaching [15][16]:
Consider referral to secondary care if: risk of self-harm or suicide, marked self-neglect, non-response to at least two treatments, significant co-morbidity (e.g., substance use, physical health problems) [16]
The following table summarises the disorder-specific approach, derived from the lecture slides [16]:
| Disorder | Mild-Moderate | Moderate-Severe | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| GAD | Self-help | SSRI, individual CBT | 2nd line: SNRI, pregabalin, TCA |
| Panic Disorder | Self-help | SSRI, individual CBT (with ERP) | 2nd line: imipramine, phenelzine. PRN benzodiazepine can be considered [16] |
| Social Phobia | Self-help | SSRI, individual CBT | 2nd line: SNRI, MAOI |
| Specific Phobia | Self-help | CBT (desensitisation, flooding, modelling) | Pharmacotherapy generally NOT effective for specific phobias |
| PTSD | — | Trauma-focused CBT, EMDR | Pharmacotherapy as augmentation or 2nd line: SSRIs, SNRIs, SGAs, prazosin [17] |
| OCD | Self-help | SSRI (higher doses), individual CBT with ERP | SSRIs often needed at higher doses than for depression |
4. Pharmacotherapy — Detailed
How SSRIs work — from first principles [18]:
"SSRI" → "Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor" — the name tells you the mechanism:
- Selective = primarily targets serotonin (not noradrenaline or dopamine)
- Reuptake = the process by which serotonin is pumped back into the presynaptic neuron by the serotonin transporter (SERT)
- Inhibitor = blocks SERT → serotonin stays in the synaptic cleft longer → enhanced serotonergic neurotransmission
Serotonin: blocking SERT to ↑synaptic availability, modulating actions of 5HT1-3, 7 receptors [18]
The therapeutic effect in anxiety is mediated primarily through:
- 5HT1A receptor: Regulates mood (primary target of antidepressants). Regulates adaptive response to stress [18]. Presynaptic 5HT1A autoreceptors at the raphe nucleus initially downregulate downstream 5HT release → slowly desensitized → accounts for delayed action of antidepressants [18]
- 5HT2C receptor: Regulates anxiety and feeding [18]
| SSRI | Typical Dose for Anxiety | Key Pharmacological Features |
|---|---|---|
| Sertraline | 50–200 mg/day | Preferred first choice; mild dopamine reuptake inhibition; safest in cardiac patients |
| Escitalopram | 10–20 mg/day | Most selective SSRI; dose-dependent QTc prolongation — max 20 mg (10 mg in elderly) |
| Fluoxetine | 20–60 mg/day | Longest half-life (active metabolite norfluoxetine ~7 days); potent CYP2D6 inhibitor → drug interactions |
| Paroxetine | 20–50 mg/day | Most potent SERT inhibition; worst withdrawal syndrome (shortest half-life among SSRIs); anticholinergic; weight gain |
| Citalopram | 20–40 mg/day | Dose-dependent QTc prolongation — max 40 mg (20 mg in elderly, hepatic impairment) |
| Fluvoxamine | 50–300 mg/day | Particularly used in OCD; potent CYP1A2 inhibitor |
Practical prescribing points for anxiety:
- Initiation: most result in ↑anxiety symptoms (apprehension, sleeplessness, palpitations) initially → dose should be increased very slowly [15]. This paradoxical initial worsening is because:
- Early SERT blockade → ↑5HT in synapse → stimulates 5HT2A and 5HT2C receptors → mediates 5HT-related S/Es (sexual dysfunction, insomnia, activation, anxiety) [18]
- The therapeutic effect requires desensitisation of presynaptic 5HT1A autoreceptors, which takes 2–4 weeks
- Start low, go slow: In panic disorder particularly, start at half the usual dose (e.g., sertraline 25 mg, escitalopram 5 mg) and titrate up over 1–2 weeks
- Duration: usually maintained for ≥6 months to prevent relapse [15]. In practice, 12–18 months is recommended, and patients with recurrent anxiety may need long-term maintenance.
- Onset of action: 2–4 weeks for initial effect, 8–12 weeks for full effect. Warn patients.
- Discontinuation: Taper slowly over weeks to months to avoid discontinuation syndrome (dizziness, nausea, electric shock sensations "brain zaps," irritability, insomnia).
Why Do SSRIs Initially Worsen Anxiety?
This is a classic exam question and a common clinical pitfall. When you first block SERT, serotonin floods the synapse. But not all serotonin receptors are "good." 5HT2A and 5HT2C activation causes anxiety, insomnia, and agitation. It takes 2–4 weeks for the presynaptic 5HT1A autoreceptors to desensitise, which then allows proper downstream serotonergic regulation. Always warn patients about this initial worsening and consider short-term benzodiazepine cover for the first 2 weeks if needed.
SSRI Side Effects (mechanism-based):
| Side Effect | Mechanism | Management |
|---|---|---|
| Nausea, GI upset | 5HT3 stimulation in GI tract (90% of body's 5HT is in gut) | Take with food; usually resolves in 1–2 weeks |
| Insomnia, agitation | 5HT2A/2C stimulation | Take in morning; short-term BZD cover |
| Sexual dysfunction | 5HT2A-mediated ↓DA in mesolimbic pathway; spinal 5HT effects on ejaculation | Common and persistent; consider switch to mirtazapine or bupropion augmentation |
| Weight gain | 5HT2C (long-term); histamine effects (paroxetine) | Monitor; dietary advice |
| Hyponatraemia (SIADH) | ↑ADH release; more common in elderly | Monitor Na⁺ in elderly; stop if symptomatic |
| QTc prolongation | Direct cardiac ion channel effect (citalopram, escitalopram) | Baseline ECG; dose limits |
| Serotonin syndrome | Excess serotonergic stimulation (especially with MAOIs, tramadol, triptans) | Avoid combination with MAOIs (washout ≥2 weeks); supportive treatment if occurs |
| GI bleeding | ↓platelet serotonin → impaired aggregation | Caution with NSAIDs/anticoagulants; consider PPI cover |
Contraindications/Cautions:
- Absolute: concurrent MAOI use (serotonin syndrome risk — potentially fatal)
- Relative: active GI bleeding, severe hepatic impairment, QTc > 500ms (for citalopram/escitalopram), pregnancy (paroxetine — teratogenic; others generally safer but risk-benefit analysis needed), breastfeeding
4.2 Second-Line: SNRIs, Pregabalin, TCAs, Mirtazapine
"SNRI" = blocks both SERT (serotonin transporter) and NET (noradrenaline transporter) → enhances both 5HT and NA neurotransmission.
| Drug | Dose | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Venlafaxine | 75–225 mg/day (XR formulation) | At lower doses mainly serotonergic; at higher doses (≥150 mg) dual action. Monitor BP (NA-mediated ↑BP in ~5%). Worst discontinuation syndrome of all antidepressants |
| Duloxetine | 60–120 mg/day | Balanced SNRI; also indicated for neuropathic pain, fibromyalgia. Lower risk of hypertension than venlafaxine |
Why add noradrenaline? Some patients with GAD have prominent fatigue, poor concentration, and psychomotor retardation that respond better to noradrenergic augmentation. NA also modulates the prefrontal cortex "top-down" inhibitory control of the amygdala.
- Mechanism: Binds to the α2δ subunit of voltage-gated calcium channels → ↓release of excitatory neurotransmitters (glutamate, noradrenaline, substance P) from hyperexcited neurons. It does NOT directly affect GABA receptors despite the name ("pre-gabalin").
- Dose: 150–600 mg/day in divided doses
- Evidence: Licensed for GAD in Europe (but not FDA-approved for GAD in the US). Rapid onset of anxiolytic effect (within 1 week, faster than SSRIs).
- Side effects: Dizziness, somnolence, weight gain, peripheral oedema, cognitive dulling.
- Caution: Abuse potential (now a controlled substance in UK since 2019); dose adjustment in renal impairment (renally excreted).
Choice: SSRIs as 1st line, alternatives include TCAs (esp imipramine/clomipramine), MAOIs, mirtazapine, SNRI [15]
"TCA" = Tricyclic Antidepressant — named for the three-ring chemical structure. They block reuptake of both serotonin and noradrenaline (like SNRIs) but also have significant effects on histamine (H1), muscarinic (M1), and alpha-1 adrenergic receptors → more side effects.
| Drug | Specific Use | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Imipramine | Panic disorder (2nd line) [16] | Tertiary amine TCA; balanced 5HT/NA reuptake inhibition |
| Clomipramine | OCD, panic disorder | Most serotonergic TCA; particularly effective in OCD |
Side effects (mechanism-based):
- Anticholinergic (M1 blockade): dry mouth, constipation, urinary retention, blurred vision, cognitive impairment
- Antihistaminergic (H1 blockade): sedation, weight gain
- Anti-α1 adrenergic: postural hypotension, dizziness
- Cardiac: QTc prolongation, conduction abnormalities (Na⁺ channel blockade) → lethal in overdose (this is the critical reason TCAs are not first-line — a 2-week supply can be fatal if ingested at once)
Contraindications: Recent MI, heart block, mania, severe hepatic impairment. Use with extreme caution in patients with suicidal ideation (overdose lethality).
- Mechanism: Noradrenergic and specific serotonergic antidepressant (NaSSA). Blocks presynaptic α2-autoreceptors (→ ↑NA and 5HT release) + blocks 5HT2A, 5HT2C, 5HT3 receptors + potent H1 antagonist.
- Dose: 15–45 mg at night
- Why useful in anxiety: Blocks 5HT2A/2C (the receptors responsible for SSRI-related anxiety and insomnia) → anxiolytic without initial worsening; potent H1 antagonism → sedation → excellent for patients with prominent insomnia.
- Side effects: Sedation (paradoxically more at lower doses because at 15 mg H1 blockade dominates; at higher doses noradrenergic effects counteract sedation), weight gain (H1 + 5HT2C blockade), ↑appetite, dry mouth. Rarely: agranulocytosis.
- Advantage: No sexual dysfunction (blocks 5HT2A); no initial anxiety worsening; good for underweight/anorexic patients.
2nd line: phenelzine [16]
- Mechanism: Irreversibly inhibits monoamine oxidase A and B → ↓degradation of 5HT, NA, DA → ↑synaptic availability of all monoamines.
- MAO: inhibiting MAO to ↑synaptic availability of all monoamines [18]
- Drug: Phenelzine — the MAOI most commonly used for anxiety, particularly social anxiety disorder and treatment-resistant panic disorder.
- Side effects: Postural hypotension, weight gain, sexual dysfunction, insomnia, peripheral neuropathy (pyridoxine deficiency).
- Critical danger — Hypertensive crisis: Tyramine in foods (cheese, red wine, cured meats, fermented products) is normally degraded by MAO-A in the gut wall. With MAO inhibition, ingested tyramine enters the systemic circulation → massive noradrenaline release → hypertensive crisis (severe headache, hypertension, potential stroke/death). This is known as the "cheese reaction."
- Drug interactions: Serotonin syndrome with SSRIs/SNRIs/TCAs/opioids (especially pethidine, tramadol). Mandatory 2-week washout between SSRI and MAOI (5 weeks for fluoxetine due to long-acting metabolite).
- Contraindications: Concurrent serotonergic drugs, phaeochromocytoma, hepatic impairment, cerebrovascular disease. Dietary restrictions make adherence difficult.
MAOI Dietary Restrictions — The Cheese Reaction
Why cheese specifically? Tyramine is produced by bacterial decarboxylation of tyrosine during fermentation/ageing. MAO-A in the gut wall normally metabolises tyramine before it enters the systemic circulation. When MAO-A is inhibited: tyramine → enters circulation → displaces noradrenaline from vesicles in sympathetic nerve terminals → massive NA release → hypertensive crisis. Patients must avoid: aged cheese, red wine, cured/smoked meats, fermented soy products (soy sauce, miso — particularly relevant in Hong Kong), broad bean pods, yeast extracts (Marmite).
BZDs: effective in controlling panic attacks when given at ↑↑doses [15]
NOT as primary treatment (usually an antidepressant), only as short-term Tx not more than 1 month [19]
Mechanism [19]:
- Work at GABAA-BDZ receptor complex on neuronal membrane
- GABA-binding site at interface between α and β subunits
- BDZ-binding site at interface between α and γ subunits
- BZDs are positive allosteric modulators — they don't activate the GABA-A receptor themselves but increase the frequency of chloride channel opening when GABA binds → ↑Cl⁻ influx → neuronal hyperpolarisation → ↓neuronal excitability → anxiolysis, sedation, muscle relaxation, anticonvulsion.
| BZD | Half-Life | Use in Anxiety |
|---|---|---|
| Alprazolam | Short (~6–12h) | Most have sedative effect except alprazolam → commonly used to treat panic disorder in US [15]. High potency → effective for panic attacks but highest abuse potential and worst rebound anxiety |
| Clonazepam | Long (~18–50h) | Used for panic disorder; longer half-life → smoother anxiolysis with less interdose rebound |
| Diazepam | Long (~20–100h) | Classic anxiolytic; long half-life useful for smooth coverage but prolonged sedation in elderly |
| Lorazepam | Intermediate (~10–20h) | Preferred in hepatic impairment (no hepatic oxidative metabolism — only glucuronidated) |
Effective to ↓pathological anxiety, agitation and tension [19] Prefer long-acting drugs to ↓withdrawal [19] Panic attacks may require high-potency agents (e.g., alprazolam, clonazepam) [19]
Side effects:
- Sedation, drowsiness, psychomotor impairment
- Cognitive impairment, amnesia
- Dependence (tolerance and withdrawal develop within 2–4 weeks of regular use)
- Withdrawal syndrome: rebound anxiety, insomnia, irritability, tremor, seizures (in severe cases)
- Paradoxical reaction ( < 1%): esp in ↓IQ, neurological disease, extremes of age and with Hx of aggression → may have unexpected ↑aggressive or impulsive behaviour [19]
- Respiratory depression (especially when combined with opioids or alcohol)
Contraindications:
- Acute narrow-angle glaucoma (anticholinergic-like effect on ciliary muscle)
- Severe respiratory insufficiency (respiratory depression)
- Sleep apnoea (worsens upper airway obstruction)
- Severe hepatic impairment (except lorazepam)
- Myasthenia gravis (worsens weakness)
- History of substance use disorder (high abuse potential)
- Pregnancy (teratogenic — cleft palate risk in first trimester; floppy infant syndrome in third trimester)
BZDs: The Clinical Rules
BZDs are NOT primary treatment for anxiety disorders [19]. They are a bridge — used for 2–4 weeks maximum while waiting for SSRIs to take effect, or for acute crisis management. The reasons:
- Tolerance: anxiolytic effect diminishes within weeks
- Dependence: physical dependence develops rapidly
- Cognitive impairment: impairs new learning, which is essential for CBT to work
- Does not address maintaining factors: masks symptoms without addressing the underlying cognitive/behavioural patterns
- Withdrawal: can be worse than the original anxiety, creating a vicious cycle In Hong Kong, BZD overuse in primary care is a recognised problem. Always have an exit strategy when prescribing.
| Drug | Mechanism | Role | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buspirone | 5HT1A partial agonist | GAD (particularly in patients who cannot tolerate SSRIs) | Slow onset (2–4 weeks); no sedation, no dependence, no withdrawal. Not effective for panic disorder. |
| Hydroxyzine | H1 antihistamine | Short-term anxiolysis in GAD | Sedating; useful for insomnia component. No dependence. QTc prolongation risk. |
| Beta-blockers (propranolol) | β-adrenergic blockade | Performance anxiety (e.g., public speaking); somatic symptoms of anxiety (tremor, palpitations) | Does NOT treat the cognitive component of anxiety — only blocks peripheral sympathetic manifestations. Not effective for GAD or panic disorder as monotherapy. |
| Quetiapine (low dose) | D2/5HT2A antagonist + H1 antagonist | Augmentation in treatment-resistant GAD | Off-label; metabolic side effects limit use. Evidence supports efficacy but not first/second line. |
| Prazosin | α1-adrenergic antagonist | Can ↓PTSD symptoms, nightmares, sleep disturbance [17] | Blocks NA-mediated hyperarousal during sleep. Monitor for first-dose hypotension. |
5. Psychological Therapies — Detailed
CBT is the gold standard psychological treatment for all anxiety disorders [15][16][20].
CBT: targets fears of physical effects of anxiety [15] Involves: pointing out sequence of physical symptoms leading to fear → question patient's belief in feared outcome [15] Efficacy: as effective as antidepressants in Tx of panic disorders, combination Tx may give better response in early stages but long-term results are uncertain [15]
How CBT works in anxiety — First Principles:
The cognitive-behavioural model of anxiety posits that anxiety is maintained by:
- Cognitive distortions: Overestimation of threat probability and severity; underestimation of coping ability
- Avoidance/safety behaviours: Prevent disconfirmation of feared catastrophe → anxiety never extinguishes
- Physiological hyperarousal: Misinterpreted as evidence of danger → feeds the cycle
CBT directly targets all three:
| CBT Component | What It Does | Example in GAD | Example in Panic Disorder |
|---|---|---|---|
| Psychoeducation | Explains the anxiety cycle | "Your worry is your brain's alarm system being too sensitive — not a sign of danger" | "Your palpitations are adrenaline, not a heart attack" |
| Cognitive restructuring | Identifies and challenges catastrophic thoughts | "What is the evidence that you will lose your job?" → Socratic questioning | "What actually happened the last 50 times you had palpitations? You didn't die." |
| Behavioural experiments | Tests predictions in real-world situations | Gradually reducing "checking" behaviours | Deliberately inducing somatic sensations (interoceptive exposure) to demonstrate they are harmless |
| Graded exposure | Systematic confrontation of feared situations | Engaging with previously avoided activities | Entering crowded places without escape plan |
| Relaxation/breathing training | ↓Physiological arousal | Progressive muscle relaxation, diaphragmatic breathing | Controlled breathing to counteract hyperventilation |
Format: Typically 12–16 sessions of individual CBT, delivered weekly.
CBT (desensitisation, flooding, modelling) [16]:
| Technique | Description | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Systematic desensitisation | Gradual exposure to feared stimulus in a hierarchy (least to most anxiety-provoking) while maintaining relaxation | Classical counter-conditioning (Wolpe) — relaxation is incompatible with anxiety. Also: habituation — repeated non-reinforced exposure → extinction of conditioned fear response |
| Flooding | Prolonged, intense exposure to the most feared stimulus without escape | Habituation — if you stay long enough, anxiety must come down (the autonomic system cannot sustain peak arousal indefinitely). Demonstrates that feared catastrophe does not occur |
| Modelling | Therapist or model demonstrates non-fearful interaction with feared stimulus | Vicarious learning (Bandura) — observing that no harm occurs to another reduces fear |
| Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP) | Exposure to obsessional trigger + prevention of compulsive response | Specific to OCD — breaks the reinforcement cycle of compulsion → anxiety relief |
Involves: pt imagines a scene from trauma, focusing on accompanying cognition and arousal, while the therapist moves two fingers across the patient's visual field and instructs the patient to track fingers → sequence repeated until anxiety decreases, with patient instructed to generate a more adaptive thought [17]
Efficacy: most studies show that it is efficacious in PTSD, superior to other less specific psychotherapy [17]
| Approach | Description | Indication |
|---|---|---|
| Anxiety management techniques, e.g., relaxation training [15] | Progressive muscle relaxation, diaphragmatic breathing, mindfulness | Adjunctive to all anxiety disorders |
| Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) | Utilizes traditional CBT methods in conjunction with mindfulness and meditation. Mindfulness focuses on becoming aware of thoughts and feelings and accepting them, rather than reacting to them [20] | GAD, relapse prevention |
| Applied relaxation | Taught to identify early signs of anxiety and apply rapid relaxation techniques | GAD (comparable efficacy to CBT) |
| Interpersonal therapy | Focuses on improving interpersonal relationships and communication | When interpersonal stressors are primary |
| Counselling | For stressful life events, illnesses, bereavements [20] | Adjustment difficulties, mild anxiety |
These form Step 1 of the stepped-care model and should be offered to all patients regardless of severity:
| Intervention | Mechanism / Rationale |
|---|---|
| Psychoeducation | Understanding that anxiety is a normal alarm system gone overboard reduces the catastrophic interpretation of symptoms |
| Guided self-help (bibliotherapy, online CBT programs) | Structured CBT techniques delivered in workbook/digital format. Evidence supports efficacy for mild-moderate GAD. |
| Regular aerobic exercise | ↑Endorphins, ↑BDNF (neuroplasticity), ↓cortisol, ↑serotonin. Meta-analyses show moderate effect size for anxiety reduction. 30 min, 3–5×/week. |
| Sleep hygiene | Consistent sleep-wake times, avoiding screens before bed, limiting caffeine after noon. Poor sleep worsens anxiety (bidirectional relationship). |
| Caffeine reduction | Caffeine is an adenosine receptor antagonist → ↑sympathetic activation → ↑anxiety. Particularly important in panic disorder. |
| Alcohol reduction | Alcohol initially anxiolytic (GABA enhancement) but rebound anxiety on withdrawal. Chronic use → GABA-A receptor downregulation → worsens baseline anxiety. |
| Breathing exercises | Diaphragmatic breathing → activates vagus nerve → parasympathetic activation → ↓HR, ↓BP, ↓arousal. Directly counteracts hyperventilation-alkalosis-paraesthesiae cycle. |
| Mindfulness meditation | Strengthens VMPFC inhibition of amygdala → improved emotional regulation. Neuroimaging shows ↑VMPFC grey matter density after 8-week mindfulness programs. |
| Population | Considerations |
|---|---|
| Elderly | ↑Risk of hyponatraemia with SSRIs. ↓BZD metabolism → prolonged sedation, falls, cognitive impairment. Start at lower doses. Dementia must be excluded. |
| Children/Adolescents | CBT is first-line. If SSRI needed, fluoxetine or sertraline preferred. Monitor closely for suicidal ideation (FDA black box warning for under-25s). |
| Pregnancy | CBT is first-line. If medication needed, sertraline has best safety data. Avoid paroxetine (cardiac malformations), BZDs (teratogenic in T1, floppy infant in T3), MAOIs. |
| Comorbid depression | Treat both simultaneously. SSRIs/SNRIs treat both conditions. Combine with CBT. Actively assess suicide risk. |
| Comorbid substance use | Treat concurrently. Avoid BZDs (cross-dependence risk, especially with alcohol). SSRIs preferred. |
| Phase | Duration | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Acute phase | 0–12 weeks | Titrate SSRI to therapeutic dose; review at 2, 4, 8, 12 weeks; monitor side effects; assess with GAD-7 |
| Continuation phase | 6–12 months after remission | Maintain effective dose to prevent relapse |
| Maintenance/tapering | After continuation phase | Gradual taper over 1–3 months. If relapse → restart and consider longer-term maintenance. Patients with ≥3 episodes or chronic course may need indefinite treatment |
If a patient has failed ≥2 adequate trials of first-line treatments (SSRIs/SNRIs at adequate doses for adequate duration, and/or CBT):
- Re-assess the diagnosis: Is there an unrecognised comorbidity (depression, substance use, personality disorder, medical condition)?
- Re-assess adherence: Is the patient taking the medication? Is there avoidance that prevents CBT engagement?
- Optimise current treatment: Ensure adequate dose and duration before switching
- Augmentation strategies: Add pregabalin, low-dose quetiapine, buspirone, or mirtazapine to SSRI/SNRI
- Switch class: TCA (imipramine), MAOI (phenelzine) for treatment-resistant cases
- Specialist referral: Intensive CBT, combined pharmacotherapy, inpatient treatment if severe functional impairment
High Yield Summary
Management principle: Stepped care — psychoeducation/self-help → CBT or SSRI → SNRI/pregabalin/TCA → MAOI/specialist.
First-line: CBT and/or SSRI. First-line is usually either CBT or SSRIs with various self-help strategies [15].
SSRIs in anxiety: Start low, go slow (initial anxiety worsening due to 5HT2A/2C stimulation before 5HT1A desensitisation). Full effect takes 8–12 weeks. Maintain ≥6 months (ideally 12–18 months).
BZDs: Short-term bridge only (≤1 month). NOT as primary treatment [19]. Risk: tolerance, dependence, cognitive impairment, paradoxical aggression. Contraindicated in substance use disorders, respiratory insufficiency, pregnancy.
Specific phobias: CBT (desensitisation, flooding) is the mainstay. Medications generally NOT effective.
PTSD: Trauma-focused CBT or EMDR first-line. Pharmacotherapy is augmentation/second-line.
CBT mechanism: Targets cognitive distortions (catastrophising), safety behaviours (avoidance), and physiological arousal (relaxation). As effective as pharmacotherapy in panic disorder.
MAOIs: Last resort. Cheese reaction (tyramine → hypertensive crisis). Mandatory 2-week SSRI washout. Serotonin syndrome risk.
Active Recall - Management of Anxiety Disorders
References
[15] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p181 — Panic disorder management: approach, pharmacotherapy, psychotherapy) [16] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p186 — Management of anxiety disorders table: stepped care by disorder and severity) [17] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p197 — PTSD management: trauma-focused CBT, EMDR, pharmacotherapy including prazosin) [18] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p35 — Antidepressant pharmacology: monoamine hypothesis, serotonin receptor subtypes, SERT blockade) [19] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p57 — Benzodiazepines: indications, mechanism of action, GABA-A receptor complex) [20] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p71 — Psychological therapies: CBT, EMDR, MBCT, indications table)
Complications of Anxiety Disorders
Anxiety disorders are often perceived by the public — and sometimes even by clinicians — as "just worry." This is a dangerous misconception. Untreated or poorly managed anxiety disorders carry significant morbidity across psychiatric, medical, functional, and social domains. The complications arise from the chronic biological burden of sustained autonomic and neuroendocrine activation, from maladaptive behavioural patterns (avoidance, substance use), and from the downstream effects of functional impairment on the patient's life.
Let's work through these systematically.
1. Psychiatric Complications
This is the single most clinically significant complication. Depression (MADD or comorbid MDD, a/w ↑severity, functional impairment and ↑duration of illness) [1].
Why does anxiety lead to depression?
The two conditions share:
- Neurochemical substrates: Both involve serotonergic and noradrenergic dysfunction. Chronic anxiety depletes 5-HT reserves over time. The same 5-HT transporter polymorphisms predispose to both.
- HPA axis dysregulation: Chronic cortisol elevation from sustained anxiety → hippocampal atrophy (cortisol is neurotoxic to hippocampal CA1 neurons) → impaired stress regulation and memory consolidation → depressive cognitions.
- Cognitive overlap: Chronic worry about the future (anxiety) gradually shifts to rumination about past failures and helplessness (depression) as the patient's functional capacity declines and they feel increasingly unable to cope.
- Learned helplessness: Persistent anxiety with failed attempts to control it → sense of uncontrollability → hopelessness → depression.
Early onset a/w more protracted course and usually a/w comorbid depression [1].
Clinical significance: Comorbid anxiety + depression is associated with:
- Greater symptom severity than either disorder alone
- Longer duration of illness
- Poorer treatment response
- ↑Suicidal ideation and attempts (see below)
Exam Alert
Always screen for depression in every anxiety patient (PHQ-9 alongside GAD-7). Comorbid depression transforms the prognosis and may necessitate more aggressive treatment. Note content of rumination: depressive pt tends to brood self-critically on previous events and circumstances, but GAD pt tends to worry about possible future events [3] — if the content shifts from future-oriented worry to past-oriented self-blame, the patient may be developing depression.
Anxiety disorders independently increase suicide risk, and this risk is dramatically amplified when comorbid with depression.
- Panic disorder is particularly associated with suicidal ideation — the sheer terror of repeated panic attacks, the feeling of "going crazy," and the sense that life is unlivable during attacks drives despair.
- Impact: ↓QoL, functioning and ↑all-cause mortality (esp cardiovascular disorders) [21].
- GAD patients with comorbid depression have suicide attempt rates approaching those of depression alone.
Why anxiety increases suicide risk from first principles: Chronic anxiety → functional impairment → social isolation → hopelessness → loss of reasons for living. Additionally, the agitation component of anxiety may lower the threshold for impulsive suicidal acts — a patient with depression alone may have suicidal thoughts but lack the energy to act; add anxiety-driven agitation and the risk of action increases.
Other associations: SA, OCD, PTSD, chronic physical illness, medically unexplained symptoms [1].
The self-medication hypothesis: Anxious patients discover that alcohol, benzodiazepines, cannabis, or other substances temporarily relieve their distress. This negative reinforcement drives escalating use.
- Alcohol: Acts on GABA-A receptors → anxiolysis. But chronic use → GABA-A receptor downregulation → tolerance → need for higher doses → dependence → withdrawal anxiety worse than baseline → vicious cycle. Panic disorder: 37% with lifetime Hx of major depression... Others: alcohol (self-medication) [5].
- Benzodiazepines: Same GABA-A mechanism. Iatrogenic dependence when prescribed long-term is a significant problem, particularly in Hong Kong where benzodiazepine overuse in primary care is well-documented.
- Cannabis: Initially anxiolytic at low doses (CB1 receptor activation in amygdala) but at higher doses or chronic use → ↑anxiety, paranoia. Also associated with amotivational syndrome.
Potential complications of somatoform presentations: substance use disorders in attempt to ↓distress, e.g., narcotic analgesics, benzodiazepines [22].
Anxiety disorders breed more anxiety disorders. A patient with one anxiety disorder is at significantly elevated risk of developing another:
- Associated comorbidities: other anxiety disorders (social phobia 23.2–34.4%, specific phobia 24.5–35.1%, panic disorder 22.6–23.5%) [1].
- Panic disorder → Agoraphobia: This is the classic progression. Repeated unexpected panic attacks → anticipatory anxiety about having further attacks → avoidance of situations where attacks occurred or escape would be difficult → progressively restricted activities → full-blown agoraphobia. Often develops into agoraphobia as an attempt to avoid panic attacks and their consequences [5].
- GAD → Panic disorder: Escalating, uncontrollable worry → panic attacks. Though unexpected panic attacks are unusual in GAD, the boundary can blur.
In children: Nearly 2/3 expected to disappear in 3–5y, but ~1/3 of them will have other categories of anxiety disorders at follow-up [23].
While OCD is now classified separately from anxiety disorders, anxious patients can develop obsessional features — particularly checking behaviours, reassurance-seeking, and repetitive mental acts. These represent the brain's attempt to achieve certainty and control in the face of intolerable uncertainty.
2. Medical / Physical Complications
Impact: a/w functional impairment and ↑CVS mortality [1].
↑all-cause mortality (esp cardiovascular disorders) [21].
Why chronic anxiety damages the cardiovascular system — First Principles:
- Chronic sympathetic activation → sustained ↑heart rate + ↑blood pressure → ↑cardiac workload → accelerated atherosclerosis, endothelial damage
- HPA axis dysregulation → chronic cortisol elevation → insulin resistance → metabolic syndrome (visceral obesity, dyslipidaemia, hyperglycaemia) → atherogenic milieu
- Inflammation: Chronic stress → ↑pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-6, TNF-α, CRP) → endothelial inflammation → plaque formation and instability
- Platelet activation: Stress hormones → ↑platelet reactivity → ↑thrombotic risk
- Autonomic imbalance: ↓Heart rate variability (a marker of ↓vagal tone and ↑sympathetic dominance) → arrhythmia risk
- Behavioural mediators: Anxious patients are more likely to smoke, be sedentary, eat poorly, and have poor medication adherence
Meta-analyses show that GAD is associated with a 26% increased risk of coronary heart disease events and a 48% increased risk of cardiac death independent of traditional cardiovascular risk factors.
Chronic anxiety drives central sensitisation — the nervous system becomes hyperexcitable and amplifies pain signals. This manifests as:
- Chronic tension-type headache (sustained muscle contraction of temporalis, frontalis, cervical muscles)
- Fibromyalgia (central sensitisation → widespread pain, fatigue, cognitive dysfunction)
- Irritable bowel syndrome (gut-brain axis dysregulation; visceral hypersensitivity)
- Chronic musculoskeletal pain (shoulder, back, jaw/TMJ)
The pathophysiology: Chronic cortisol and noradrenaline → ↓descending inhibitory pain modulation (serotonergic/noradrenergic pathways in periaqueductal grey and rostroventromedial medulla) → ↑pain perception.
The gut-brain axis is a bidirectional communication system. Chronic anxiety:
- ↑Gut permeability ("leaky gut") via cortisol-mediated effects on tight junctions
- Alters gut microbiome composition (dysbiosis)
- Exacerbates functional GI disorders: IBS, functional dyspepsia, GERD
Chronic cortisol elevation → immunosuppression (↓T-cell function, ↓NK cell activity, ↓antibody production) → ↑susceptibility to infections, impaired wound healing, and potentially ↑cancer risk (though the latter remains debated).
Paradoxically, chronic low-grade inflammation also co-occurs (cortisol resistance at the immune cell level) → autoimmune exacerbation.
- Insomnia: Both a symptom and a complication. Chronic insomnia from anxiety → sleep deprivation → impaired prefrontal function → ↓top-down amygdala inhibition → ↑anxiety. This is a self-perpetuating cycle.
- Obstructive sleep apnoea may be exacerbated by weight gain from sedentary lifestyle or medication side effects (mirtazapine, pregabalin).
3. Functional and Psychosocial Complications
- ↓Concentration and ↓decision-making capacity → poor work performance
- Avoidance behaviour → absenteeism, inability to meet deadlines
- Social anxiety → inability to attend meetings, present, or network
- Economic burden: GAD is one of the psychiatric disorders associated with the highest number of lost work productivity days. In Hong Kong, where competitive work culture is the norm, this creates a particularly vicious cycle of ↑stress → ↑anxiety → ↓performance → ↑stress.
Highly relevant in the Hong Kong context. Anxiety disorders in adolescents and young adults → poor academic performance → missed educational opportunities → long-term socioeconomic consequences.
- Avoidance of social situations → social isolation → loneliness → ↑depression
- Irritability and emotional dysregulation → interpersonal conflict
- Reassurance-seeking → strain on relationships (partners/family become exhausted)
- Sexual dysfunction (both anxiety-driven and medication-induced) → relationship strain
In severe cases (especially panic disorder with agoraphobia), patients may become progressively housebound. This represents one of the most devastating functional outcomes:
- Complete loss of independence
- Inability to work, shop, or attend medical appointments
- Total dependence on family/caregivers
- Profound social isolation
4. Treatment-Related Complications (Iatrogenic)
| Complication | Mechanism | Risk Factor |
|---|---|---|
| Serotonin syndrome | Excess serotonergic stimulation when combined with MAOIs, tramadol, triptans | Drug interactions; inadequate washout period |
| Hyponatraemia (SIADH) | ↑ADH secretion → dilutional hyponatraemia | Elderly, concurrent diuretics, low BMI |
| GI bleeding | ↓Platelet 5-HT → impaired aggregation | Concurrent NSAIDs, anticoagulants, elderly |
| Suicidal ideation | Paradoxical activation in early treatment (first 2 weeks) — energy returns before mood improves, or initial anxiety worsening provokes despair | Young adults ( < 25 years), early treatment phase |
| Discontinuation syndrome | Abrupt cessation → serotonergic withdrawal (dizziness, nausea, "brain zaps," insomnia, irritability) | Paroxetine and venlafaxine (shortest half-lives) |
| Sexual dysfunction | 5HT2A-mediated ↓dopamine in mesolimbic pathway + spinal 5-HT effects | Persistent; may last beyond discontinuation |
- Dependence and withdrawal: The most significant iatrogenic complication. Physical dependence develops within 2–4 weeks of regular use. Withdrawal can include rebound anxiety (worse than baseline), insomnia, tremor, and in severe cases withdrawal seizures (life-threatening).
- Cognitive impairment: Long-term BZD use is associated with impaired memory consolidation, ↓processing speed, and possibly ↑dementia risk (controversial but concerning).
- Falls and fractures: Particularly in the elderly — sedation + muscle relaxation + impaired coordination → falls → hip fractures → significant morbidity/mortality.
- Road traffic accidents: Psychomotor impairment equivalent to legal alcohol intoxication.
- Paradoxical reaction ( < 1%): esp in ↓IQ, neurological disease, extremes of age and with Hx of aggression → may have unexpected ↑aggressive or impulsive behaviour [19].
Unnecessary invasive procedures with iatrogenic complications [22].
When anxiety presents primarily with somatic symptoms (as it often does in Hong Kong), patients may undergo repeated investigations — CT scans, endoscopies, cardiac catheterisations, lumbar punctures — searching for an organic cause that doesn't exist. Each investigation carries its own risks:
- Radiation exposure (cumulative from repeated CT scans)
- Procedural complications (perforation, bleeding, infection)
- False-positive results → further unnecessary investigations (the investigation cascade)
- Reinforcement of illness beliefs (each new test confirms the patient's belief that something must be physically wrong)
Ix: judicious → false-positive results may lead to unnecessary invasive investigations and risks [24].
Understanding the natural history helps us understand why complications are so common:
| Feature | GAD | Panic Disorder |
|---|---|---|
| Course | Usually chronic fluctuating, with ↓rates of remission in short/medium term [1] | Tends to be recurrent and chronic with fluctuating anxiety and depression [21] |
| Prognosis | Generally poor if disease lasts > 6mo, with only 60% having complete recovery after 12y and 50% of those recovering having subsequent relapses [1] | Remission occurs in 64% at 2y with mean time to remission of 5.7mo [21] |
| Impact | A/w functional impairment and ↑CVS mortality [1] | ↓QoL, functioning and ↑all-cause mortality (esp cardiovascular disorders) [21] |
| Good prognostic factors (panic disorder) | — | Female gender, no ongoing life stressors, ↓initial attack frequency, subthreshold panic, no major depression, no agoraphobia, no personality disorders [21] |
For specific phobia: Those lasting > 1y generally remain the same after 5y, but help-seeking may occur during episodes of secondary depression [25].
For social anxiety disorder: 1/2–2/3 will respond to Tx, with ~50% of responders achieving full remission [25].
For childhood anxiety: Nearly 2/3 expected to disappear in 3–5y, but ~1/3 of them will have other categories of anxiety disorders at follow-up [23]. Selective mutism prognosis is often poor, with 58% remission rate at 13y. Associated with later development of phobia, social anxiety, ↑risk for depression, substance misuse in unresolved cases [23].
| Category | Complication | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Psychiatric | Comorbid depression | Shared neurochemistry; chronic helplessness; HPA axis dysregulation |
| Suicidal ideation/attempt | Despair + agitation lowers threshold for impulsive acts | |
| Substance use disorder | Self-medication with alcohol/BZDs/cannabis | |
| Development of other anxiety disorders | Shared vulnerability; avoidance generalisation (panic → agoraphobia) | |
| Cardiovascular | ↑IHD, ↑cardiac mortality | Chronic sympathetic activation, cortisol-driven metabolic syndrome, inflammation, platelet activation |
| Somatic | Chronic pain, fibromyalgia, IBS | Central sensitisation; gut-brain axis dysfunction; ↓descending pain inhibition |
| Immune dysfunction | Chronic cortisol → immunosuppression + paradoxical inflammation | |
| Functional | Occupational impairment | ↓Concentration, avoidance, absenteeism |
| Social isolation | Avoidance behaviour, irritability, relationship strain | |
| Agoraphobic restriction / housebound | Progressive avoidance in panic disorder + agoraphobia | |
| Iatrogenic | SSRI side effects | Serotonin syndrome, hyponatraemia, GI bleeding, discontinuation syndrome |
| BZD dependence/withdrawal | GABA-A receptor adaptation; withdrawal seizures | |
| Unnecessary procedures | Somatic presentation → investigation cascade → procedural risk |
High Yield Summary
Most important complication: Comorbid depression — affects up to 60–70% of GAD patients over lifetime; associated with ↑severity, ↑duration, ↑functional impairment, and ↑suicide risk.
Cardiovascular mortality: Independently elevated in both GAD and panic disorder. Mechanism: chronic sympathetic activation + cortisol-driven metabolic syndrome + inflammation + platelet hyperreactivity.
Substance misuse: Self-medication with alcohol and benzodiazepines is extremely common; creates a vicious cycle of tolerance → withdrawal anxiety → escalating use.
Panic → Agoraphobia: The classic progression — avoidance of panic-associated situations progressively restricts the patient's world.
Prognosis of GAD: Only 60% recover after 12 years; 50% of those relapse. Associated with ↑CVS mortality and functional impairment.
Iatrogenic: BZD dependence and unnecessary investigations/procedures are significant preventable complications.
Childhood: 1/3 develop other anxiety disorders at follow-up; selective mutism has 58% remission at 13 years.
Active Recall - Complications of Anxiety Disorders
References
[1] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p173–174 — GAD epidemiology, comorbidities, clinical course, prognosis) [3] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p174 — GAD differential diagnosis: depression vs GAD content of rumination) [5] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p178 — Panic disorder epidemiology, comorbidities including alcohol) [19] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p57 — Benzodiazepines: paradoxical reactions) [21] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p179 — Panic disorder course and prognosis: QoL, all-cause mortality, prognostic factors) [22] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p202 — Somatic symptom disorder complications: unnecessary procedures, substance use) [23] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p270–271 — Childhood anxiety disorders: prognosis, selective mutism) [24] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p200 — Investigations in medically unexplained symptoms: judicious approach) [25] Senior notes: Ryan Ho Psychiatry.pdf (p183 — Specific phobia and social anxiety disorder prognosis)
High Yield Summary
Definition: GAD = excessive, persistent, free-floating worry about multiple topics, continuous (not situational), lasting ≥6 months (DSM-5), with psychological + somatic symptoms of arousal.
Epidemiology: Lifetime prevalence ~5%, F:M = 2:1, median onset ~30y, associated with social disadvantage. High comorbidity with depression (most important), other anxiety disorders, SA.
Neuroanatomy: Amygdala (alarm) → Hypothalamus (coordinator) → SAM + HPA axes. Insula (interoception), dACC (error detection), VMPFC (brake). Key neurotransmitters: 5-HT, NA, GABA.
Aetiology: Biopsychosocial — genetics (~30-40% heritability, shared with depression), neuroticism, anxiety sensitivity, cognitive catastrophising, safety behaviours (avoidance), life stress, early adversity.
Classification (ICD-10): Phobic (agoraphobia, social, specific) vs Other (panic disorder, GAD, MADD).
Clinical features: Psychological (worry, irritability, poor concentration, noise sensitivity) + Somatic (every system — cardiovascular, respiratory, GI, MSK, neuro, GU, autonomic). All somatic symptoms trace to autonomic activation.
Critical points: (1) No clear line between normal anxiety and GAD — clinical judgement. (2) Always rule out physical causes (thyrotoxicosis = constant anxiety; phaeochromocytoma/hypoglycaemia = episodic anxiety mimicking panic). (3) Distinguish poor concentration (anxiety) from poor memory (dementia). (4) Morning anxiety → think substance withdrawal.
High Yield Summary
Approach: Organic → Substance → Other psychiatric → Primary anxiety disorder. Always work hierarchically.
Key differentiators for GAD: (1) Anxiety is continuous, not episodic. (2) Free-floating, not situational. (3) Multiple trivial worries, not focused on one theme. (4) Early morning wakening is NOT GAD — think depression. (5) ICD-10 hierarchy: panic disorder, phobic anxiety, and OCD all take precedence over GAD.
Must-exclude organic causes: Thyrotoxicosis (constant anxiety), phaeochromocytoma and hypoglycaemia (episodic anxiety mimicking panic), TLE, BPSD of dementia, cardiac conditions.
Substance clue: Anxiety worst in the morning → think substance withdrawal (alcohol, benzodiazepines).
Theme of anxiety guides diagnosis: Weight → eating disorder. Illness → hypochondriasis. Poisoned/killed → paranoid schizophrenia. Guilt → depression. Obsessions + compulsions → OCD. Abandonment → borderline PD. Inadequacy → avoidant PD.
Never forget: Organic heart disease can coexist with anxiety — never dismiss chest pain as psychogenic purely because the patient is anxious.
High Yield Summary
Diagnostic criteria: GAD requires ≥6 months (DSM-5) of excessive worry + ≥3/6 symptoms (restlessness, fatigue, poor concentration, irritability, muscle tension, sleep disturbance) + functional impairment + exclusion of organic/substance/other psychiatric causes. ICD-10 requires apprehension + motor tension + autonomic overactivity, with stricter hierarchy (cannot diagnose if panic/phobia/OCD/depression criteria met).
Panic disorder: Recurrent UNEXPECTED panic attacks (≥4 of 13 symptoms peaking within minutes) + ≥1 month of concern about further attacks or maladaptive behaviour change.
Investigations are to EXCLUDE mimics, not confirm diagnosis: Minimum screen = TFTs, FBC, glucose, ECG. Targeted: 24h urine fractionated metanephrines (phaeochromocytoma, Sens 98% Spec 98%), EEG (TLE), MoCA (dementia), cortisol (Cushing's).
Screening tools: GAD-7 (cut-off ≥10), always pair with PHQ-9 for depression comorbidity.
Prognosis: Chronic fluctuating course. Only 60% recover after 12 years. 50% of those who recover relapse. Associated with ↑CVS mortality.
High Yield Summary
Management principle: Stepped care — psychoeducation/self-help → CBT or SSRI → SNRI/pregabalin/TCA → MAOI/specialist.
First-line: CBT and/or SSRI. First-line is usually either CBT or SSRIs with various self-help strategies [15].
SSRIs in anxiety: Start low, go slow (initial anxiety worsening due to 5HT2A/2C stimulation before 5HT1A desensitisation). Full effect takes 8–12 weeks. Maintain ≥6 months (ideally 12–18 months).
BZDs: Short-term bridge only (≤1 month). NOT as primary treatment [19]. Risk: tolerance, dependence, cognitive impairment, paradoxical aggression. Contraindicated in substance use disorders, respiratory insufficiency, pregnancy.
Specific phobias: CBT (desensitisation, flooding) is the mainstay. Medications generally NOT effective.
PTSD: Trauma-focused CBT or EMDR first-line. Pharmacotherapy is augmentation/second-line.
CBT mechanism: Targets cognitive distortions (catastrophising), safety behaviours (avoidance), and physiological arousal (relaxation). As effective as pharmacotherapy in panic disorder.
MAOIs: Last resort. Cheese reaction (tyramine → hypertensive crisis). Mandatory 2-week SSRI washout. Serotonin syndrome risk.
High Yield Summary
Most important complication: Comorbid depression — affects up to 60–70% of GAD patients over lifetime; associated with ↑severity, ↑duration, ↑functional impairment, and ↑suicide risk.
Cardiovascular mortality: Independently elevated in both GAD and panic disorder. Mechanism: chronic sympathetic activation + cortisol-driven metabolic syndrome + inflammation + platelet hyperreactivity.
Substance misuse: Self-medication with alcohol and benzodiazepines is extremely common; creates a vicious cycle of tolerance → withdrawal anxiety → escalating use.
Panic → Agoraphobia: The classic progression — avoidance of panic-associated situations progressively restricts the patient's world.
Prognosis of GAD: Only 60% recover after 12 years; 50% of those relapse. Associated with ↑CVS mortality and functional impairment.
Iatrogenic: BZD dependence and unnecessary investigations/procedures are significant preventable complications.
Childhood: 1/3 develop other anxiety disorders at follow-up; selective mutism has 58% remission at 13 years.
Abdominal Pain
Abdominal pain is a symptom of discomfort felt between the chest and pelvis, arising from visceral, parietal, or referred mechanisms, that signals a wide range of gastrointestinal, genitourinary, vascular, or systemic conditions.
Chest Pain
Chest pain is a symptom of discomfort or distress in the thoracic region that may originate from cardiac, pulmonary, gastrointestinal, musculoskeletal, or psychogenic causes, requiring prompt evaluation to exclude life-threatening conditions.